173_a_law_h15a119
(2) A business operator handling personal information may request a person making a request for disclosure and others to show sufficient items to identify the retained personal data in question.

%3 r_0173_0007__handling handling r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator A business operator r_0173_0007__handling->r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator [arg0] r_0173_0009__information information r_0173_0007__handling->r_0173_0009__information [arg1] r_0173_0008__personal personal r_0173_0009__information->r_0173_0008__personal [attrib] r_0173_0010__may may r_0173_0011__request request r_0173_0010__may->r_0173_0011__request [scope] r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator [arg0] r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person a person r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg2] r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show to show r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show [arg1] r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg0] r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify to identify r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show->r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify [arg1] r_0173_0014__making making r_0173_0014__making->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg0] r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request a request r_0173_0014__making->r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request [arg1] r_0173_0019__and and r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request->r_0173_0019__and for r_0173_0018__disclosure disclosure r_0173_0019__and->r_0173_0018__disclosure [conj1] r_0173_0020__others others r_0173_0019__and->r_0173_0020__others [conj2] r_0173_0024__items items r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify->r_0173_0024__items [arg0] r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data the data r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify->r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data [arg1] r_0173_0023__sufficient sufficient r_0173_0024__items->r_0173_0023__sufficient [attrib] r_0173_0028__retained retained r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0028__retained [attrib] r_0173_0029__personal personal r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0029__personal [attrib] r_0173_0032__question question r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0032__question in
arc(r_0173_0007__handling, r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator, arg0).
arc(r_0173_0007__handling, r_0173_0009__information, arg1).
arc(r_0173_0009__information, r_0173_0008__personal, attrib20).
arc(r_0173_0010__may, r_0173_0011__request, scope).
arc(r_0173_0011__request, r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator, arg0).
arc(r_0173_0011__request, r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person, arg2).
arc(r_0173_0011__request, r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show, arg1).
arc(r_0173_0014__making, r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person, arg0).
arc(r_0173_0014__making, r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request, arg1).
arc(r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request, r_0173_0019__and, r_0173_0017__for).
arc(r_0173_0019__and, r_0173_0018__disclosure, conj1).
arc(r_0173_0019__and, r_0173_0020__others, conj2).
arc(r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show, r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person, arg0).
arc(r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show, r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify, arg1).
arc(r_0173_0024__items, r_0173_0023__sufficient, attrib63).
arc(r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify, r_0173_0024__items, arg0).
arc(r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify, r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data, arg1).
arc(r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data, r_0173_0028__retained, attrib76).
arc(r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data, r_0173_0029__personal, attrib79).
arc(r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data, r_0173_0032__question, r_0173_0031__in).



