31_a_major_case
In any normal case, it would be all but inconceivable that a court in these circumstances would reach any conclusion other than that (i) the “legislative programme” explanation must be, at best, materially incomplete, and (ii) the decision was in fact substantially motivated by a desire to obstruct Parliament from interfering with the Prime Minister's plans.
%3
r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case
any case
r_0031_0003__normal
normal
r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case->r_0031_0003__normal
[attrib]
r_0031_0007__would
would
r_0031_0007__would->r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case
In [nim]
r_0031_0008__be
be
r_0031_0007__would->r_0031_0008__be
[scope]
r_0031_0010__inconceivable
inconceivable
r_0031_0008__be->r_0031_0010__inconceivable
[prd]
r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would
that would
r_0031_0008__be->r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would
[arg0]
r_0031_0009__all_but
all but
r_0031_0010__inconceivable->r_0031_0009__all_but
[qual]
r_0031_0018__reach
reach
r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would->r_0031_0018__reach
[scope]
r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court
a court
r_0031_0018__reach->r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court
[arg0]
r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion
any conclusion
r_0031_0018__reach->r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion
[arg1]
r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances
these circumstances
r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court->r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances
in
r_0031_0021__other
other
r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion->r_0031_0021__other
[attrib]
arc(r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case, r_0031_0003__normal, attrib8).
arc(r_0031_0007__would, r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case, r_0031_0001__In_nim5).
arc(r_0031_0007__would, r_0031_0008__be, scope).
arc(r_0031_0008__be, r_0031_0010__inconceivable, prd).
arc(r_0031_0008__be, r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would, arg0).
arc(r_0031_0010__inconceivable, r_0031_0009__all_but, qual24).
arc(r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would, r_0031_0018__reach, scope).
arc(r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court, r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances, r_0031_0014__in).
arc(r_0031_0018__reach, r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court, arg0).
arc(r_0031_0018__reach, r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion, arg1).
arc(r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion, r_0031_0021__other, attrib56).
%3
r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case
any case
r_0031_0003__normal
normal
r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case->r_0031_0003__normal
[attrib]
r_0031_0007__would_r_0031_0008__be
would be
r_0031_0007__would_r_0031_0008__be->r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case
In [nim]
r_0031_0010__inconceivable
inconceivable
r_0031_0007__would_r_0031_0008__be->r_0031_0010__inconceivable
[prd]
r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would_r_0031_0018__reach
that would reach
r_0031_0007__would_r_0031_0008__be->r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would_r_0031_0018__reach
[arg0]
r_0031_0009__all_but
all but
r_0031_0010__inconceivable->r_0031_0009__all_but
[qual]
r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court
a court
r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would_r_0031_0018__reach->r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court
[arg0]
r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion
any conclusion
r_0031_0011__that_r_0031_0017__would_r_0031_0018__reach->r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion
[arg1]
r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances
these circumstances
r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court->r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances
in
r_0031_0021__other
other
r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion->r_0031_0021__other
[attrib]
fof(formula,axiom,
? [R_31_7_WOULD_BE,R_31_11_THAT_WOULD_REACH,R_31_12_A_COURT,R_31_15_THESE_CIRCUMSTANCES,R_31_19_ANY_CONCLUSION,R_31_21_OTHER,R_31_10_INCONCEIVABLE,R_31_9_ALL_BUT,R_31_2_ANY_CASE,R_31_3_NORMAL] :
( these_circumstances(R_31_15_THESE_CIRCUMSTANCES)
& other(R_31_21_OTHER)
& all_but(R_31_9_ALL_BUT)
& normal(R_31_3_NORMAL)
& would_be(R_31_7_WOULD_BE,R_31_11_THAT_WOULD_REACH,R_31_10_INCONCEIVABLE)
& that_would_reach(R_31_11_THAT_WOULD_REACH,R_31_12_A_COURT,R_31_19_ANY_CONCLUSION)
& a_court(R_31_12_A_COURT)
& in(R_31_12_A_COURT,R_31_15_THESE_CIRCUMSTANCES)
& any_conclusion(R_31_19_ANY_CONCLUSION)
& attrib56(R_31_19_ANY_CONCLUSION,R_31_21_OTHER)
& inconceivable(R_31_10_INCONCEIVABLE)
& qual24(R_31_10_INCONCEIVABLE,R_31_9_ALL_BUT)
& in_nim5(R_31_7_WOULD_BE,R_31_2_ANY_CASE)
& any_case(R_31_2_ANY_CASE)
& attrib8(R_31_2_ANY_CASE,R_31_3_NORMAL) ) ).
