TSPC 25_a_major

25_a_major_case
“Mr Dominic Grieve (Beaconsfield) (Ind): In the light of the Prime Minister's answer to my right hon. Friend the Member for South West Hertfordshire (Mr Gauke), could the Prime Minister please explain why it has proved impossible to find any official or Minister prepared to state that the reasons for Prorogation were to pave the way for a Queen's Speech, in the course of the current legal proceedings in which the Government are involved?

( (CP-QUE-MAT (PULQ <ldquo>)
              (IP-SUB (META (NP (NPR Mr;{Mr})
                                (NPR Dominic;{Dominic})
                                (NPR Grieve;{Grieve})
                                (PRN (PULB -LRB-)
                                     (NP (NPR Beaconsfield;{Beaconsfield}))
                                     (PURB -RRB-))
                                (PRN (PULB -LRB-)
                                     (NP (NPR Ind;{Ind}))
                                     (PURB -RRB-)))
                            (PUNC :))
                      (PP-NIM (P-ROLE In;{in})
                              (NP (D the;{the})
                                  (N light;{light})
                                  (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                      (NP (NP-GEN;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
                                                            (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                                            (NPR Minister;{Minister})
                                                            (GENM <apos>s))
                                          (N answer;{answer})
                                          (PP (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                              (NP (NP-GEN (PRO;_genm_ my;{my}))
                                                  (ADJP (ADJ right;{right}))
                                                  (N hon<dot>)
                                                  (N Friend;{friend})
                                                  (PRN (NP (D the;{the})
                                                           (NPR Member;{Member})
                                                           (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                               (NP (NPR South;{South})
                                                                   (NPR West;{West})
                                                                   (NPR Hertfordshire;{Hertfordshire})))
                                                           (PULB -LRB-)
                                                           (PRN (NP;{PERSON} (NPR Mr;{Mr})
                                                                             (NPR Gauke;{Gauke})))
                                                           (PURB -RRB-)))))))))
                      (PUNC ,)
                      (MD;_cat_Vi_ could;{can})
                      (NP-SBJ;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
                                        (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                        (NPR Minister;{Minister}))
                      (IP-INF-CAT (FRM please)
                                  (VB;__ explain;{explain})
                                  (CP-QUE-OB1 (IP-SUB (ADVP-NIM (WADV why;{why}))
                                                      (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                                                      (HVP;_cat_Ve_ has;{have})
                                                      (IP-PPL-CAT (VVN;__ proved;{prove})
                                                                  (ADJP-PRD (ADJ impossible;{impossible}))
                                                                  (IP-INF-NSBJ (TO to;{to})
                                                                               (VB;__ find;{find})
                                                                               (NP-OB1 (D any;{any})
                                                                                       (NLYR (NLYR (N official;{official}))
                                                                                             (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                                                                    (NLYR (N Minister;{minister}))))
                                                                                       (IP-PPL (VVN;__ prepared;{prepare})
                                                                                               (PP-CLR (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                                                                       (NP (N state;{state})
                                                                                                           (CP-THT (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                                                                                                           (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                   (NS reasons;{reason})
                                                                                                                                   (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                                                                                                       (NP (N Prorogation;{prorogation}))))
                                                                                                                           (BED;_cat_Vt_ were;{be})
                                                                                                                           (IP-INF-CAT (TO to;{to})
                                                                                                                                       (VB;_Tn.pr_ pave;{pave})
                                                                                                                                       (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                               (N way;{way}))
                                                                                                                                       (PP-CLR (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                                                                                                               (NP (NP-GEN (D a;{a})
                                                                                                                                                           (NPR Queen;{Queen})
                                                                                                                                                           (GENM <apos>s))
                                                                                                                                                   (N Speech;{speech}))))))))
                                                                                               (PUNC ,)
                                                                                               (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                       (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                           (N course;{course})
                                                                                                           (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                   (ADJP (ADJ current;{current}))
                                                                                                                   (ADJP (ADJ legal;{legal}))
                                                                                                                   (NS proceedings;{proceeding})
                                                                                                                   (IP-REL (PP-125 (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                                                                   (NP (RPRO which;{which})))
                                                                                                                           (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                                   (N Government;{government}))
                                                                                                                           (BEP;_cat_VePASS_ are;{be})
                                                                                                                           (IP-PPL-CAT (PP-CLR *ICH*-125)
                                                                                                                                       (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                                                                       (VVN;__ involved;{involve})))))))))))))))
              (PUNC ?))