%3 r_0173_0007__handling handling r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator A business operator r_0173_0007__handling->r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator [arg0] r_0173_0009__information information r_0173_0007__handling->r_0173_0009__information [arg1] r_0173_0008__personal personal r_0173_0009__information->r_0173_0008__personal [attrib] r_0173_0010__may_r_0173_0011__request may request r_0173_0010__may_r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0004__A_r_0173_0005__business_r_0173_0006__operator [arg0] r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person a person r_0173_0010__may_r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg2] r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show to show r_0173_0010__may_r_0173_0011__request->r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show [arg1] r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg0] r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify to identify r_0173_0021__to_r_0173_0022__show->r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify [arg1] r_0173_0014__making making r_0173_0014__making->r_0173_0012__a_r_0173_0013__person [arg0] r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request a request r_0173_0014__making->r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request [arg1] r_0173_0019__and and r_0173_0015__a_r_0173_0016__request->r_0173_0019__and for r_0173_0018__disclosure disclosure r_0173_0019__and->r_0173_0018__disclosure [conj1] r_0173_0020__others others r_0173_0019__and->r_0173_0020__others [conj2] r_0173_0024__items items r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify->r_0173_0024__items [arg0] r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data the data r_0173_0025__to_r_0173_0026__identify->r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data [arg1] r_0173_0023__sufficient sufficient r_0173_0024__items->r_0173_0023__sufficient [attrib] r_0173_0028__retained retained r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0028__retained [attrib] r_0173_0029__personal personal r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0029__personal [attrib] r_0173_0032__question question r_0173_0027__the_r_0173_0030__data->r_0173_0032__question in
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_173_7_HANDLING,R_173_9_INFORMATION,R_173_8_PERSONAL,R_173_10_MAY_REQUEST,R_173_4_A_BUSINESS_OPERATOR,R_173_21_TO_SHOW,R_173_25_TO_IDENTIFY,R_173_24_ITEMS,R_173_23_SUFFICIENT,R_173_27_THE_DATA,R_173_28_RETAINED,R_173_29_PERSONAL,R_173_32_QUESTION,R_173_14_MAKING,R_173_12_A_PERSON,R_173_15_A_REQUEST,R_173_19_AND,R_173_18_DISCLOSURE,R_173_20_OTHERS] :
      ( personal(R_173_8_PERSONAL)
      & a_business_operator(R_173_4_A_BUSINESS_OPERATOR)
      & sufficient(R_173_23_SUFFICIENT)
      & retained(R_173_28_RETAINED)
      & personal(R_173_29_PERSONAL)
      & question(R_173_32_QUESTION)
      & a_person(R_173_12_A_PERSON)
      & disclosure(R_173_18_DISCLOSURE)
      & others(R_173_20_OTHERS)
      & handling(R_173_7_HANDLING,R_173_4_A_BUSINESS_OPERATOR,R_173_9_INFORMATION)
      & information(R_173_9_INFORMATION)
      & attrib20(R_173_9_INFORMATION,R_173_8_PERSONAL)
      & may_request(R_173_10_MAY_REQUEST,R_173_4_A_BUSINESS_OPERATOR,R_173_21_TO_SHOW,R_173_12_A_PERSON)
      & to_show(R_173_21_TO_SHOW,R_173_12_A_PERSON,R_173_25_TO_IDENTIFY)
      & to_identify(R_173_25_TO_IDENTIFY,R_173_24_ITEMS,R_173_27_THE_DATA)
      & items(R_173_24_ITEMS)
      & attrib63(R_173_24_ITEMS,R_173_23_SUFFICIENT)
      & the_data(R_173_27_THE_DATA)
      & attrib76(R_173_27_THE_DATA,R_173_28_RETAINED)
      & attrib79(R_173_27_THE_DATA,R_173_29_PERSONAL)
      & in(R_173_27_THE_DATA,R_173_32_QUESTION)
      & making(R_173_14_MAKING,R_173_12_A_PERSON,R_173_15_A_REQUEST)
      & a_request(R_173_15_A_REQUEST)
      & for(R_173_15_A_REQUEST,R_173_19_AND)
      & and(R_173_19_AND)
      & conj1(R_173_19_AND,R_173_18_DISCLOSURE)
      & conj2(R_173_19_AND,R_173_20_OTHERS) ) ).



