Context                Previous, Next                Top


19_a_major_case
He answered: “If people were carrying out discussions without candour, I would not know about them so would not be able to tell the hon. Gentleman whether they had happened.” -LCB- HC Deb Vol 664 col 91 -RCB-

%3 r_0019_0002__answered answered r_0019_0001__He He r_0019_0002__answered->r_0019_0001__He [arg0] utterance_19_a_major_case_9 [utterance] r_0019_0002__answered->utterance_19_a_major_case_9 [arg1] r_0019_0005__If If utterance_19_a_major_case_9->r_0019_0005__If [part1] r_0019_0007__were were r_0019_0005__If->r_0019_0007__were [restriction] z_000_19_a_major_case_41 r_0019_0005__If->z_000_19_a_major_case_41 [scope] r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out carrying out r_0019_0007__were->r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out [scope] r_0019_0016__not not z_000_19_a_major_case_41->r_0019_0016__not [conj1] r_0019_0022__not not z_000_19_a_major_case_41->r_0019_0022__not [conj2] r_0019_0006__people people r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out->r_0019_0006__people [arg0] r_0019_0010__discussions discussions r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out->r_0019_0010__discussions [arg1] r_0019_0012__candour candour r_0019_0010__discussions->r_0019_0012__candour without r_0019_0015__would would r_0019_0017__know know r_0019_0015__would->r_0019_0017__know [scope] r_0019_0017__know->r_0019_0010__discussions about [clr] r_0019_0014__I I r_0019_0017__know->r_0019_0014__I [arg0] r_0019_0016__not->r_0019_0015__would [keep_scope] r_0019_0021__would would r_0019_0020__so so r_0019_0021__would->r_0019_0020__so [nim] r_0019_0023__be be r_0019_0021__would->r_0019_0023__be [scope] r_0019_0023__be->r_0019_0014__I [arg0] r_0019_0024__able able r_0019_0023__be->r_0019_0024__able [prd] r_0019_0022__not->r_0019_0021__would [keep_scope] r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell to tell r_0019_0024__able->r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell [emb] r_0019_0027__the_r_0019_0028__hon_dot__r_0019_0029__Gentleman the hon. Gentleman r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->r_0019_0027__the_r_0019_0028__hon_dot__r_0019_0029__Gentleman [arg2] r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had whether had r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had [arg1] z_000_19_a_major_case_71 r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->z_000_19_a_major_case_71 [arg0] r_0019_0033__happened happened r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had->r_0019_0033__happened [scope] r_0019_0033__happened->r_0019_0010__discussions [arg0] 
arc(r_0019_0002__answered, r_0019_0001__He, arg0).
arc(r_0019_0002__answered, utterance_19_a_major_case_9, arg1).
arc(r_0019_0005__If, r_0019_0007__were, restriction).
arc(r_0019_0005__If, z_000_19_a_major_case_41, scope).
arc(r_0019_0007__were, r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out, scope).
arc(r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out, r_0019_0006__people, arg0).
arc(r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out, r_0019_0010__discussions, arg1).
arc(r_0019_0010__discussions, r_0019_0012__candour, r_0019_0011__without).
arc(r_0019_0015__would, r_0019_0017__know, scope).
arc(r_0019_0016__not, r_0019_0015__would, keep_scope).
arc(r_0019_0017__know, r_0019_0010__discussions, r_0019_0018__about_clr53).
arc(r_0019_0017__know, r_0019_0014__I, arg0).
arc(r_0019_0021__would, r_0019_0020__so, nim58).
arc(r_0019_0021__would, r_0019_0023__be, scope).
arc(r_0019_0022__not, r_0019_0021__would, keep_scope).
arc(r_0019_0023__be, r_0019_0014__I, arg0).
arc(r_0019_0023__be, r_0019_0024__able, prd).
arc(r_0019_0024__able, r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell, emb71).
arc(r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell, r_0019_0027__the_r_0019_0028__hon_dot__r_0019_0029__Gentleman, arg2).
arc(r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell, r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had, arg1).
arc(r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell, z_000_19_a_major_case_71, arg0).
arc(r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had, r_0019_0033__happened, scope).
arc(r_0019_0033__happened, r_0019_0010__discussions, arg0).
arc(utterance_19_a_major_case_9, r_0019_0005__If, part1).
arc(z_000_19_a_major_case_41, r_0019_0016__not, conj1).
arc(z_000_19_a_major_case_41, r_0019_0022__not, conj2).