n31_a_major_case
n31_a_major_case_4
In
n31_a_major_case_7
any
n31_a_major_case_10
normal
n31_a_major_case_12
case
n31_a_major_case_14
,
n31_a_major_case_17
it
n31_a_major_case_19
would
n31_a_major_case_22
be
n31_a_major_case_26
all_but
n31_a_major_case_28
inconceivable
n31_a_major_case_32
that
n31_a_major_case_35
a
n31_a_major_case_37
court
n31_a_major_case_40
in
n31_a_major_case_43
these
n31_a_major_case_45
circumstances
n31_a_major_case_47
would
n31_a_major_case_50
reach
n31_a_major_case_53
any
n31_a_major_case_55
conclusion
n31_a_major_case_58
other
n31_a_major_case_61
than
n31_a_major_case_65
that
n31_a_major_case_70
-LRB-
n31_a_major_case_72
i
n31_a_major_case_74
-RRB-
n31_a_major_case_77
the
n31_a_major_case_79
<ldquo>
n31_a_major_case_82
legislative
n31_a_major_case_84
programme
n31_a_major_case_86
<rdquo>
n31_a_major_case_88
explanation
n31_a_major_case_90
must
n31_a_major_case_93
be
n31_a_major_case_95
,
n31_a_major_case_98
at_best
n31_a_major_case_100
,
n31_a_major_case_104
materially
n31_a_major_case_106
incomplete
n31_a_major_case_108
,
n31_a_major_case_111
and
n31_a_major_case_115
-LRB-
n31_a_major_case_117
ii
n31_a_major_case_119
-RRB-
n31_a_major_case_122
the
n31_a_major_case_124
decision
n31_a_major_case_126
was
n31_a_major_case_129
in_fact
n31_a_major_case_133
substantially
n31_a_major_case_135
motivated
n31_a_major_case_138
by
n31_a_major_case_141
a
n31_a_major_case_143
desire
n31_a_major_case_146
to
n31_a_major_case_148
obstruct
n31_a_major_case_151
Parliament
n31_a_major_case_154
from
n31_a_major_case_157
interfering
n31_a_major_case_160
with
n31_a_major_case_164
the
n31_a_major_case_166
Prime
n31_a_major_case_168
Minister
n31_a_major_case_170
's
n31_a_major_case_172
plans
n31_a_major_case_174
.
