Context                Previous, Next                Top


14_a_major_case
15. Since then, the absence of proper witness evidence in these proceedings, and the issue of compliance with the duty of candour more generally, has been raised with the Prime Minister and other members of the Cabinet on several occasions.

%3 r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence the absence r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence witness evidence r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence->r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence of r_0014_0008__proper proper r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence->r_0014_0008__proper [attrib] r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings these proceedings r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence->r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings in r_0014_0015__and and r_0014_0015__and->r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence [conj1] r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue the issue r_0014_0015__and->r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue [conj2] r_0014_0019__compliance compliance r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue->r_0014_0019__compliance of r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty the duty r_0014_0019__compliance->r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty with r_0014_0024__candour candour r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty->r_0014_0024__candour of r_0014_0026__generally generally r_0014_0024__candour->r_0014_0026__generally [qual] r_0014_0025__more more r_0014_0026__generally->r_0014_0025__more [qual] r_0014_0028__has has r_0014_0003__then then r_0014_0028__has->r_0014_0003__then Since [nim] r_0014_0029__been been r_0014_0028__has->r_0014_0029__been [scope] r_0014_0030__raised raised r_0014_0029__been->r_0014_0030__raised [scope] r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0015__and [arg1] r_0014_0035__and and r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0035__and with [nim] r_0014_0043__occasions occasions r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0043__occasions on [nim] z_000_14_a_major_case_83 r_0014_0030__raised->z_000_14_a_major_case_83 [arg0] r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister the Prime Minister r_0014_0035__and->r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister [conj1] r_0014_0037__members members r_0014_0035__and->r_0014_0037__members [conj2] r_0014_0042__several several r_0014_0043__occasions->r_0014_0042__several [attrib] r_0014_0036__other other r_0014_0037__members->r_0014_0036__other [attrib] r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet the Cabinet r_0014_0037__members->r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet of 
arc(r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence, r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence, r_0014_0007__of).
arc(r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence, r_0014_0008__proper, attrib24).
arc(r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence, r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings, r_0014_0011__in).
arc(r_0014_0015__and, r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence, conj1).
arc(r_0014_0015__and, r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue, conj2).
arc(r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue, r_0014_0019__compliance, r_0014_0018__of).
arc(r_0014_0019__compliance, r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty, r_0014_0020__with).
arc(r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty, r_0014_0024__candour, r_0014_0023__of).
arc(r_0014_0024__candour, r_0014_0026__generally, qual69).
arc(r_0014_0026__generally, r_0014_0025__more, qual70).
arc(r_0014_0028__has, r_0014_0003__then, r_0014_0002__Since_nim8).
arc(r_0014_0028__has, r_0014_0029__been, scope).
arc(r_0014_0029__been, r_0014_0030__raised, scope).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised, r_0014_0015__and, arg1).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised, r_0014_0035__and, r_0014_0031__with_nim90).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised, r_0014_0043__occasions, r_0014_0041__on_nim119).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised, z_000_14_a_major_case_83, arg0).
arc(r_0014_0035__and, r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister, conj1).
arc(r_0014_0035__and, r_0014_0037__members, conj2).
arc(r_0014_0037__members, r_0014_0036__other, attrib103).
arc(r_0014_0037__members, r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet, r_0014_0038__of).
arc(r_0014_0043__occasions, r_0014_0042__several, attrib120).