%3 r_0019_0002__answered answered r_0019_0001__He He r_0019_0002__answered->r_0019_0001__He [arg0] utterance_19_a_major_case_9 [utterance] r_0019_0002__answered->utterance_19_a_major_case_9 [arg1] r_0019_0005__If If utterance_19_a_major_case_9->r_0019_0005__If [part1] r_0019_0007__were_r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out were carrying out r_0019_0005__If->r_0019_0007__were_r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out [restriction] z_000_19_a_major_case_41 r_0019_0005__If->z_000_19_a_major_case_41 [scope] r_0019_0006__people people r_0019_0007__were_r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out->r_0019_0006__people [arg0] r_0019_0010__discussions discussions r_0019_0007__were_r_0019_0008__carrying_r_0019_0009__out->r_0019_0010__discussions [arg1] r_0019_0016__not not z_000_19_a_major_case_41->r_0019_0016__not [conj1] r_0019_0022__not not z_000_19_a_major_case_41->r_0019_0022__not [conj2] r_0019_0012__candour candour r_0019_0010__discussions->r_0019_0012__candour without r_0019_0015__would_r_0019_0017__know would know r_0019_0015__would_r_0019_0017__know->r_0019_0010__discussions about [clr] r_0019_0014__I I r_0019_0015__would_r_0019_0017__know->r_0019_0014__I [arg0] r_0019_0016__not->r_0019_0015__would_r_0019_0017__know [keep_scope] r_0019_0021__would_r_0019_0023__be would be r_0019_0021__would_r_0019_0023__be->r_0019_0014__I [arg0] r_0019_0020__so so r_0019_0021__would_r_0019_0023__be->r_0019_0020__so [nim] r_0019_0024__able able r_0019_0021__would_r_0019_0023__be->r_0019_0024__able [prd] r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell to tell r_0019_0024__able->r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell [emb] r_0019_0022__not->r_0019_0021__would_r_0019_0023__be [keep_scope] r_0019_0027__the_r_0019_0028__hon_dot__r_0019_0029__Gentleman the hon. Gentleman r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->r_0019_0027__the_r_0019_0028__hon_dot__r_0019_0029__Gentleman [arg2] r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had_r_0019_0033__happened whether had happened r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had_r_0019_0033__happened [arg1] z_000_19_a_major_case_71 r_0019_0025__to_r_0019_0026__tell->z_000_19_a_major_case_71 [arg0] r_0019_0030__whether_r_0019_0032__had_r_0019_0033__happened->r_0019_0010__discussions [arg0] 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_19_2_ANSWERED,R_19_1_HE,UTTERANCE_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_9] :
      ( he(R_19_1_HE)
      & answered(R_19_2_ANSWERED,R_19_1_HE,UTTERANCE_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_9)
      & ! [R_19_7_WERE_CARRYING_OUT,R_19_6_PEOPLE,R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS,R_19_12_CANDOUR] :
          ( ( people(R_19_6_PEOPLE)
            & candour(R_19_12_CANDOUR)
            & were_carrying_out(R_19_7_WERE_CARRYING_OUT,R_19_6_PEOPLE,R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS)
            & discussions(R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS)
            & without(R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS,R_19_12_CANDOUR) )
         => ? [Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_41] :
              ( z_19_a_major_case_41(Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_41)
              & conj1(Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_41,R_19_16_NOT)
              & ~ ? [R_19_15_WOULD_KNOW,R_19_14_I] :
                    ( i(R_19_14_I)
                    & would_know(R_19_15_WOULD_KNOW,R_19_14_I)
                    & about_clr53(R_19_15_WOULD_KNOW,R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS) )
              & conj2(Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_41,R_19_22_NOT)
              & ~ ? [R_19_21_WOULD_BE,R_19_14_I,R_19_20_SO,R_19_24_ABLE,R_19_25_TO_TELL,Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_71,R_19_30_WHETHER_HAD_HAPPENED,R_19_27_THE_HON_DOT_GENTLEMAN] :
                    ( i(R_19_14_I)
                    & so(R_19_20_SO)
                    & the_hon_dot_Gentleman(R_19_27_THE_HON_DOT_GENTLEMAN)
                    & would_be(R_19_21_WOULD_BE,R_19_14_I,R_19_24_ABLE)
                    & able(R_19_24_ABLE)
                    & emb71(R_19_24_ABLE,R_19_25_TO_TELL)
                    & to_tell(R_19_25_TO_TELL,Z_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_71,R_19_30_WHETHER_HAD_HAPPENED,R_19_27_THE_HON_DOT_GENTLEMAN)
                    & whether_had_happened(R_19_30_WHETHER_HAD_HAPPENED,R_19_10_DISCUSSIONS)
                    & nim58(R_19_21_WOULD_BE,R_19_20_SO) ) ) )
      & part1(PART1)
      & utterance_19_a_major_case_9(UTTERANCE_19_A_MAJOR_CASE_9) ) ).


