161_a_law_h15a119 
 
(1) Where a business operator handling personal information is requested by a person to discontinue using or to erase such retained personal data as may lead to the identification of the person on the ground that the retained personal data is being handled in violation of Article 16 or has been acquired in violation of Article 17, and where it is found that the request has a reason, the business operator shall discontinue using or erase the retained personal data concerned without delay to the extent necessary for redressing the violation.
 
 
 
0161_0004__Where 
 
where 
 
0161_0011__is 
 
is 
 
0161_0004__Where->0161_0011__is 
 
 
[restriction] 
 
0161_0062__where 
 
where 
 
0161_0004__Where->0161_0062__where 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0012__requested 
 
requested 
 
0161_0011__is->0161_0012__requested 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0064__is 
 
is 
 
0161_0062__where->0161_0064__is 
 
 
[restriction] 
 
0161_0076__shall 
 
shall 
 
0161_0062__where->0161_0076__shall 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0008__handling 
 
handling 
 
0161_0005__a_0161_0006__business_0161_0007__operator 
 
a_business_operator 
 
0161_0008__handling->0161_0005__a_0161_0006__business_0161_0007__operator 
 
 
[inv][arg0] 
 
0161_0010__information 
 
information 
 
0161_0008__handling->0161_0010__information 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0009__personal 
 
personal 
 
0161_0010__information->0161_0009__personal 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0012__requested->0161_0005__a_0161_0006__business_0161_0007__operator 
 
 
[arg2] 
 
0161_0014__a_0161_0015__person 
 
a_person 
 
0161_0012__requested->0161_0014__a_0161_0015__person 
 
 
by[arg0] 
 
0161_0019__or 
 
or 
 
0161_0012__requested->0161_0019__or 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0036__the_0161_0037__ground 
 
the_ground 
 
0161_0012__requested->0161_0036__the_0161_0037__ground 
 
 
on[nim] 
 
0161_0017__discontinue 
 
discontinue 
 
0161_0019__or->0161_0017__discontinue 
 
 
[conj1] 
 
0161_0021__erase 
 
erase 
 
0161_0019__or->0161_0021__erase 
 
 
[conj2] 
 
0161_0051__or 
 
or 
 
0161_0036__the_0161_0037__ground->0161_0051__or 
 
 
[emb] 
 
0161_0017__discontinue->0161_0005__a_0161_0006__business_0161_0007__operator 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0018__using 
 
using 
 
0161_0017__discontinue->0161_0018__using 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0025__data 
 
data 
 
0161_0018__using->0161_0025__data 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0022__such 
 
such 
 
0161_0025__data->0161_0022__such 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0023__retained 
 
retained 
 
0161_0025__data->0161_0023__retained 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0024__personal 
 
personal 
 
0161_0025__data->0161_0024__personal 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0021__erase->0161_0005__a_0161_0006__business_0161_0007__operator 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0021__erase->0161_0025__data 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0027__may 
 
may 
 
0161_0028__lead 
 
lead 
 
0161_0027__may->0161_0028__lead 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0028__lead->0161_0025__data 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0030__the_0161_0031__identification 
 
the_identification 
 
0161_0028__lead->0161_0030__the_0161_0031__identification 
 
 
to[clr] 
 
0161_0033__the_0161_0034__person 
 
the_person 
 
0161_0030__the_0161_0031__identification->0161_0033__the_0161_0034__person 
 
 
of 
 
0161_0043__is 
 
is 
 
0161_0051__or->0161_0043__is 
 
 
[conj1] 
 
0161_0052__has 
 
has 
 
0161_0051__or->0161_0052__has 
 
 
[conj2] 
 
0161_0039__the_0161_0042__data 
 
the_data 
 
0161_0040__retained 
 
retained 
 
0161_0039__the_0161_0042__data->0161_0040__retained 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0041__personal 
 
personal 
 
0161_0039__the_0161_0042__data->0161_0041__personal 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0044__being 
 
being 
 
0161_0043__is->0161_0044__being 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0045__handled 
 
handled 
 
0161_0044__being->0161_0045__handled 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0045__handled->0161_0039__the_0161_0042__data 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
staz_0161_5031 
 
* 
 
0161_0045__handled->staz_0161_5031 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0047__violation 
 
violation 
 
0161_0045__handled->0161_0047__violation 
 
 
in[nim] 
 
