TSPC 14_a_major

14_a_major_case
15. Since then, the absence of proper witness evidence in these proceedings, and the issue of compliance with the duty of candour more generally, has been raised with the Prime Minister and other members of the Cabinet on several occasions.

( (IP-MAT (LST (LS 15<dot>))
          (PP-NIM (P-ROLE Since;{since})
                  (ADVP (ADV then;{then})))
          (PUNC ,)
          (NP-SBJ (NLYR (NLYR (D the;{the})
                              (N absence;{absence})
                              (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                  (NP (ADJP (ADJ proper;{proper}))
                                      (N witness;{witness})
                                      (N evidence;{evidence})
                                      (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                          (NP (D these;{these})
                                              (NS proceedings;{proceeding}))))))
                        (PUNC ,)
                        (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                               (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                     (N issue;{issue})
                                     (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                         (NP (N compliance;{compliance})
                                             (PP (P-ROLE with;{with})
                                                 (NP (D the;{the})
                                                     (N duty;{duty})
                                                     (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                         (NP (N candour;{candour})
                                                             (ADVP (ADVP (ADVR more;{more}))
                                                                   (ADV generally;{generally}))))))))))))
          (PUNC ,)
          (HVP;_cat_Ve_ has;{have})
          (IP-PPL-CAT (BEN;_cat_VePASS_ been;{be})
                      (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                  (VVN;__ raised;{raise})
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE with;{with})
                                          (NP (NLYR (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                                          (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                                          (NPR Minister;{Minister}))
                                                    (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                                           (NLYR (ADJP (ADJ other;{other}))
                                                                 (NS members;{member})
                                                                 (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                     (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                         (NPR Cabinet;{Cabinet}))))))))
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE on;{on})
                                          (NP (ADJP (ADJ several;{several}))
                                              (NS occasions;{occasion})))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 14_a_major_case))

arc(r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence,r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence,r_0014_0007__of).
arc(r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence,r_0014_0008__proper,attrib).
arc(r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence,r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings,r_0014_0011__in).
arc(r_0014_0015__and,r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence,conj1).
arc(r_0014_0015__and,r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue,conj2).
arc(r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue,r_0014_0019__compliance,r_0014_0018__of).
arc(r_0014_0019__compliance,r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty,r_0014_0020__with).
arc(r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty,r_0014_0024__candour,r_0014_0023__of).
arc(r_0014_0024__candour,r_0014_0026__generally,qual).
arc(r_0014_0026__generally,r_0014_0025__more,qual).
arc(r_0014_0028__has,r_0014_0003__then,r_0014_0002__Since__nim).
arc(r_0014_0028__has,r_0014_0029__been,scope).
arc(r_0014_0029__been,r_0014_0030__raised,scope).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised,r_0014_0015__and,arg1).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised,r_0014_0035__and,r_0014_0031__with__nim).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised,r_0014_0043__occasions,r_0014_0041__on__nim).
arc(r_0014_0030__raised,z_0014_5020___star_,arg0).
arc(r_0014_0035__and,r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister,conj1).
arc(r_0014_0035__and,r_0014_0037__members,conj2).
arc(r_0014_0037__members,r_0014_0036__other,attrib).
arc(r_0014_0037__members,r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet,r_0014_0038__of).
arc(r_0014_0043__occasions,r_0014_0042__several,attrib).

fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_0014_0003__THEN,R_0014_0008__PROPER,R_0014_0012__THESE_R_0014_0013__PROCEEDINGS,R_0014_0009__WITNESS_R_0014_0010__EVIDENCE,R_0014_0005__THE_R_0014_0006__ABSENCE,R_0014_0025__MORE,R_0014_0026__GENERALLY,R_0014_0024__CANDOUR,R_0014_0021__THE_R_0014_0022__DUTY,R_0014_0019__COMPLIANCE,R_0014_0016__THE_R_0014_0017__ISSUE,R_0014_0015__AND,R_0014_0032__THE_R_0014_0033__PRIME_R_0014_0034__MINISTER,R_0014_0036__OTHER,R_0014_0039__THE_R_0014_0040__CABINET,R_0014_0037__MEMBERS,R_0014_0035__AND,R_0014_0042__SEVERAL,R_0014_0043__OCCASIONS,Z_0014_5020___STAR_,R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED] :
      ( r_0014_0003__then(R_0014_0003__THEN)
      & r_0014_0008__proper(R_0014_0008__PROPER)
      & r_0014_0012__these_r_0014_0013__proceedings(R_0014_0012__THESE_R_0014_0013__PROCEEDINGS)
      & r_0014_0025__more(R_0014_0025__MORE)
      & r_0014_0032__the_r_0014_0033__Prime_r_0014_0034__Minister(R_0014_0032__THE_R_0014_0033__PRIME_R_0014_0034__MINISTER)
      & r_0014_0036__other(R_0014_0036__OTHER)
      & r_0014_0039__the_r_0014_0040__Cabinet(R_0014_0039__THE_R_0014_0040__CABINET)
      & r_0014_0042__several(R_0014_0042__SEVERAL)
      & z_0014_5020___star_(Z_0014_5020___STAR_)
      & r_0014_0028__has_r_0014_0029__been_r_0014_0030__raised(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED)
      & has_arg0(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED,Z_0014_5020___STAR_)
      & has_r_0014_0041__on__nim(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED,R_0014_0043__OCCASIONS)
      & r_0014_0043__occasions(R_0014_0043__OCCASIONS)
      & has_attrib(R_0014_0043__OCCASIONS,R_0014_0042__SEVERAL)
      & has_r_0014_0031__with__nim(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED,R_0014_0035__AND)
      & r_0014_0035__and(R_0014_0035__AND)
      & has_conj2(R_0014_0035__AND,R_0014_0037__MEMBERS)
      & r_0014_0037__members(R_0014_0037__MEMBERS)
      & has_r_0014_0038__of(R_0014_0037__MEMBERS,R_0014_0039__THE_R_0014_0040__CABINET)
      & has_attrib(R_0014_0037__MEMBERS,R_0014_0036__OTHER)
      & has_conj1(R_0014_0035__AND,R_0014_0032__THE_R_0014_0033__PRIME_R_0014_0034__MINISTER)
      & has_arg1(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED,R_0014_0015__AND)
      & r_0014_0015__and(R_0014_0015__AND)
      & has_conj2(R_0014_0015__AND,R_0014_0016__THE_R_0014_0017__ISSUE)
      & r_0014_0016__the_r_0014_0017__issue(R_0014_0016__THE_R_0014_0017__ISSUE)
      & has_r_0014_0018__of(R_0014_0016__THE_R_0014_0017__ISSUE,R_0014_0019__COMPLIANCE)
      & r_0014_0019__compliance(R_0014_0019__COMPLIANCE)
      & has_r_0014_0020__with(R_0014_0019__COMPLIANCE,R_0014_0021__THE_R_0014_0022__DUTY)
      & r_0014_0021__the_r_0014_0022__duty(R_0014_0021__THE_R_0014_0022__DUTY)
      & has_r_0014_0023__of(R_0014_0021__THE_R_0014_0022__DUTY,R_0014_0024__CANDOUR)
      & r_0014_0024__candour(R_0014_0024__CANDOUR)
      & has_qual(R_0014_0024__CANDOUR,R_0014_0026__GENERALLY)
      & r_0014_0026__generally(R_0014_0026__GENERALLY)
      & has_qual(R_0014_0026__GENERALLY,R_0014_0025__MORE)
      & has_conj1(R_0014_0015__AND,R_0014_0005__THE_R_0014_0006__ABSENCE)
      & r_0014_0005__the_r_0014_0006__absence(R_0014_0005__THE_R_0014_0006__ABSENCE)
      & has_r_0014_0007__of(R_0014_0005__THE_R_0014_0006__ABSENCE,R_0014_0009__WITNESS_R_0014_0010__EVIDENCE)
      & r_0014_0009__witness_r_0014_0010__evidence(R_0014_0009__WITNESS_R_0014_0010__EVIDENCE)
      & has_r_0014_0011__in(R_0014_0009__WITNESS_R_0014_0010__EVIDENCE,R_0014_0012__THESE_R_0014_0013__PROCEEDINGS)
      & has_attrib(R_0014_0009__WITNESS_R_0014_0010__EVIDENCE,R_0014_0008__PROPER)
      & has_r_0014_0002__Since__nim(R_0014_0028__HAS_R_0014_0029__BEEN_R_0014_0030__RAISED,R_0014_0003__THEN) ) ).