%3 r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence the absence r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence witness evidence r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence->r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence of r_0014_0008__proper proper r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence->r_0014_0008__proper [attrib] r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings these proceedings r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence->r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings in r_0014_0015__and and r_0014_0015__and->r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence [conj1] r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue the issue r_0014_0015__and->r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue [conj2] r_0014_0019__compliance compliance r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue->r_0014_0019__compliance of r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty the duty r_0014_0019__compliance->r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty with r_0014_0024__candour candour r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty->r_0014_0024__candour of r_0014_0026__generally generally r_0014_0024__candour->r_0014_0026__generally [qual] r_0014_0025__more more r_0014_0026__generally->r_0014_0025__more [qual] r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised has been raised r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0015__and [arg1] r_0014_0003__then then r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0003__then Since [nim] r_0014_0035__and and r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0035__and with [nim] r_0014_0043__occasions occasions r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised->r_0014_0043__occasions on [nim] z_000_14_a_major_case_83 r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised->z_000_14_a_major_case_83 [arg0] r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister the Prime Minister r_0014_0035__and->r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister [conj1] r_0014_0037__members members r_0014_0035__and->r_0014_0037__members [conj2] r_0014_0042__several several r_0014_0043__occasions->r_0014_0042__several [attrib] r_0014_0036__other other r_0014_0037__members->r_0014_0036__other [attrib] r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet the Cabinet r_0014_0037__members->r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet of 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_14_28_HAS_BEEN_RAISED,Z_14_A_MAJOR_CASE_83,R_14_15_AND,R_14_5_THE_ABSENCE,R_14_9_WITNESS_EVIDENCE,R_14_8_PROPER,R_14_12_THESE_PROCEEDINGS,R_14_16_THE_ISSUE,R_14_19_COMPLIANCE,R_14_21_THE_DUTY,R_14_24_CANDOUR,R_14_26_GENERALLY,R_14_25_MORE,R_14_3_THEN,R_14_35_AND,R_14_32_THE_PRIME_MINISTER,R_14_37_MEMBERS,R_14_36_OTHER,R_14_39_THE_CABINET,R_14_43_OCCASIONS,R_14_42_SEVERAL] :
      ( proper(R_14_8_PROPER)
      & these_proceedings(R_14_12_THESE_PROCEEDINGS)
      & more(R_14_25_MORE)
      & then(R_14_3_THEN)
      & the_Prime_Minister(R_14_32_THE_PRIME_MINISTER)
      & other(R_14_36_OTHER)
      & the_Cabinet(R_14_39_THE_CABINET)
      & several(R_14_42_SEVERAL)
      & has_been_raised(R_14_28_HAS_BEEN_RAISED,Z_14_A_MAJOR_CASE_83,R_14_15_AND)
      & and(R_14_15_AND)
      & conj1(R_14_15_AND,R_14_5_THE_ABSENCE)
      & the_absence(R_14_5_THE_ABSENCE)
      & of(R_14_5_THE_ABSENCE,R_14_9_WITNESS_EVIDENCE)
      & witness_evidence(R_14_9_WITNESS_EVIDENCE)
      & attrib24(R_14_9_WITNESS_EVIDENCE,R_14_8_PROPER)
      & in(R_14_9_WITNESS_EVIDENCE,R_14_12_THESE_PROCEEDINGS)
      & conj2(R_14_15_AND,R_14_16_THE_ISSUE)
      & the_issue(R_14_16_THE_ISSUE)
      & of(R_14_16_THE_ISSUE,R_14_19_COMPLIANCE)
      & compliance(R_14_19_COMPLIANCE)
      & with(R_14_19_COMPLIANCE,R_14_21_THE_DUTY)
      & the_duty(R_14_21_THE_DUTY)
      & of(R_14_21_THE_DUTY,R_14_24_CANDOUR)
      & candour(R_14_24_CANDOUR)
      & qual69(R_14_24_CANDOUR,R_14_26_GENERALLY)
      & generally(R_14_26_GENERALLY)
      & qual70(R_14_26_GENERALLY,R_14_25_MORE)
      & since_nim8(R_14_28_HAS_BEEN_RAISED,R_14_3_THEN)
      & with_nim90(R_14_28_HAS_BEEN_RAISED,R_14_35_AND)
      & and(R_14_35_AND)
      & conj1(R_14_35_AND,R_14_32_THE_PRIME_MINISTER)
      & conj2(R_14_35_AND,R_14_37_MEMBERS)
      & members(R_14_37_MEMBERS)
      & attrib103(R_14_37_MEMBERS,R_14_36_OTHER)
      & of(R_14_37_MEMBERS,R_14_39_THE_CABINET)
      & on_nim119(R_14_28_HAS_BEEN_RAISED,R_14_43_OCCASIONS)
      & occasions(R_14_43_OCCASIONS)
      & attrib120(R_14_43_OCCASIONS,R_14_42_SEVERAL) ) ).


