25_a_major_case
“ Mr Dominic Grieve ( Beaconsfield ) ( Ind ) : In the light of the Prime Minister 's answer to my right hon. Friend the Member for South West Hertfordshire ( Mr Gauke ) , could the Prime Minister please explain why it has proved impossible to find any official or Minister prepared to state that the reasons for Prorogation were to pave the way for a Queen 's Speech , in the course of the current legal proceedings in which the Government are involved ?

%3 0025_0013__the_0025_0014__light the_light 0025_0020__answer answer 0025_0013__the_0025_0014__light->0025_0020__answer of 0025_0016__the_0025_0017__Prime_0025_0018__Minister the_prime_minister 0025_0020__answer->0025_0016__the_0025_0017__Prime_0025_0018__Minister [genv] 0025_0024__hon._0025_0025__Friend hon._friend 0025_0020__answer->0025_0024__hon._0025_0025__Friend to 0025_0022__my my 0025_0024__hon._0025_0025__Friend->0025_0022__my [genv] 0025_0023__right right 0025_0024__hon._0025_0025__Friend->0025_0023__right [attrib] 0025_0026__the_0025_0027__Member the_member 0025_0026__the_0025_0027__Member->0025_0024__hon._0025_0025__Friend [prn] 0025_0029__South_0025_0030__West_0025_0031__Hertfordshire south_west_hertfordshire 0025_0026__the_0025_0027__Member->0025_0029__South_0025_0030__West_0025_0031__Hertfordshire for 0025_0033__M0025_0034__Gauke mr_gauke 0025_0033__M0025_0034__Gauke->0025_0026__the_0025_0027__Member [prn] 0025_0037__could_0025_0042__explain could_explain 0025_0037__could_0025_0042__explain->0025_0013__the_0025_0014__light in[rst] 0025_0037__could_0025_0042__explain->0025_0016__the_0025_0017__Prime_0025_0018__Minister [arg0] z_0025_1011 [question] 0025_0037__could_0025_0042__explain->z_0025_1011 [arg1] 0025_0043__why_0025_0045__has_0025_0046__proved why_has_proved z_0025_1011->0025_0043__why_0025_0045__has_0025_0046__proved [scope] 0025_0047__impossible impossible 0025_0043__why_0025_0045__has_0025_0046__proved->0025_0047__impossible [prd2] 0025_0049__find find 0025_0043__why_0025_0045__has_0025_0046__proved->0025_0049__find [argn0] 0025_0050__any_0025_0051__official_0025_0052__o0025_0053__Minister any_official_or_minister 0025_0049__find->0025_0050__any_0025_0051__official_0025_0052__o0025_0053__Minister [arg1] 0025_0054__prepared prepared 0025_0054__prepared->0025_0050__any_0025_0051__official_0025_0052__o0025_0053__Minister [arg0] 0025_0056__state state 0025_0054__prepared->0025_0056__state to[clr] 0025_0074__the_0025_0075__course the_course 0025_0054__prepared->0025_0074__the_0025_0075__course in[tmp] 0025_0062__were_0025_0064__pave were_pave 0025_0056__state->0025_0062__were_0025_0064__pave [emb] 0025_0077__the_0025_0080__proceedings the_proceedings 0025_0074__the_0025_0075__course->0025_0077__the_0025_0080__proceedings of 0025_0058__the_0025_0059__reasons the_reasons 0025_0062__were_0025_0064__pave->0025_0058__the_0025_0059__reasons [arg0] 0025_0065__the_0025_0066__way the_way 0025_0062__were_0025_0064__pave->0025_0065__the_0025_0066__way [arg1] 0025_0071__Speech speech 0025_0062__were_0025_0064__pave->0025_0071__Speech for[clr] 0025_0061__Prorogation prorogation 0025_0058__the_0025_0059__reasons->0025_0061__Prorogation for 0025_0068__a_0025_0069__Queen a_queen 0025_0071__Speech->0025_0068__a_0025_0069__Queen [genv] 0025_0078__current current 0025_0077__the_0025_0080__proceedings->0025_0078__current [attrib] 0025_0079__legal legal 0025_0077__the_0025_0080__proceedings->0025_0079__legal [attrib] 0025_0085__are_0025_0086__involved are_involved 0025_0085__are_0025_0086__involved->0025_0077__the_0025_0080__proceedings in[clr] 0025_0083__the_0025_0084__Government the_government 0025_0085__are_0025_0086__involved->0025_0083__the_0025_0084__Government [arg1] z_0025_1002 [question] z_0025_1002->0025_0037__could_0025_0042__explain [scope]
arc(r_0025_0013__the_r_0025_0014__light,r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0015__of).