n19_a_major_case n19_a_major_case_4 He n19_a_major_case_6 answered n19_a_major_case_8 : n19_a_major_case_12 <ldquo> n19_a_major_case_15 If n19_a_major_case_19 people n19_a_major_case_21 were n19_a_major_case_24 carrying n19_a_major_case_26 out n19_a_major_case_29 discussions n19_a_major_case_32 without n19_a_major_case_35 candour n19_a_major_case_37 , n19_a_major_case_40 I n19_a_major_case_44 would n19_a_major_case_46 not n19_a_major_case_49 know n19_a_major_case_52 about n19_a_major_case_55 them n19_a_major_case_60 so n19_a_major_case_62 would n19_a_major_case_64 not n19_a_major_case_67 be n19_a_major_case_70 able n19_a_major_case_73 to n19_a_major_case_75 tell n19_a_major_case_78 the n19_a_major_case_80 hon. n19_a_major_case_82 Gentleman n19_a_major_case_86 whether n19_a_major_case_89 they n19_a_major_case_91 had n19_a_major_case_94 happened n19_a_major_case_96 . n19_a_major_case_98 <rdquo> n19_a_major_case_101 -LCB- n19_a_major_case_104 HC n19_a_major_case_106 Deb n19_a_major_case_108 Vol n19_a_major_case_110 664 n19_a_major_case_112 col n19_a_major_case_114 91 n19_a_major_case_116 -RCB- n19_a_major_case_1 IP-MAT n19_a_major_case_2 NP-SBJ n19_a_major_case_1->n19_a_major_case_2 n19_a_major_case_5 VBD;_Tr_ n19_a_major_case_1->n19_a_major_case_5 n19_a_major_case_7 PUNC n19_a_major_case_1->n19_a_major_case_7 n19_a_major_case_9 utterance-OB1 n19_a_major_case_1->n19_a_major_case_9 n19_a_major_case_3 PRO n19_a_major_case_2->n19_a_major_case_3 n19_a_major_case_3->n19_a_major_case_4 n19_a_major_case_5->n19_a_major_case_6 n19_a_major_case_7->n19_a_major_case_8 n19_a_major_case_10 IP-MAT n19_a_major_case_9->n19_a_major_case_10 n19_a_major_case_11 PULQ n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_11 n19_a_major_case_13 PP-SCON n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_13 n19_a_major_case_36 PUNC n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_36 n19_a_major_case_38 NP-SBJ n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_38 n19_a_major_case_41 ILYR n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_41 n19_a_major_case_95 PUNC n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_95 n19_a_major_case_97 PURQ n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_97 n19_a_major_case_99 META n19_a_major_case_10->n19_a_major_case_99 n19_a_major_case_11->n19_a_major_case_12 n19_a_major_case_14 P-CONN n19_a_major_case_13->n19_a_major_case_14 n19_a_major_case_16 IP-ADV n19_a_major_case_13->n19_a_major_case_16 n19_a_major_case_14->n19_a_major_case_15 n19_a_major_case_17 NP-SBJ n19_a_major_case_16->n19_a_major_case_17 n19_a_major_case_20 BED;_cat_Vg_ n19_a_major_case_16->n19_a_major_case_20 n19_a_major_case_22 IP-PPL-CAT n19_a_major_case_16->n19_a_major_case_22 n19_a_major_case_18 NS n19_a_major_case_17->n19_a_major_case_18 n19_a_major_case_18->n19_a_major_case_19 n19_a_major_case_20->n19_a_major_case_21 n19_a_major_case_23 VAG;__ n19_a_major_case_22->n19_a_major_case_23 n19_a_major_case_25 RP n19_a_major_case_22->n19_a_major_case_25 n19_a_major_case_27 NP-OB1 n19_a_major_case_22->n19_a_major_case_27 n19_a_major_case_23->n19_a_major_case_24 n19_a_major_case_25->n19_a_major_case_26 n19_a_major_case_28 NS n19_a_major_case_27->n19_a_major_case_28 n19_a_major_case_30 PP n19_a_major_case_27->n19_a_major_case_30 n19_a_major_case_28->n19_a_major_case_29 n19_a_major_case_31 P-ROLE n19_a_major_case_30->n19_a_major_case_31 n19_a_major_case_33 NP n19_a_major_case_30->n19_a_major_case_33 n19_a_major_case_31->n19_a_major_case_32 n19_a_major_case_34 N n19_a_major_case_33->n19_a_major_case_34 n19_a_major_case_34->n19_a_major_case_35 n19_a_major_case_36->n19_a_major_case_37 n19_a_major_case_39 PRO n19_a_major_case_38->n19_a_major_case_39 n19_a_major_case_39->n19_a_major_case_40 n19_a_major_case_42 ILYR n19_a_major_case_41->n19_a_major_case_42 