n31_a_major_case_1
IP-MAT
n31_a_major_case_2
PP-NIM
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_2
n31_a_major_case_13
PUNC
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_13
n31_a_major_case_15
NP-SBJ
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_15
n31_a_major_case_18
MD;_cat_Vi_
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_18
n31_a_major_case_20
IP-INF-CAT
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_20
n31_a_major_case_173
PUNC
n31_a_major_case_1->n31_a_major_case_173
n31_a_major_case_3
P-ROLE
n31_a_major_case_2->n31_a_major_case_3
n31_a_major_case_5
NP
n31_a_major_case_2->n31_a_major_case_5
n31_a_major_case_3->n31_a_major_case_4
n31_a_major_case_6
D
n31_a_major_case_5->n31_a_major_case_6
n31_a_major_case_8
ADJP
n31_a_major_case_5->n31_a_major_case_8
n31_a_major_case_11
N
n31_a_major_case_5->n31_a_major_case_11
n31_a_major_case_6->n31_a_major_case_7
n31_a_major_case_9
ADJ
n31_a_major_case_8->n31_a_major_case_9
n31_a_major_case_9->n31_a_major_case_10
n31_a_major_case_11->n31_a_major_case_12
n31_a_major_case_13->n31_a_major_case_14
n31_a_major_case_16
PRO;_provisional_
n31_a_major_case_15->n31_a_major_case_16
n31_a_major_case_16->n31_a_major_case_17
n31_a_major_case_18->n31_a_major_case_19
n31_a_major_case_21
BE;_La_
n31_a_major_case_20->n31_a_major_case_21
n31_a_major_case_23
ADJP-PRD
n31_a_major_case_20->n31_a_major_case_23
n31_a_major_case_29
CP-THT-NSBJ
n31_a_major_case_20->n31_a_major_case_29
n31_a_major_case_21->n31_a_major_case_22
n31_a_major_case_24
ADVP
n31_a_major_case_23->n31_a_major_case_24
n31_a_major_case_27
ADJ
n31_a_major_case_23->n31_a_major_case_27
n31_a_major_case_25
ADV
n31_a_major_case_24->n31_a_major_case_25
n31_a_major_case_25->n31_a_major_case_26
n31_a_major_case_27->n31_a_major_case_28
n31_a_major_case_30
IP-SUB
n31_a_major_case_29->n31_a_major_case_30
n31_a_major_case_31
C
n31_a_major_case_30->n31_a_major_case_31
n31_a_major_case_33
NP-SBJ
n31_a_major_case_30->n31_a_major_case_33
n31_a_major_case_46
MD;_cat_Vi_
n31_a_major_case_30->n31_a_major_case_46
n31_a_major_case_48
IP-INF-CAT
n31_a_major_case_30->n31_a_major_case_48
n31_a_major_case_31->n31_a_major_case_32
n31_a_major_case_34
D
n31_a_major_case_33->n31_a_major_case_34
n31_a_major_case_36
N
n31_a_major_case_33->n31_a_major_case_36
n31_a_major_case_38
PP
n31_a_major_case_33->n31_a_major_case_38
n31_a_major_case_34->n31_a_major_case_35
n31_a_major_case_36->n31_a_major_case_37
n31_a_major_case_39
P-ROLE
n31_a_major_case_38->n31_a_major_case_39
n31_a_major_case_41
NP
n31_a_major_case_38->n31_a_major_case_41
n31_a_major_case_39->n31_a_major_case_40
n31_a_major_case_42
D
n31_a_major_case_41->n31_a_major_case_42
n31_a_major_case_44
NS
n31_a_major_case_41->n31_a_major_case_44
n31_a_major_case_42->n31_a_major_case_43
n31_a_major_case_44->n31_a_major_case_45
n31_a_major_case_46->n31_a_major_case_47
n31_a_major_case_49
VB;__
n31_a_major_case_48->n31_a_major_case_49
n31_a_major_case_51
NP-OB1
n31_a_major_case_48->n31_a_major_case_51
n31_a_major_case_49->n31_a_major_case_50
n31_a_major_case_52
D
n31_a_major_case_51->n31_a_major_case_52
n31_a_major_case_54
N