arc(r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0016__the_r_0025_0017__Prime_r_0025_0018__Minister,genv).
arc(r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0021__to).
arc(r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0022__my,genv).
arc(r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0023__right,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,prn).
arc(r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,r_0025_0029__South_r_0025_0030__West_r_0025_0031__Hertfordshire,r_0025_0028__for).
arc(r_0025_0033__Mr_r_0025_0034__Gauke,r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,prn).
arc(r_0025_0037__could_r_0025_0042__explain,r_0025_0013__the_r_0025_0014__light,r_0025_0012__In__rst).
arc(r_0025_0037__could_r_0025_0042__explain,r_0025_0016__the_r_0025_0017__Prime_r_0025_0018__Minister,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0037__could_r_0025_0042__explain,z_0025_1011__question,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0043__why_r_0025_0045__has_r_0025_0046__proved,r_0025_0047__impossible,prd2).
arc(r_0025_0043__why_r_0025_0045__has_r_0025_0046__proved,r_0025_0049__find,argn0).
arc(r_0025_0049__find,r_0025_0050__any_r_0025_0051__official_r_0025_0052__or_r_0025_0053__Minister,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0050__any_r_0025_0051__official_r_0025_0052__or_r_0025_0053__Minister,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0056__state,r_0025_0055__to__clr).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0074__the_r_0025_0075__course,r_0025_0073__in__tmp).
arc(r_0025_0056__state,r_0025_0062__were_r_0025_0064__pave,emb).
arc(r_0025_0058__the_r_0025_0059__reasons,r_0025_0061__Prorogation,r_0025_0060__for).
arc(r_0025_0062__were_r_0025_0064__pave,r_0025_0058__the_r_0025_0059__reasons,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0062__were_r_0025_0064__pave,r_0025_0065__the_r_0025_0066__way,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0062__were_r_0025_0064__pave,r_0025_0071__Speech,r_0025_0067__for__clr).
arc(r_0025_0071__Speech,r_0025_0068__a_r_0025_0069__Queen,genv).
arc(r_0025_0074__the_r_0025_0075__course,r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0076__of).
arc(r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0078__current,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0079__legal,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0085__are_r_0025_0086__involved,r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0081__in__clr).
arc(r_0025_0085__are_r_0025_0086__involved,r_0025_0083__the_r_0025_0084__Government,arg1).
arc(z_0025_1002__question,r_0025_0037__could_r_0025_0042__explain,keep_scope).
arc(z_0025_1011__question,r_0025_0043__why_r_0025_0045__has_r_0025_0046__proved,keep_scope).


CP-QUE-MAT PULQ IP-SUB META NP NPR Mr NPR Dominic NPR Grieve PRN PULB -LRB- NP NPR Beaconsfield PURB -RRB- PRN PULB -LRB- NP NPR Ind PURB -RRB- PUNC : PP-RST P-ROLE In NP D the N light PP P-ROLE of NP NP-GENV D the NPR Prime NPR Minister GENM 's N answer PP P-ROLE to NP NP-GENV PRO;_genm_ my ADJP ADJ right N hon. N Friend PRN NP D the NPR Member PP P-ROLE for NP NPR South NPR West NPR Hertfordshire PULB -LRB- PRN NP NPR Mr NPR Gauke PURB -RRB- PUNC , MD;~cat_Vi could NP-SBJ D the NPR Prime NPR Minister IP-INF-CAT FRM please VB explain CP-QUE-OB1 IP-SUB ADVP-CNT WADV why NP-SBJ PRO;_provisional_ it HVP;~cat_Ve has IP-PPL-CAT VVN proved ADJP-PRD2 ADJ impossible IP-INF-NSBJ TO to VB find NP-OB1 D any NLYR NP N official CONJP CONJ or NP N Minister IP-PPL VVN prepared PP-CLR P-ROLE to NP N state CP-THT IP-SUB C that NP-SBJ D the NS reasons PP P-ROLE for NP N Prorogation BED;~cat_Vt were IP-INF-CAT TO to VB;~Tn.pr pave NP-OB1 D the N way PP-CLR P-ROLE for NP NP-GENV D a NPR Queen GENM 's N Speech PUNC , PP-TMP P-ROLE in NP D the N course PP P-ROLE of NP D the ADJP ADJ current ADJP ADJ legal NS proceedings IP-REL PP-125 P-ROLE in NP RPRO which NP-SBJ D the N Government BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ are IP-PPL-CAT PP-CLR *ICH*-125 NP-LGS * VVN involved PUNC ?