0161_0049__Article_0161_0050__16 
 
article_16 
 
0161_0047__violation->0161_0049__Article_0161_0050__16 
 
 
of 
 
0161_0053__been 
 
been 
 
0161_0052__has->0161_0053__been 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0054__acquired 
 
acquired 
 
0161_0053__been->0161_0054__acquired 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0054__acquired->0161_0039__the_0161_0042__data 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
staz_0161_5039 
 
* 
 
0161_0054__acquired->staz_0161_5039 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0056__violation 
 
violation 
 
0161_0054__acquired->0161_0056__violation 
 
 
in[nim] 
 
0161_0058__Article_0161_0059__17 
 
article_17 
 
0161_0056__violation->0161_0058__Article_0161_0059__17 
 
 
of 
 
0161_0065__found 
 
found 
 
0161_0064__is->0161_0065__found 
 
 
[scope] 
 
0161_0079__or 
 
or 
 
0161_0076__shall->0161_0079__or 
 
 
[scope] 
 
staz_0161_5054 
 
* 
 
0161_0065__found->staz_0161_5054 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0069__has 
 
has 
 
0161_0065__found->0161_0069__has 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0067__the_0161_0068__request 
 
the_request 
 
0161_0069__has->0161_0067__the_0161_0068__request 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0070__a_0161_0071__reason 
 
a_reason 
 
0161_0069__has->0161_0070__a_0161_0071__reason 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0077__discontinue 
 
discontinue 
 
0161_0079__or->0161_0077__discontinue 
 
 
[conj1] 
 
0161_0080__erase 
 
erase 
 
0161_0079__or->0161_0080__erase 
 
 
[conj2] 
 
0161_0073__the_0161_0074__business_0161_0075__operator 
 
the_business_operator 
 
0161_0077__discontinue->0161_0073__the_0161_0074__business_0161_0075__operator 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0078__using 
 
using 
 
0161_0077__discontinue->0161_0078__using 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0087__delay 
 
delay 
 
0161_0077__discontinue->0161_0087__delay 
 
 
without[nim] 
 
0161_0089__the_0161_0090__extent 
 
the_extent 
 
0161_0077__discontinue->0161_0089__the_0161_0090__extent 
 
 
to[nim] 
 
0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data 
 
the_data 
 
0161_0078__using->0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0091__necessary 
 
necessary 
 
0161_0089__the_0161_0090__extent->0161_0091__necessary 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0082__retained 
 
retained 
 
0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data->0161_0082__retained 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0083__personal 
 
personal 
 
0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data->0161_0083__personal 
 
 
[attrib] 
 
0161_0080__erase->0161_0073__the_0161_0074__business_0161_0075__operator 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
0161_0080__erase->0161_0087__delay 
 
 
without[nim] 
 
0161_0080__erase->0161_0089__the_0161_0090__extent 
 
 
to[nim] 
 
0161_0080__erase->0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
0161_0085__concerned 
 
concerned 
 
0161_0085__concerned->0161_0081__the_0161_0084__data 
 
 
[inv][arg0] 
 
0161_0093__redressing 
 
redressing 
 
0161_0091__necessary->0161_0093__redressing 
 
 
for 
 
0161_0094__the_0161_0095__violation 
 
the_violation 
 
0161_0093__redressing->0161_0094__the_0161_0095__violation 
 
 
[arg1] 
 
z_0161_5067 
 
_ 
 
0161_0093__redressing->z_0161_5067 
 
 
[arg0] 
 
 
 