n31_a_major_case_51->n31_a_major_case_54
n31_a_major_case_56
ADJP
n31_a_major_case_51->n31_a_major_case_56
n31_a_major_case_52->n31_a_major_case_53
n31_a_major_case_54->n31_a_major_case_55
n31_a_major_case_57
ADJ
n31_a_major_case_56->n31_a_major_case_57
n31_a_major_case_59
PP
n31_a_major_case_56->n31_a_major_case_59
n31_a_major_case_57->n31_a_major_case_58
n31_a_major_case_60
P-ROLE
n31_a_major_case_59->n31_a_major_case_60
n31_a_major_case_62
CP-THT
n31_a_major_case_59->n31_a_major_case_62
n31_a_major_case_60->n31_a_major_case_61
n31_a_major_case_63
IP-SUB
n31_a_major_case_62->n31_a_major_case_63
n31_a_major_case_64
C
n31_a_major_case_63->n31_a_major_case_64
n31_a_major_case_66
ILYR
n31_a_major_case_63->n31_a_major_case_66
n31_a_major_case_64->n31_a_major_case_65
n31_a_major_case_67
ILYR
n31_a_major_case_66->n31_a_major_case_67
n31_a_major_case_107
PUNC
n31_a_major_case_66->n31_a_major_case_107
n31_a_major_case_109
CONJP
n31_a_major_case_66->n31_a_major_case_109
n31_a_major_case_68
LST
n31_a_major_case_67->n31_a_major_case_68
n31_a_major_case_75
NP-SBJ
n31_a_major_case_67->n31_a_major_case_75
n31_a_major_case_89
MD;_cat_Vi_
n31_a_major_case_67->n31_a_major_case_89
n31_a_major_case_91
IP-INF-CAT
n31_a_major_case_67->n31_a_major_case_91
n31_a_major_case_69
PULB
n31_a_major_case_68->n31_a_major_case_69
n31_a_major_case_71
LS
n31_a_major_case_68->n31_a_major_case_71
n31_a_major_case_73
PURB
n31_a_major_case_68->n31_a_major_case_73
n31_a_major_case_69->n31_a_major_case_70
n31_a_major_case_71->n31_a_major_case_72
n31_a_major_case_73->n31_a_major_case_74
n31_a_major_case_76
D
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_76
n31_a_major_case_78
PULQ
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_78
n31_a_major_case_80
ADJP
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_80
n31_a_major_case_83
N
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_83
n31_a_major_case_85
PURQ
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_85
n31_a_major_case_87
N
n31_a_major_case_75->n31_a_major_case_87
n31_a_major_case_76->n31_a_major_case_77
n31_a_major_case_78->n31_a_major_case_79
n31_a_major_case_81
ADJ
n31_a_major_case_80->n31_a_major_case_81
n31_a_major_case_81->n31_a_major_case_82
n31_a_major_case_83->n31_a_major_case_84
n31_a_major_case_85->n31_a_major_case_86
n31_a_major_case_87->n31_a_major_case_88
n31_a_major_case_89->n31_a_major_case_90
n31_a_major_case_92
BE;_La_
n31_a_major_case_91->n31_a_major_case_92
n31_a_major_case_94
PUNC
n31_a_major_case_91->n31_a_major_case_94
n31_a_major_case_96
ADVP-NIM
n31_a_major_case_91->n31_a_major_case_96
n31_a_major_case_99
PUNC
n31_a_major_case_91->n31_a_major_case_99
n31_a_major_case_101
ADJP-PRD
n31_a_major_case_91->n31_a_major_case_101
n31_a_major_case_92->n31_a_major_case_93
n31_a_major_case_94->n31_a_major_case_95
n31_a_major_case_97
ADV
n31_a_major_case_96->n31_a_major_case_97
n31_a_major_case_97->n31_a_major_case_98
n31_a_major_case_99->n31_a_major_case_100
n31_a_major_case_102
ADVP
n31_a_major_case_101->n31_a_major_case_102
n31_a_major_case_105
ADJ
n31_a_major_case_101->n31_a_major_case_105
n31_a_major_case_103
ADV