n14_a_major_case n14_a_major_case_4 15. n14_a_major_case_7 Since n14_a_major_case_10 then n14_a_major_case_12 , n14_a_major_case_17 the n14_a_major_case_19 absence n14_a_major_case_22 of n14_a_major_case_26 proper n14_a_major_case_28 witness n14_a_major_case_30 evidence n14_a_major_case_33 in n14_a_major_case_36 these n14_a_major_case_38 proceedings n14_a_major_case_40 , n14_a_major_case_43 and n14_a_major_case_46 the n14_a_major_case_48 issue n14_a_major_case_51 of n14_a_major_case_54 compliance n14_a_major_case_57 with n14_a_major_case_60 the n14_a_major_case_62 duty n14_a_major_case_65 of n14_a_major_case_68 candour n14_a_major_case_72 more n14_a_major_case_74 generally n14_a_major_case_76 , n14_a_major_case_78 has n14_a_major_case_81 been n14_a_major_case_84 * n14_a_major_case_86 raised n14_a_major_case_89 with n14_a_major_case_94 the n14_a_major_case_96 Prime n14_a_major_case_98 Minister n14_a_major_case_101 and n14_a_major_case_105 other n14_a_major_case_107 members n14_a_major_case_110 of n14_a_major_case_113 the n14_a_major_case_115 Cabinet n14_a_major_case_118 on n14_a_major_case_122 several n14_a_major_case_124 occasions n14_a_major_case_126 . n14_a_major_case_1 IP-MAT n14_a_major_case_2 LST n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_2 n14_a_major_case_5 PP-NIM n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_5 n14_a_major_case_11 PUNC n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_11 n14_a_major_case_13 NP-SBJ n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_13 n14_a_major_case_75 PUNC n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_75 n14_a_major_case_77 HVP;_cat_Ve_ n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_77 n14_a_major_case_79 IP-PPL-CAT n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_79 n14_a_major_case_125 PUNC n14_a_major_case_1->n14_a_major_case_125 n14_a_major_case_3 LS n14_a_major_case_2->n14_a_major_case_3 n14_a_major_case_3->n14_a_major_case_4 n14_a_major_case_6 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_5->n14_a_major_case_6 n14_a_major_case_8 ADVP n14_a_major_case_5->n14_a_major_case_8 n14_a_major_case_6->n14_a_major_case_7 n14_a_major_case_9 ADV n14_a_major_case_8->n14_a_major_case_9 n14_a_major_case_9->n14_a_major_case_10 n14_a_major_case_11->n14_a_major_case_12 n14_a_major_case_14 NLYR n14_a_major_case_13->n14_a_major_case_14 n14_a_major_case_15 NLYR n14_a_major_case_14->n14_a_major_case_15 n14_a_major_case_39 PUNC n14_a_major_case_14->n14_a_major_case_39 n14_a_major_case_41 CONJP n14_a_major_case_14->n14_a_major_case_41 n14_a_major_case_16 D n14_a_major_case_15->n14_a_major_case_16 n14_a_major_case_18 N n14_a_major_case_15->n14_a_major_case_18 n14_a_major_case_20 PP n14_a_major_case_15->n14_a_major_case_20 n14_a_major_case_16->n14_a_major_case_17 n14_a_major_case_18->n14_a_major_case_19 n14_a_major_case_21 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_20->n14_a_major_case_21 n14_a_major_case_23 NP n14_a_major_case_20->n14_a_major_case_23 n14_a_major_case_21->n14_a_major_case_22 n14_a_major_case_24 ADJP n14_a_major_case_23->n14_a_major_case_24 n14_a_major_case_27 N n14_a_major_case_23->n14_a_major_case_27 n14_a_major_case_29 N n14_a_major_case_23->n14_a_major_case_29 n14_a_major_case_31 PP n14_a_major_case_23->n14_a_major_case_31 n14_a_major_case_25 ADJ n14_a_major_case_24->n14_a_major_case_25 n14_a_major_case_25->n14_a_major_case_26 n14_a_major_case_27->n14_a_major_case_28 n14_a_major_case_29->n14_a_major_case_30 n14_a_major_case_32 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_31->n14_a_major_case_32 n14_a_major_case_34 NP n14_a_major_case_31->n14_a_major_case_34 n14_a_major_case_32->n14_a_major_case_33 n14_a_major_case_35 D n14_a_major_case_34->n14_a_major_case_35 n14_a_major_case_37 NS n14_a_major_case_34->n14_a_major_case_37 n14_a_major_case_35->n14_a_major_case_36 n14_a_major_case_37->n14_a_major_case_38 