 
arc(r_0161_0004__Where,r_0161_0011__is,restriction).
arc(r_0161_0004__Where,r_0161_0062__where,scope).
arc(r_0161_0008__handling,r_0161_0005__a_r_0161_0006__business_r_0161_0007__operator,inv_arg0).
arc(r_0161_0008__handling,r_0161_0010__information,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0010__information,r_0161_0009__personal,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0011__is,r_0161_0012__requested,scope).
arc(r_0161_0012__requested,r_0161_0005__a_r_0161_0006__business_r_0161_0007__operator,arg2).
arc(r_0161_0012__requested,r_0161_0014__a_r_0161_0015__person,r_0161_0013__by_arg0).
arc(r_0161_0012__requested,r_0161_0019__or,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0012__requested,r_0161_0036__the_r_0161_0037__ground,r_0161_0035__on__nim).
arc(r_0161_0017__discontinue,r_0161_0005__a_r_0161_0006__business_r_0161_0007__operator,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0017__discontinue,r_0161_0018__using,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0018__using,r_0161_0025__data,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0019__or,r_0161_0017__discontinue,conj1).
arc(r_0161_0019__or,r_0161_0021__erase,conj2).
arc(r_0161_0021__erase,r_0161_0005__a_r_0161_0006__business_r_0161_0007__operator,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0021__erase,r_0161_0025__data,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0025__data,r_0161_0022__such,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0025__data,r_0161_0023__retained,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0025__data,r_0161_0024__personal,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0027__may,r_0161_0028__lead,scope).
arc(r_0161_0028__lead,r_0161_0025__data,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0028__lead,r_0161_0030__the_r_0161_0031__identification,r_0161_0029__to__clr).
arc(r_0161_0030__the_r_0161_0031__identification,r_0161_0033__the_r_0161_0034__person,r_0161_0032__of).
arc(r_0161_0036__the_r_0161_0037__ground,r_0161_0051__or,emb).
arc(r_0161_0039__the_r_0161_0042__data,r_0161_0040__retained,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0039__the_r_0161_0042__data,r_0161_0041__personal,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0043__is,r_0161_0044__being,scope).
arc(r_0161_0044__being,r_0161_0045__handled,scope).
arc(r_0161_0045__handled,star_z_0161_5031,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0045__handled,r_0161_0039__the_r_0161_0042__data,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0045__handled,r_0161_0047__violation,r_0161_0046__in__nim).
arc(r_0161_0047__violation,r_0161_0049__Article_r_0161_0050__16,r_0161_0048__of).
arc(r_0161_0051__or,r_0161_0043__is,conj1).
arc(r_0161_0051__or,r_0161_0052__has,conj2).
arc(r_0161_0052__has,r_0161_0053__been,scope).
arc(r_0161_0053__been,r_0161_0054__acquired,scope).
arc(r_0161_0054__acquired,star_z_0161_5039,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0054__acquired,r_0161_0039__the_r_0161_0042__data,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0054__acquired,r_0161_0056__violation,r_0161_0055__in__nim).
arc(r_0161_0056__violation,r_0161_0058__Article_r_0161_0059__17,r_0161_0057__of).
arc(r_0161_0062__where,r_0161_0064__is,restriction).
arc(r_0161_0062__where,r_0161_0076__shall,scope).
arc(r_0161_0064__is,r_0161_0065__found,scope).
arc(r_0161_0065__found,star_z_0161_5054,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0065__found,r_0161_0069__has,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0069__has,r_0161_0067__the_r_0161_0068__request,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0069__has,r_0161_0070__a_r_0161_0071__reason,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0076__shall,r_0161_0079__or,scope).
arc(r_0161_0077__discontinue,r_0161_0073__the_r_0161_0074__business_r_0161_0075__operator,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0077__discontinue,r_0161_0078__using,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0077__discontinue,r_0161_0087__delay,r_0161_0086__without__nim).
arc(r_0161_0077__discontinue,r_0161_0089__the_r_0161_0090__extent,r_0161_0088__to__nim).
arc(r_0161_0078__using,r_0161_0081__the_r_0161_0084__data,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0079__or,r_0161_0077__discontinue,conj1).
arc(r_0161_0079__or,r_0161_0080__erase,conj2).
arc(r_0161_0080__erase,r_0161_0073__the_r_0161_0074__business_r_0161_0075__operator,arg0).
arc(r_0161_0080__erase,r_0161_0081__the_r_0161_0084__data,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0080__erase,r_0161_0087__delay,r_0161_0086__without__nim).
arc(r_0161_0080__erase,r_0161_0089__the_r_0161_0090__extent,r_0161_0088__to__nim).
arc(r_0161_0081__the_r_0161_0084__data,r_0161_0082__retained,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0081__the_r_0161_0084__data,r_0161_0083__personal,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0085__concerned,r_0161_0081__the_r_0161_0084__data,inv_arg0).
arc(r_0161_0089__the_r_0161_0090__extent,r_0161_0091__necessary,attrib).
arc(r_0161_0091__necessary,r_0161_0093__redressing,r_0161_0092__for).
arc(r_0161_0093__redressing,r_0161_0094__the_r_0161_0095__violation,arg1).
arc(r_0161_0093__redressing,z_0161_5067,arg0).
 