n173_a_law_h15a119 n173_a_law_h15a119_4 -LRB- n173_a_law_h15a119_6 2 n173_a_law_h15a119_8 -RRB- n173_a_law_h15a119_11 A n173_a_law_h15a119_13 business n173_a_law_h15a119_15 operator n173_a_law_h15a119_18 handling n173_a_law_h15a119_22 personal n173_a_law_h15a119_24 information n173_a_law_h15a119_26 may n173_a_law_h15a119_29 request n173_a_law_h15a119_32 a n173_a_law_h15a119_34 person n173_a_law_h15a119_37 making n173_a_law_h15a119_40 a n173_a_law_h15a119_42 request n173_a_law_h15a119_45 for n173_a_law_h15a119_50 disclosure n173_a_law_h15a119_53 and n173_a_law_h15a119_56 others n173_a_law_h15a119_59 to n173_a_law_h15a119_61 show n173_a_law_h15a119_65 sufficient n173_a_law_h15a119_67 items n173_a_law_h15a119_70 to n173_a_law_h15a119_72 identify n173_a_law_h15a119_75 the n173_a_law_h15a119_78 retained n173_a_law_h15a119_81 personal n173_a_law_h15a119_83 data n173_a_law_h15a119_86 in n173_a_law_h15a119_89 question n173_a_law_h15a119_91 . n173_a_law_h15a119_1 IP-MAT n173_a_law_h15a119_2 LST n173_a_law_h15a119_1->n173_a_law_h15a119_2 n173_a_law_h15a119_9 NP-SBJ n173_a_law_h15a119_1->n173_a_law_h15a119_9 n173_a_law_h15a119_25 MD;_cat_Vi_ n173_a_law_h15a119_1->n173_a_law_h15a119_25 n173_a_law_h15a119_27 IP-INF-CAT n173_a_law_h15a119_1->n173_a_law_h15a119_27 n173_a_law_h15a119_90 PUNC n173_a_law_h15a119_1->n173_a_law_h15a119_90 n173_a_law_h15a119_3 PULB n173_a_law_h15a119_2->n173_a_law_h15a119_3 n173_a_law_h15a119_5 LS n173_a_law_h15a119_2->n173_a_law_h15a119_5 n173_a_law_h15a119_7 PURB n173_a_law_h15a119_2->n173_a_law_h15a119_7 n173_a_law_h15a119_3->n173_a_law_h15a119_4 n173_a_law_h15a119_5->n173_a_law_h15a119_6 n173_a_law_h15a119_7->n173_a_law_h15a119_8 n173_a_law_h15a119_10 D n173_a_law_h15a119_9->n173_a_law_h15a119_10 n173_a_law_h15a119_12 N n173_a_law_h15a119_9->n173_a_law_h15a119_12 n173_a_law_h15a119_14 N n173_a_law_h15a119_9->n173_a_law_h15a119_14 n173_a_law_h15a119_16 IP-PPL n173_a_law_h15a119_9->n173_a_law_h15a119_16 n173_a_law_h15a119_10->n173_a_law_h15a119_11 n173_a_law_h15a119_12->n173_a_law_h15a119_13 n173_a_law_h15a119_14->n173_a_law_h15a119_15 n173_a_law_h15a119_17 VAG;_Tn_ n173_a_law_h15a119_16->n173_a_law_h15a119_17 n173_a_law_h15a119_19 NP-OB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_16->n173_a_law_h15a119_19 n173_a_law_h15a119_17->n173_a_law_h15a119_18 n173_a_law_h15a119_20 ADJP n173_a_law_h15a119_19->n173_a_law_h15a119_20 n173_a_law_h15a119_23 N n173_a_law_h15a119_19->n173_a_law_h15a119_23 n173_a_law_h15a119_21 ADJ n173_a_law_h15a119_20->n173_a_law_h15a119_21 n173_a_law_h15a119_21->n173_a_law_h15a119_22 n173_a_law_h15a119_23->n173_a_law_h15a119_24 n173_a_law_h15a119_25->n173_a_law_h15a119_26 n173_a_law_h15a119_28 VB;_Dn.t_ n173_a_law_h15a119_27->n173_a_law_h15a119_28 n173_a_law_h15a119_30 NP-OB2 n173_a_law_h15a119_27->n173_a_law_h15a119_30 n173_a_law_h15a119_57 IP-INF-OB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_27->n173_a_law_h15a119_57 n173_a_law_h15a119_28->n173_a_law_h15a119_29 n173_a_law_h15a119_31 D n173_a_law_h15a119_30->n173_a_law_h15a119_31 n173_a_law_h15a119_33 N n173_a_law_h15a119_30->n173_a_law_h15a119_33 n173_a_law_h15a119_35 IP-PPL n173_a_law_h15a119_30->n173_a_law_h15a119_35 n173_a_law_h15a119_31->n173_a_law_h15a119_32 n173_a_law_h15a119_33->n173_a_law_h15a119_34 n173_a_law_h15a119_36 VAG;_Tn_ n173_a_law_h15a119_35->n173_a_law_h15a119_36 n173_a_law_h15a119_38 NP-OB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_35->n173_a_law_h15a119_38 n173_a_law_h15a119_36->n173_a_law_h15a119_37 n173_a_law_h15a119_39 D n173_a_law_h15a119_38->n173_a_law_h15a119_39 n173_a_law_h15a119_41 N n173_a_law_h15a119_38->n173_a_law_h15a119_41 n173_a_law_h15a119_43 PP n173_a_law_h15a119_38->n173_a_law_h15a119_43 n173_a_law_h15a119_39->n173_a_law_h15a119_40 n173_a_law_h15a119_41->n173_a_law_h15a119_42 n173_a_law_h15a119_44 P-ROLE n173_a_law_h15a119_43->n173_a_law_h15a119_44 n173_a_law_h15a119_46 NP n173_a_law_h15a119_43->n173_a_law_h15a119_46 n173_a_law_h15a119_44->n173_a_law_h15a119_45 n173_a_law_h15a119_47 NLYR n173_a_law_h15a119_46->n173_a_law_h15a119_47 n173_a_law_h15a119_48 NLYR n173_a_law_h15a119_47->n173_a_law_h15a119_48 n173_a_law_h15a119_51 CONJP n173_a_law_h15a119_47->n173_a_law_h15a119_51 n173_a_law_h15a119_49 N n173_a_law_h15a119_48->n173_a_law_h15a119_49 n173_a_law_h15a119_49->n173_a_law_h15a119_50 n173_a_law_h15a119_52 CONJ n173_a_law_h15a119_51->n173_a_law_h15a119_52 n173_a_law_h15a119_54 NLYR n173_a_law_h15a119_51->n173_a_law_h15a119_54 n173_a_law_h15a119_52->n173_a_law_h15a119_53 