  (ID 25_a_major_case))

arc(r_0025_0013__the_r_0025_0014__light,r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0015__of).
arc(r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0016__the_r_0025_0017__Prime_r_0025_0018__Minister,gen).
arc(r_0025_0020__answer,r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0021__to).
arc(r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0022__my,gen).
arc(r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,r_0025_0023__right,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,r_0025_0029__South_r_0025_0030__West_r_0025_0031__Hertfordshire,r_0025_0028__for).
arc(r_0025_0037__could,r_0025_0013__the_r_0025_0014__light,r_0025_0012__In__nim).
arc(r_0025_0037__could,r_0025_0042__explain,scope).
arc(r_0025_0042__explain,r_0025_0016__the_r_0025_0017__Prime_r_0025_0018__Minister,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0042__explain,r_0025_0045__has,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0045__has,r_0025_0043__why,nim).
arc(r_0025_0045__has,r_0025_0046__proved,scope).
arc(r_0025_0046__proved,r_0025_0047__impossible,prd).
arc(r_0025_0046__proved,r_0025_0049__find,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0049__find,r_0025_0050__any_r_0025_0051__official_r_0025_0052__or_r_0025_0053__Minister,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0049__find,z_0025_5013,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0050__any_r_0025_0051__official_r_0025_0052__or_r_0025_0053__Minister,inv_arg0).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0056__state,r_0025_0055__to__clr).
arc(r_0025_0054__prepared,r_0025_0074__the_r_0025_0075__course,r_0025_0073__in__nim).
arc(r_0025_0056__state,r_0025_0062__were,emb).
arc(r_0025_0058__the_r_0025_0059__reasons,r_0025_0061__Prorogation,r_0025_0060__for).
arc(r_0025_0062__were,r_0025_0064__pave_r_0025_0067__for,scope).
arc(r_0025_0064__pave_r_0025_0067__for,r_0025_0058__the_r_0025_0059__reasons,arg0).
arc(r_0025_0064__pave_r_0025_0067__for,r_0025_0065__the_r_0025_0066__way,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0064__pave_r_0025_0067__for,r_0025_0071__Speech,arg2).
arc(r_0025_0071__Speech,r_0025_0068__a_r_0025_0069__Queen,gen).
arc(r_0025_0074__the_r_0025_0075__course,r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0076__of).
arc(r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0078__current,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0079__legal,attrib).
arc(r_0025_0085__are,r_0025_0086__involved,scope).
arc(r_0025_0086__involved,r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings,r_0025_0081__in__clr).
arc(r_0025_0086__involved,r_0025_0083__the_r_0025_0084__Government,arg1).
arc(r_0025_0086__involved,z_0025_5032___star_,arg0).
arc(z_0025_5005,r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,arg0).
arc(z_0025_5005,r_0025_0033__Mr_r_0025_0034__Gauke,prd).
arc(z_0025_5007,r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend,arg0).
arc(z_0025_5007,r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member,prd).

fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_0025_0016__THE_R_0025_0017__PRIME_R_0025_0018__MINISTER,R_0025_0022__MY,R_0025_0023__RIGHT,R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND,R_0025_0020__ANSWER,R_0025_0013__THE_R_0025_0014__LIGHT,R_0025_0043__WHY,R_0025_0047__IMPOSSIBLE,R_0025_0061__PROROGATION,R_0025_0058__THE_R_0025_0059__REASONS,R_0025_0065__THE_R_0025_0066__WAY,R_0025_0068__A_R_0025_0069__QUEEN,R_0025_0071__SPEECH,R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR,R_0025_0056__STATE,R_0025_0078__CURRENT,R_0025_0079__LEGAL,R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS,R_0025_0074__THE_R_0025_0075__COURSE,R_0025_0054__PREPARED,R_0025_0050__ANY_R_0025_0051__OFFICIAL_R_0025_0052__OR_R_0025_0053__MINISTER,Z_0025_5013,R_0025_0049__FIND,R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED,R_0025_0037__COULD_R_0025_0042__EXPLAIN,R_0025_0083__THE_R_0025_0084__GOVERNMENT,Z_0025_5032___STAR_,R_0025_0085__ARE_R_0025_0086__INVOLVED,R_0025_0029__SOUTH_R_0025_0030__WEST_R_0025_0031__HERTFORDSHIRE,R_0025_0026__THE_R_0025_0027__MEMBER,R_0025_0033__MR_R_0025_0034__GAUKE,Z_0025_5005,Z_0025_5007] :
      ( r_0025_0016__the_r_0025_0017__Prime_r_0025_0018__Minister(R_0025_0016__THE_R_0025_0017__PRIME_R_0025_0018__MINISTER)
      & r_0025_0022__my(R_0025_0022__MY)
      & r_0025_0023__right(R_0025_0023__RIGHT)
      & r_0025_0029__South_r_0025_0030__West_r_0025_0031__Hertfordshire(R_0025_0029__SOUTH_R_0025_0030__WEST_R_0025_0031__HERTFORDSHIRE)
      & r_0025_0033__Mr_r_0025_0034__Gauke(R_0025_0033__MR_R_0025_0034__GAUKE)
      & r_0025_0043__why(R_0025_0043__WHY)
      & r_0025_0047__impossible(R_0025_0047__IMPOSSIBLE)
      & r_0025_0061__Prorogation(R_0025_0061__PROROGATION)
      & r_0025_0065__the_r_0025_0066__way(R_0025_0065__THE_R_0025_0066__WAY)
      & r_0025_0068__a_r_0025_0069__Queen(R_0025_0068__A_R_0025_0069__QUEEN)
      & r_0025_0078__current(R_0025_0078__CURRENT)
      & r_0025_0079__legal(R_0025_0079__LEGAL)
      & r_0025_0083__the_r_0025_0084__Government(R_0025_0083__THE_R_0025_0084__GOVERNMENT)
      & z_0025_5013(Z_0025_5013)
      & z_0025_5032___star_(Z_0025_5032___STAR_)
      & z_0025_5007(Z_0025_5007)
      & has_prd(Z_0025_5007,R_0025_0026__THE_R_0025_0027__MEMBER)
      & r_0025_0026__the_r_0025_0027__Member(R_0025_0026__THE_R_0025_0027__MEMBER)
      & has_r_0025_0028__for(R_0025_0026__THE_R_0025_0027__MEMBER,R_0025_0029__SOUTH_R_0025_0030__WEST_R_0025_0031__HERTFORDSHIRE)
      & has_arg0(Z_0025_5007,R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND)
      & r_0025_0024__hon_dot__r_0025_0025__Friend(R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND)
      & has_attrib(R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND,R_0025_0023__RIGHT)
      & has_gen(R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND,R_0025_0022__MY)
      & z_0025_5005(Z_0025_5005)
      & has_prd(Z_0025_5005,R_0025_0033__MR_R_0025_0034__GAUKE)
      & has_arg0(Z_0025_5005,R_0025_0026__THE_R_0025_0027__MEMBER)
      & r_0025_0085__are_r_0025_0086__involved(R_0025_0085__ARE_R_0025_0086__INVOLVED)
      & has_arg0(R_0025_0085__ARE_R_0025_0086__INVOLVED,Z_0025_5032___STAR_)
      & has_arg1(R_0025_0085__ARE_R_0025_0086__INVOLVED,R_0025_0083__THE_R_0025_0084__GOVERNMENT)