n19_a_major_case_56 CONJP n19_a_major_case_41->n19_a_major_case_56 n19_a_major_case_43 MD;_cat_Vi_ n19_a_major_case_42->n19_a_major_case_43 n19_a_major_case_45 NEG n19_a_major_case_42->n19_a_major_case_45 n19_a_major_case_47 IP-INF-CAT n19_a_major_case_42->n19_a_major_case_47 n19_a_major_case_43->n19_a_major_case_44 n19_a_major_case_45->n19_a_major_case_46 n19_a_major_case_48 VB;__ n19_a_major_case_47->n19_a_major_case_48 n19_a_major_case_50 PP-CLR n19_a_major_case_47->n19_a_major_case_50 n19_a_major_case_48->n19_a_major_case_49 n19_a_major_case_51 P-ROLE n19_a_major_case_50->n19_a_major_case_51 n19_a_major_case_53 NP n19_a_major_case_50->n19_a_major_case_53 n19_a_major_case_51->n19_a_major_case_52 n19_a_major_case_54 PRO n19_a_major_case_53->n19_a_major_case_54 n19_a_major_case_54->n19_a_major_case_55 n19_a_major_case_57 ILYR n19_a_major_case_56->n19_a_major_case_57 n19_a_major_case_58 ADVP-NIM n19_a_major_case_57->n19_a_major_case_58 n19_a_major_case_61 MD;_cat_Vi_ n19_a_major_case_57->n19_a_major_case_61 n19_a_major_case_63 NEG n19_a_major_case_57->n19_a_major_case_63 n19_a_major_case_65 IP-INF-CAT n19_a_major_case_57->n19_a_major_case_65 n19_a_major_case_59 ADV n19_a_major_case_58->n19_a_major_case_59 n19_a_major_case_59->n19_a_major_case_60 n19_a_major_case_61->n19_a_major_case_62 n19_a_major_case_63->n19_a_major_case_64 n19_a_major_case_66 BE;_La_ n19_a_major_case_65->n19_a_major_case_66 n19_a_major_case_68 ADJP-PRD n19_a_major_case_65->n19_a_major_case_68 n19_a_major_case_66->n19_a_major_case_67 n19_a_major_case_69 ADJ;_cat_ n19_a_major_case_68->n19_a_major_case_69 n19_a_major_case_71 IP-INF n19_a_major_case_68->n19_a_major_case_71 n19_a_major_case_69->n19_a_major_case_70 n19_a_major_case_72 TO n19_a_major_case_71->n19_a_major_case_72 n19_a_major_case_74 VB;_Dn.w_ n19_a_major_case_71->n19_a_major_case_74 n19_a_major_case_76 NP-OB2 n19_a_major_case_71->n19_a_major_case_76 n19_a_major_case_83 CP-QUE-OB1 n19_a_major_case_71->n19_a_major_case_83 n19_a_major_case_72->n19_a_major_case_73 n19_a_major_case_74->n19_a_major_case_75 n19_a_major_case_77 D n19_a_major_case_76->n19_a_major_case_77 n19_a_major_case_79 NPR n19_a_major_case_76->n19_a_major_case_79 n19_a_major_case_81 NPR n19_a_major_case_76->n19_a_major_case_81 n19_a_major_case_77->n19_a_major_case_78 n19_a_major_case_79->n19_a_major_case_80 n19_a_major_case_81->n19_a_major_case_82 n19_a_major_case_84 IP-SUB n19_a_major_case_83->n19_a_major_case_84 n19_a_major_case_85 WQ n19_a_major_case_84->n19_a_major_case_85 n19_a_major_case_87 NP-SBJ n19_a_major_case_84->n19_a_major_case_87 n19_a_major_case_90 HVD;_cat_Ve_ n19_a_major_case_84->n19_a_major_case_90 n19_a_major_case_92 IP-PPL-CAT n19_a_major_case_84->n19_a_major_case_92 n19_a_major_case_85->n19_a_major_case_86 n19_a_major_case_88 PRO n19_a_major_case_87->n19_a_major_case_88 n19_a_major_case_88->n19_a_major_case_89 n19_a_major_case_90->n19_a_major_case_91 n19_a_major_case_93 VVN;__ n19_a_major_case_92->n19_a_major_case_93 n19_a_major_case_93->n19_a_major_case_94 n19_a_major_case_95->n19_a_major_case_96 n19_a_major_case_97->n19_a_major_case_98 n19_a_major_case_100 PULB n19_a_major_case_99->n19_a_major_case_100 n19_a_major_case_102 NP n19_a_major_case_99->n19_a_major_case_102 n19_a_major_case_115 PURB n19_a_major_case_99->n19_a_major_case_115 n19_a_major_case_100->n19_a_major_case_101 n19_a_major_case_103 N n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_103 n19_a_major_case_105 N n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_105 n19_a_major_case_107 N n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_107 n19_a_major_case_109 NUM n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_109 n19_a_major_case_111 N n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_111 n19_a_major_case_113 NUM n19_a_major_case_102->n19_a_major_case_113 n19_a_major_case_103->n19_a_major_case_104 n19_a_major_case_105->n19_a_major_case_106 n19_a_major_case_107->n19_a_major_case_108 n19_a_major_case_109->n19_a_major_case_110 n19_a_major_case_111->n19_a_major_case_112 n19_a_major_case_113->n19_a_major_case_114 n19_a_major_case_115->n19_a_major_case_116 