n173_a_law_h15a119_55 NS n173_a_law_h15a119_54->n173_a_law_h15a119_55 n173_a_law_h15a119_55->n173_a_law_h15a119_56 n173_a_law_h15a119_58 TO n173_a_law_h15a119_57->n173_a_law_h15a119_58 n173_a_law_h15a119_60 VB;_Tnt_ n173_a_law_h15a119_57->n173_a_law_h15a119_60 n173_a_law_h15a119_62 NP-DOB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_57->n173_a_law_h15a119_62 n173_a_law_h15a119_68 IP-INF-OB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_57->n173_a_law_h15a119_68 n173_a_law_h15a119_58->n173_a_law_h15a119_59 n173_a_law_h15a119_60->n173_a_law_h15a119_61 n173_a_law_h15a119_63 ADJP n173_a_law_h15a119_62->n173_a_law_h15a119_63 n173_a_law_h15a119_66 NS n173_a_law_h15a119_62->n173_a_law_h15a119_66 n173_a_law_h15a119_64 ADJ n173_a_law_h15a119_63->n173_a_law_h15a119_64 n173_a_law_h15a119_64->n173_a_law_h15a119_65 n173_a_law_h15a119_66->n173_a_law_h15a119_67 n173_a_law_h15a119_69 TO n173_a_law_h15a119_68->n173_a_law_h15a119_69 n173_a_law_h15a119_71 VB;_Tn_ n173_a_law_h15a119_68->n173_a_law_h15a119_71 n173_a_law_h15a119_73 NP-OB1 n173_a_law_h15a119_68->n173_a_law_h15a119_73 n173_a_law_h15a119_69->n173_a_law_h15a119_70 n173_a_law_h15a119_71->n173_a_law_h15a119_72 n173_a_law_h15a119_74 D n173_a_law_h15a119_73->n173_a_law_h15a119_74 n173_a_law_h15a119_76 ADJP n173_a_law_h15a119_73->n173_a_law_h15a119_76 n173_a_law_h15a119_79 ADJP n173_a_law_h15a119_73->n173_a_law_h15a119_79 n173_a_law_h15a119_82 NS n173_a_law_h15a119_73->n173_a_law_h15a119_82 n173_a_law_h15a119_84 PP n173_a_law_h15a119_73->n173_a_law_h15a119_84 n173_a_law_h15a119_74->n173_a_law_h15a119_75 n173_a_law_h15a119_77 ADJ n173_a_law_h15a119_76->n173_a_law_h15a119_77 n173_a_law_h15a119_77->n173_a_law_h15a119_78 n173_a_law_h15a119_80 ADJ n173_a_law_h15a119_79->n173_a_law_h15a119_80 n173_a_law_h15a119_80->n173_a_law_h15a119_81 n173_a_law_h15a119_82->n173_a_law_h15a119_83 n173_a_law_h15a119_85 P-ROLE n173_a_law_h15a119_84->n173_a_law_h15a119_85 n173_a_law_h15a119_87 NP n173_a_law_h15a119_84->n173_a_law_h15a119_87 n173_a_law_h15a119_85->n173_a_law_h15a119_86 n173_a_law_h15a119_88 N n173_a_law_h15a119_87->n173_a_law_h15a119_88 n173_a_law_h15a119_88->n173_a_law_h15a119_89 n173_a_law_h15a119_90->n173_a_law_h15a119_91
( (IP-MAT (LST (PULB -LRB-)
               (LS 2)
               (PURB -RRB-))
          (NP-SBJ (D A;{a})
                  (N business;{business})
                  (N operator;{operator})
                  (IP-PPL (VAG;_Tn_ handling;{handle})
                          (NP-OB1 (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                  (N information;{information}))))
          (MD;_cat_Vi_ may;{may})
          (IP-INF-CAT (VB;_Dn.t_ request;{request})
                      (NP-OB2 (D a;{a})
                              (N person;{person})
                              (IP-PPL (VAG;_Tn_ making;{make})
                                      (NP-OB1 (D a;{a})
                                              (N request;{request})
                                              (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                  (NP (NLYR (NLYR (N disclosure;{disclosure}))
                                                            (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                                                   (NLYR (NS others;{other})))))))))
                      (IP-INF-OB1 (TO to;{to})
                                  (VB;_Tnt_ show;{show})
                                  (NP-DOB1 (ADJP (ADJ sufficient;{sufficient}))
                                           (NS items;{item}))
                                  (IP-INF-OB1 (TO to;{to})
                                              (VB;_Tn_ identify;{identify})
                                              (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                      (ADJP (ADJ retained;{retained}))
                                                      (ADJP (ADJ personal;{personal}))
                                                      (NS data;{data})
                                                      (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                          (NP (N question;{question})))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 173_a_law_h15a119;137_4_29_2))