n14_a_major_case_39->n14_a_major_case_40 n14_a_major_case_42 CONJ n14_a_major_case_41->n14_a_major_case_42 n14_a_major_case_44 NLYR n14_a_major_case_41->n14_a_major_case_44 n14_a_major_case_42->n14_a_major_case_43 n14_a_major_case_45 D n14_a_major_case_44->n14_a_major_case_45 n14_a_major_case_47 N n14_a_major_case_44->n14_a_major_case_47 n14_a_major_case_49 PP n14_a_major_case_44->n14_a_major_case_49 n14_a_major_case_45->n14_a_major_case_46 n14_a_major_case_47->n14_a_major_case_48 n14_a_major_case_50 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_49->n14_a_major_case_50 n14_a_major_case_52 NP n14_a_major_case_49->n14_a_major_case_52 n14_a_major_case_50->n14_a_major_case_51 n14_a_major_case_53 N n14_a_major_case_52->n14_a_major_case_53 n14_a_major_case_55 PP n14_a_major_case_52->n14_a_major_case_55 n14_a_major_case_53->n14_a_major_case_54 n14_a_major_case_56 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_55->n14_a_major_case_56 n14_a_major_case_58 NP n14_a_major_case_55->n14_a_major_case_58 n14_a_major_case_56->n14_a_major_case_57 n14_a_major_case_59 D n14_a_major_case_58->n14_a_major_case_59 n14_a_major_case_61 N n14_a_major_case_58->n14_a_major_case_61 n14_a_major_case_63 PP n14_a_major_case_58->n14_a_major_case_63 n14_a_major_case_59->n14_a_major_case_60 n14_a_major_case_61->n14_a_major_case_62 n14_a_major_case_64 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_63->n14_a_major_case_64 n14_a_major_case_66 NP n14_a_major_case_63->n14_a_major_case_66 n14_a_major_case_64->n14_a_major_case_65 n14_a_major_case_67 N n14_a_major_case_66->n14_a_major_case_67 n14_a_major_case_69 ADVP n14_a_major_case_66->n14_a_major_case_69 n14_a_major_case_67->n14_a_major_case_68 n14_a_major_case_70 ADVP n14_a_major_case_69->n14_a_major_case_70 n14_a_major_case_73 ADV n14_a_major_case_69->n14_a_major_case_73 n14_a_major_case_71 ADVR n14_a_major_case_70->n14_a_major_case_71 n14_a_major_case_71->n14_a_major_case_72 n14_a_major_case_73->n14_a_major_case_74 n14_a_major_case_75->n14_a_major_case_76 n14_a_major_case_77->n14_a_major_case_78 n14_a_major_case_80 BEN;_cat_VePASS_ n14_a_major_case_79->n14_a_major_case_80 n14_a_major_case_82 IP-PPL-CAT n14_a_major_case_79->n14_a_major_case_82 n14_a_major_case_80->n14_a_major_case_81 n14_a_major_case_83 NP-LGS n14_a_major_case_82->n14_a_major_case_83 n14_a_major_case_85 VVN;__ n14_a_major_case_82->n14_a_major_case_85 n14_a_major_case_87 PP-NIM n14_a_major_case_82->n14_a_major_case_87 n14_a_major_case_116 PP-NIM n14_a_major_case_82->n14_a_major_case_116 n14_a_major_case_83->n14_a_major_case_84 n14_a_major_case_85->n14_a_major_case_86 n14_a_major_case_88 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_87->n14_a_major_case_88 n14_a_major_case_90 NP n14_a_major_case_87->n14_a_major_case_90 n14_a_major_case_88->n14_a_major_case_89 n14_a_major_case_91 NLYR n14_a_major_case_90->n14_a_major_case_91 n14_a_major_case_92 NLYR n14_a_major_case_91->n14_a_major_case_92 n14_a_major_case_99 CONJP n14_a_major_case_91->n14_a_major_case_99 n14_a_major_case_93 D n14_a_major_case_92->n14_a_major_case_93 n14_a_major_case_95 NPR n14_a_major_case_92->n14_a_major_case_95 n14_a_major_case_97 NPR n14_a_major_case_92->n14_a_major_case_97 n14_a_major_case_93->n14_a_major_case_94 n14_a_major_case_95->n14_a_major_case_96 n14_a_major_case_97->n14_a_major_case_98 n14_a_major_case_100 CONJ n14_a_major_case_99->n14_a_major_case_100 n14_a_major_case_102 NLYR n14_a_major_case_99->n14_a_major_case_102 n14_a_major_case_100->n14_a_major_case_101 n14_a_major_case_103 ADJP n14_a_major_case_102->n14_a_major_case_103 n14_a_major_case_106 NS n14_a_major_case_102->n14_a_major_case_106 n14_a_major_case_108 PP n14_a_major_case_102->n14_a_major_case_108 n14_a_major_case_104 ADJ n14_a_major_case_103->n14_a_major_case_104 n14_a_major_case_104->n14_a_major_case_105 n14_a_major_case_106->n14_a_major_case_107 n14_a_major_case_109 