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ;{HOUSE_LEADER} (PRO He;{he}))
          (VBD;_Tr_ answered;{answer})
          (PUNC :)
          (utterance-OB1 (IP-MAT (PULQ <ldquo>)
                                 (PP-SCON (P-CONN If;{if})
                                          (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ (NS people;{people}))
                                                  (BED;_cat_Vg_ were;{be})
                                                  (IP-PPL-CAT (VAG;__ carrying;{carry})
                                                              (RP out;{out})
                                                              (NP-OB1;{DISCUSSIONS} (NS discussions;{discussion})
                                                                                    (PP (P-ROLE without;{without})
                                                                                        (NP (N candour;{candour})))))))
                                 (PUNC ,)
                                 (NP-SBJ (PRO I;{I}))
                                 (ILYR (ILYR (MD;_cat_Vi_ would;{will})
                                             (NEG not;{not})
                                             (IP-INF-CAT (VB;__ know;{know})
                                                         (PP-CLR (P-ROLE about;{about})
                                                                 (NP;{DISCUSSIONS} (PRO them;{they})))))
                                       (CONJP (ILYR (ADVP-NIM (ADV so;{so}))
                                                    (MD;_cat_Vi_ would;{will})
                                                    (NEG not;{not})
                                                    (IP-INF-CAT (BE;_La_ be;{be})
                                                                (ADJP-PRD (ADJ;_cat_ able;{able})
                                                                          (IP-INF (TO to;{to})
                                                                                  (VB;_Dn.w_ tell;{tell})
                                                                                  (NP-OB2 (D the;{the})
                                                                                          (NPR hon<dot>)
                                                                                          (NPR Gentleman;{Gentleman}))
                                                                                  (CP-QUE-OB1 (IP-SUB (WQ whether;{whether})
                                                                                                      (NP-SBJ;{DISCUSSIONS} (PRO they;{they}))
                                                                                                      (HVD;_cat_Ve_ had;{have})
                                                                                                      (IP-PPL-CAT (VVN;__ happened;{happen}))))))))))
                                 (PUNC .)
                                 (PURQ <rdquo>)
                                 (META (PULB -LCB-)
                                       (NP (N HC;{hc})
                                           (N Deb;{deb})
                                           (N Vol;{vol})
                                           (NUM 664)
                                           (N col;{col})
                                           (NUM 91))
                                       (PURB -RCB-)))))
  (ID 19_a_major_case))