 
IP-MAT 
LST 
PULB 
-LRB- 
 
 
LS 
1 
 
 
PURB 
-RRB- 
 
 
 
PP-SCON 
P-CONN 
Where 
 
 
IP-ADV 
NP-SBJ 
D 
a 
 
 
N 
business 
 
 
N 
operator 
 
 
IP-PPL 
VAG;~Tn 
handling 
 
 
NP-OB1 
ADJP 
ADJ 
personal 
 
 
 
N 
information 
 
 
 
 
 
BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ 
is 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
VVN 
requested 
 
 
PP-LGS 
P-ROLE;_lgs_ 
by 
 
 
NP 
D 
a 
 
 
N 
person 
 
 
 
 
IP-INF-OB1 
ILYR 
ILYR 
TO 
to 
 
 
VB 
discontinue 
 
 
IP-PPL-OB1 
VAG 
using 
 
 
 
 
CONJP 
CONJ 
or 
 
 
ILYR 
TO 
to 
 
 
VB 
erase 
 
 
 
 
 
NP-OB1 
ADJP 
ADJ;_such_ 
such 
 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
retained 
 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
personal 
 
 
 
NS 
data 
 
 
IP-REL 
NP-SBJ 
RPRO 
as 
 
 
 
MD;~cat_Vi 
may 
 
 
IP-INF-CAT 
VB 
lead 
 
 
PP-CLR 
P-ROLE 
to 
 
 
NP 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
identification 
 
 
PP 
P-ROLE 
of 
 
 
NP 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
person 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
PP-NIM 
P-ROLE 
on 
 
 
NP 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
ground 
 
 
CP-THT 
IP-SUB 
C 
that 
 
 
NP-SBJ 
D 
the 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
retained 
 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
personal 
 
 
 
N 
data 
 
 
 
ILYR 
ILYR 
BEP;~cat_Vg 
is 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
BAG;~cat_Ve_passive_ 
being 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
NP-LGS 
* 
 
 
VVN;~Tn 
handled 
 
 
PP-NIM 
P-ROLE 
in 
 
 
NP 
N 
violation 
 
 
PP 
P-ROLE 
of 
 
 
NP 
N 
Article 
 
 
NUM 
16 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
CONJP 
CONJ 
or 
 
 
ILYR 
HVP;~cat_Ve 
has 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
BEN;~cat_Ve_passive_ 
been 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
NP-LGS 
* 
 
 
VVN;~Tn 
acquired 
 
 
PP-NIM 
P-ROLE 
in 
 
 
NP 
N 
violation 
 
 
PP 
P-ROLE 
of 
 
 
NP 
N 
Article 
 
 
NUM 
17 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
PUNC 
, 
 
 
ILYR 
CONJ;_cl_ 
and 
 
 
PP-SCON 
P-CONN 
where 
 
 
IP-ADV 
NP-SBJ 
PRO;_provisional_ 
it 
 
 
 
BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ 
is 
 
 
IP-PPL-CAT 
NP-LGS 
* 
 
 
VVN 
found 
 
 
CP-THT-NSBJ 
IP-SUB 
C 
that 
 
 
NP-SBJ 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
request 
 
 
 
HVP;~Tn 
has 
 
 
NP-OB1 
D 
a 
 
 
N 
reason 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
PUNC 
, 
 
 
NP-SBJ 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
business 
 
 
N 
operator 
 
 
 
MD;~cat_Vi 
shall 
 
 
IP-INF-CAT 
ILYR 
ILYR 
VB 
discontinue 
 
 
IP-PPL-OB1 
VAG 
using 
 
 
 
 
CONJP 
CONJ 
or 
 
 
ILYR 
VB 
erase 
 
 
 
 
 
NP-OB1 
D 
the 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
retained 
 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
personal 
 
 
 
NS 
data 
 
 
IP-PPL 
VVN 
concerned 
 
 
 
 
PP-NIM 
P-ROLE 
without 
 
 
NP 
N 
delay 
 
 
 
 
PP-NIM 
P-ROLE 
to 
 
 
NP 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
extent 
 
 
ADJP 
ADJ 
necessary 
 
 
PP 
P-ROLE 
for 
 
 
IP-PPL 
VAG 
redressing 
 
 
NP-OB1 
D 
the 
 
 
N 
violation 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
PUNC 
. 
 