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_108->n14_a_major_case_109 n14_a_major_case_111 NP n14_a_major_case_108->n14_a_major_case_111 n14_a_major_case_109->n14_a_major_case_110 n14_a_major_case_112 D n14_a_major_case_111->n14_a_major_case_112 n14_a_major_case_114 NPR n14_a_major_case_111->n14_a_major_case_114 n14_a_major_case_112->n14_a_major_case_113 n14_a_major_case_114->n14_a_major_case_115 n14_a_major_case_117 P-ROLE n14_a_major_case_116->n14_a_major_case_117 n14_a_major_case_119 NP n14_a_major_case_116->n14_a_major_case_119 n14_a_major_case_117->n14_a_major_case_118 n14_a_major_case_120 ADJP n14_a_major_case_119->n14_a_major_case_120 n14_a_major_case_123 NS n14_a_major_case_119->n14_a_major_case_123 n14_a_major_case_121 ADJ n14_a_major_case_120->n14_a_major_case_121 n14_a_major_case_121->n14_a_major_case_122 n14_a_major_case_123->n14_a_major_case_124 n14_a_major_case_125->n14_a_major_case_126 
( (IP-MAT (LST (LS 15<dot>))
          (PP-NIM (P-ROLE Since;{since})
                  (ADVP (ADV then;{then})))
          (PUNC ,)
          (NP-SBJ (NLYR (NLYR (D the;{the})
                              (N absence;{absence})
                              (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                  (NP (ADJP (ADJ proper;{proper}))
                                      (N witness;{witness})
                                      (N evidence;{evidence})
                                      (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                          (NP (D these;{these})
                                              (NS proceedings;{proceeding}))))))
                        (PUNC ,)
                        (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                               (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                     (N issue;{issue})
                                     (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                         (NP (N compliance;{compliance})
                                             (PP (P-ROLE with;{with})
                                                 (NP (D the;{the})
                                                     (N duty;{duty})
                                                     (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                         (NP (N candour;{candour})
                                                             (ADVP (ADVP (ADVR more;{more}))
                                                                   (ADV generally;{generally}))))))))))))
          (PUNC ,)
          (HVP;_cat_Ve_ has;{have})
          (IP-PPL-CAT (BEN;_cat_VePASS_ been;{be})
                      (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                  (VVN;__ raised;{raise})
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE with;{with})
                                          (NP (NLYR (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                                          (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                                          (NPR Minister;{Minister}))
                                                    (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                                           (NLYR (ADJP (ADJ other;{other}))
                                                                 (NS members;{member})
                                                                 (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                     (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                         (NPR Cabinet;{Cabinet}))))))))
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE on;{on})
                                          (NP (ADJP (ADJ several;{several}))
                                              (NS occasions;{occasion})))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 14_a_major_case))