      & has_r_0025_0081__in__clr(R_0025_0085__ARE_R_0025_0086__INVOLVED,R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS)
      & r_0025_0077__the_r_0025_0080__proceedings(R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS)
      & has_attrib(R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS,R_0025_0079__LEGAL)
      & has_attrib(R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS,R_0025_0078__CURRENT)
      & r_0025_0037__could_r_0025_0042__explain(R_0025_0037__COULD_R_0025_0042__EXPLAIN)
      & has_arg1(R_0025_0037__COULD_R_0025_0042__EXPLAIN,R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED)
      & r_0025_0045__has_r_0025_0046__proved(R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED)
      & has_arg0(R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED,R_0025_0049__FIND)
      & r_0025_0049__find(R_0025_0049__FIND)
      & has_arg0(R_0025_0049__FIND,Z_0025_5013)
      & has_arg1(R_0025_0049__FIND,R_0025_0050__ANY_R_0025_0051__OFFICIAL_R_0025_0052__OR_R_0025_0053__MINISTER)
      & r_0025_0050__any_r_0025_0051__official_r_0025_0052__or_r_0025_0053__Minister(R_0025_0050__ANY_R_0025_0051__OFFICIAL_R_0025_0052__OR_R_0025_0053__MINISTER)
      & has_inv_arg0(R_0025_0050__ANY_R_0025_0051__OFFICIAL_R_0025_0052__OR_R_0025_0053__MINISTER,R_0025_0054__PREPARED)
      & r_0025_0054__prepared(R_0025_0054__PREPARED)
      & has_r_0025_0073__in__nim(R_0025_0054__PREPARED,R_0025_0074__THE_R_0025_0075__COURSE)
      & r_0025_0074__the_r_0025_0075__course(R_0025_0074__THE_R_0025_0075__COURSE)
      & has_r_0025_0076__of(R_0025_0074__THE_R_0025_0075__COURSE,R_0025_0077__THE_R_0025_0080__PROCEEDINGS)
      & has_r_0025_0055__to__clr(R_0025_0054__PREPARED,R_0025_0056__STATE)
      & r_0025_0056__state(R_0025_0056__STATE)
      & has_emb(R_0025_0056__STATE,R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR)
      & r_0025_0062__were_r_0025_0064__pave_r_0025_0067__for(R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR)
      & has_arg2(R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR,R_0025_0071__SPEECH)
      & r_0025_0071__Speech(R_0025_0071__SPEECH)
      & has_gen(R_0025_0071__SPEECH,R_0025_0068__A_R_0025_0069__QUEEN)
      & has_arg1(R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR,R_0025_0065__THE_R_0025_0066__WAY)
      & has_arg0(R_0025_0062__WERE_R_0025_0064__PAVE_R_0025_0067__FOR,R_0025_0058__THE_R_0025_0059__REASONS)
      & r_0025_0058__the_r_0025_0059__reasons(R_0025_0058__THE_R_0025_0059__REASONS)
      & has_r_0025_0060__for(R_0025_0058__THE_R_0025_0059__REASONS,R_0025_0061__PROROGATION)
      & has_prd(R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED,R_0025_0047__IMPOSSIBLE)
      & has_nim(R_0025_0045__HAS_R_0025_0046__PROVED,R_0025_0043__WHY)
      & has_arg0(R_0025_0037__COULD_R_0025_0042__EXPLAIN,R_0025_0016__THE_R_0025_0017__PRIME_R_0025_0018__MINISTER)
      & has_r_0025_0012__In__nim(R_0025_0037__COULD_R_0025_0042__EXPLAIN,R_0025_0013__THE_R_0025_0014__LIGHT)
      & r_0025_0013__the_r_0025_0014__light(R_0025_0013__THE_R_0025_0014__LIGHT)
      & has_r_0025_0015__of(R_0025_0013__THE_R_0025_0014__LIGHT,R_0025_0020__ANSWER)
      & r_0025_0020__answer(R_0025_0020__ANSWER)
      & has_r_0025_0021__to(R_0025_0020__ANSWER,R_0025_0024__HON_DOT__R_0025_0025__FRIEND)
      & has_gen(R_0025_0020__ANSWER,R_0025_0016__THE_R_0025_0017__PRIME_R_0025_0018__MINISTER) ) ).