 
 
 
( (IP-MAT (LST (PULB -LRB-)
               (LS 1)
               (PURB -RRB-))
          (PP-SCON (P-CONN Where;{where})
                   (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ (D a;{a})
                                   (N business;{business})
                                   (N operator;{operator})
                                   (IP-PPL (VAG;~Tn handling;{handle})
                                           (NP-OB1 (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                                   (N information;{information}))))
                           (BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ is;{be})
                           (IP-PPL-CAT (VVN requested;{request})
                                       (PP-LGS (P-ROLE;_lgs_ by;{by})
                                               (NP (D a;{a})
                                                   (N person;{person})))
                                       (IP-INF-OB1 (ILYR (ILYR (TO to;{to})
                                                               (VB discontinue;{discontinue})
                                                               (IP-PPL-OB1 (VAG using;{use})))
                                                         (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                                (ILYR (TO to;{to})
                                                                      (VB erase;{erase}))))
                                                   (NP-OB1 (ADJP (ADJ;_such_ such;{such}))
                                                           (ADJP (ADJ retained;{retained}))
                                                           (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                                           (NS data;{data})
                                                           (IP-REL (NP-SBJ (RPRO as;{as}))
                                                                   (MD;~cat_Vi may;{may})
                                                                   (IP-INF-CAT (VB lead;{lead})
                                                                               (PP-CLR (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                                                       (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                           (N identification;{identification})
                                                                                           (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                   (N person;{person})))))))))
                                       (PP-NIM (P-ROLE on;{on})
                                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                                   (N ground;{ground})
                                                   (CP-THT (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                                                   (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                           (ADJP (ADJ retained;{retained}))
                                                                           (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                                                           (N data;{data}))
                                                                   (ILYR (ILYR (BEP;~cat_Vg is;{be})
                                                                               (IP-PPL-CAT (BAG;~cat_Ve_passive_ being;{be})
                                                                                           (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                                       (VVN;~Tn handled;{handle})
                                                                                                       (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                               (NP (N violation;{violation})
                                                                                                                   (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                                                       (NP (N Article;{article})
                                                                                                                           (NUM 16))))))))
                                                                         (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                                                (ILYR (HVP;~cat_Ve has;{have})
                                                                                      (IP-PPL-CAT (BEN;~cat_Ve_passive_ been;{be})
                                                                                                  (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                                              (VVN;~Tn acquired;{acquire})
                                                                                                              (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                                      (NP (N violation;{violation})
                                                                                                                          (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                                                              (NP (N Article;{article})
                                                                                                                                  (NUM 17)))))))))))))))))
          (PUNC ,)
          (ILYR (CONJ;_cl_ and;{and})
                (PP-SCON (P-CONN where;{where})
                         (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                                 (BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ is;{be})
                                 (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                             (VVN found;{find})
                                             (CP-THT-NSBJ (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                                                  (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                          (N request;{request}))
                                                                  (HVP;~Tn has;{have})
                                                                  (NP-OB1 (D a;{a})
                                                                          (N reason;{reason})))))))
                (PUNC ,)
                (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                        (N business;{business})
                        (N operator;{operator}))
                (MD;~cat_Vi shall;{shall})
                (IP-INF-CAT (ILYR (ILYR (VB discontinue;{discontinue})
                                        (IP-PPL-OB1 (VAG using;{use})))
                                  (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                         (ILYR (VB erase;{erase}))))
                            (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                    (ADJP (ADJ retained;{retained}))
                                    (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                    (NS data;{data})
                                    (IP-PPL (VVN concerned;{concern})))
                            (PP-NIM (P-ROLE without;{without})
                                    (NP (N delay;{delay})))
                            (PP-NIM (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                    (NP (D the;{the})
                                        (N extent;{extent})
                                        (ADJP (ADJ necessary;{necessary})
                                              (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                  (IP-PPL (VAG redressing;{redress})
                                                          (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                                  (N violation;{violation})))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 161_a_law_h15a119;130_4_27_1))