( (CP-QUE-MAT (PULQ <ldquo>)
              (IP-SUB (META (NP (NPR Mr;{Mr})
                                (NPR Dominic;{Dominic})
                                (NPR Grieve;{Grieve})
                                (PRN (PULB -LRB-)
                                     (NP (NPR Beaconsfield;{Beaconsfield}))
                                     (PURB -RRB-))
                                (PRN (PULB -LRB-)
                                     (NP (NPR Ind;{Ind}))
                                     (PURB -RRB-)))
                            (PUNC :))
                      (PP-RST (P-ROLE In;{in})
                              (NP (D the;{the})
                                  (N light;{light})
                                  (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                      (NP (NP-GENV;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
                                                             (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                                             (NPR Minister;{Minister})
                                                             (GENM <apos>s))
                                          (N answer;{answer})
                                          (PP (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                              (NP (NP-GENV (PRO;_genm_ my;{my}))
                                                  (ADJP (ADJ right;{right}))
                                                  (N hon<dot>)
                                                  (N Friend;{friend})
                                                  (PRN (NP (D the;{the})
                                                           (NPR Member;{Member})
                                                           (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                               (NP (NPR South;{South})
                                                                   (NPR West;{West})
                                                                   (NPR Hertfordshire;{Hertfordshire})))
                                                           (PULB -LRB-)
                                                           (PRN (NP;{PERSON} (NPR Mr;{Mr})
                                                                             (NPR Gauke;{Gauke})))
                                                           (PURB -RRB-)))))))))
                      (PUNC ,)
                      (MD;~cat_Vi could;{can})
                      (NP-SBJ;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
                                        (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                        (NPR Minister;{Minister}))
                      (IP-INF-CAT (FRM please)
                                  (VB explain;{explain})
                                  (CP-QUE-OB1 (IP-SUB (ADVP-CNT (WADV why;{why}))
                                                      (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                                                      (HVP;~cat_Ve has;{have})
                                                      (IP-PPL-CAT (VVN proved;{prove})
                                                                  (ADJP-PRD2 (ADJ impossible;{impossible}))
                                                                  (IP-INF-NSBJ (TO to;{to})
                                                                               (VB find;{find})
                                                                               (NP-OB1 (D any;{any})
                                                                                       (NLYR (NP (N official;{official}))
                                                                                             (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                                                                    (NP (N Minister;{minister}))))
                                                                                       (IP-PPL (VVN prepared;{prepare})
                                                                                               (PP-CLR (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                                                                       (NP (N state;{state})
                                                                                                           (CP-THT (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                                                                                                           (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                   (NS reasons;{reason})
                                                                                                                                   (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                                                                                                       (NP (N Prorogation;{prorogation}))))
                                                                                                                           (BED;~cat_Vt were;{be})
                                                                                                                           (IP-INF-CAT (TO to;{to})
                                                                                                                                       (VB;~Tn.pr pave;{pave})
                                                                                                                                       (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                               (N way;{way}))
                                                                                                                                       (PP-CLR (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                                                                                                               (NP (NP-GENV (D a;{a})
                                                                                                                                                            (NPR Queen;{Queen})
                                                                                                                                                            (GENM <apos>s))
                                                                                                                                                   (N Speech;{speech}))))))))
                                                                                               (PUNC ,)
                                                                                               (PP-TMP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                       (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                           (N course;{course})
                                                                                                           (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                   (ADJP (ADJ current;{current}))
                                                                                                                   (ADJP (ADJ legal;{legal}))
                                                                                                                   (NS proceedings;{proceeding})
                                                                                                                   (IP-REL (PP-125 (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                                                   (NP (RPRO which;{which})))
                                                                                                                           (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                   (N Government;{government}))
                                                                                                                           (BEP;~cat_Ve_passive_ are;{be})
                                                                                                                           (IP-PPL-CAT (PP-CLR *ICH*-125)
                                                                                                                                       (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                                                                       (VVN involved;{involve})))))))))))))))
              (PUNC ?))
  (ID 25_a_major_case))