n31_a_major_case_102->n31_a_major_case_103
n31_a_major_case_103->n31_a_major_case_104
n31_a_major_case_105->n31_a_major_case_106
n31_a_major_case_107->n31_a_major_case_108
n31_a_major_case_110
CONJ
n31_a_major_case_109->n31_a_major_case_110
n31_a_major_case_112
ILYR
n31_a_major_case_109->n31_a_major_case_112
n31_a_major_case_110->n31_a_major_case_111
n31_a_major_case_113
LST
n31_a_major_case_112->n31_a_major_case_113
n31_a_major_case_120
NP-SBJ
n31_a_major_case_112->n31_a_major_case_120
n31_a_major_case_125
BED;_cat_VePASS_
n31_a_major_case_112->n31_a_major_case_125
n31_a_major_case_127
ADVP-NIM
n31_a_major_case_112->n31_a_major_case_127
n31_a_major_case_130
IP-PPL-CAT
n31_a_major_case_112->n31_a_major_case_130
n31_a_major_case_114
PULB
n31_a_major_case_113->n31_a_major_case_114
n31_a_major_case_116
LS
n31_a_major_case_113->n31_a_major_case_116
n31_a_major_case_118
PURB
n31_a_major_case_113->n31_a_major_case_118
n31_a_major_case_114->n31_a_major_case_115
n31_a_major_case_116->n31_a_major_case_117
n31_a_major_case_118->n31_a_major_case_119
n31_a_major_case_121
D
n31_a_major_case_120->n31_a_major_case_121
n31_a_major_case_123
N
n31_a_major_case_120->n31_a_major_case_123
n31_a_major_case_121->n31_a_major_case_122
n31_a_major_case_123->n31_a_major_case_124
n31_a_major_case_125->n31_a_major_case_126
n31_a_major_case_128
ADV
n31_a_major_case_127->n31_a_major_case_128
n31_a_major_case_128->n31_a_major_case_129
n31_a_major_case_131
ADVP-NIM
n31_a_major_case_130->n31_a_major_case_131
n31_a_major_case_134
VVN;__
n31_a_major_case_130->n31_a_major_case_134
n31_a_major_case_136
PP-LGS
n31_a_major_case_130->n31_a_major_case_136
n31_a_major_case_132
ADV
n31_a_major_case_131->n31_a_major_case_132
n31_a_major_case_132->n31_a_major_case_133
n31_a_major_case_134->n31_a_major_case_135
n31_a_major_case_137
P-ROLE;_lgs_
n31_a_major_case_136->n31_a_major_case_137
n31_a_major_case_139
NP
n31_a_major_case_136->n31_a_major_case_139
n31_a_major_case_137->n31_a_major_case_138
n31_a_major_case_140
D
n31_a_major_case_139->n31_a_major_case_140
n31_a_major_case_142
N
n31_a_major_case_139->n31_a_major_case_142
n31_a_major_case_144
IP-INF
n31_a_major_case_139->n31_a_major_case_144
n31_a_major_case_140->n31_a_major_case_141
n31_a_major_case_142->n31_a_major_case_143
n31_a_major_case_145
TO
n31_a_major_case_144->n31_a_major_case_145
n31_a_major_case_147
VB;__
n31_a_major_case_144->n31_a_major_case_147
n31_a_major_case_149
NP-OB1
n31_a_major_case_144->n31_a_major_case_149
n31_a_major_case_152
PP-NIM
n31_a_major_case_144->n31_a_major_case_152
n31_a_major_case_145->n31_a_major_case_146
n31_a_major_case_147->n31_a_major_case_148
n31_a_major_case_150
NPR
n31_a_major_case_149->n31_a_major_case_150
n31_a_major_case_150->n31_a_major_case_151
n31_a_major_case_153
P-ROLE
n31_a_major_case_152->n31_a_major_case_153
n31_a_major_case_155
IP-PPL
n31_a_major_case_152->n31_a_major_case_155
n31_a_major_case_153->n31_a_major_case_154
n31_a_major_case_156
VAG;__
n31_a_major_case_155->n31_a_major_case_156
n31_a_major_case_158
PP-CLR
n31_a_major_case_155->n31_a_major_case_158
n31_a_major_case_156->n31_a_major_case_157
n31_a_major_case_159
P-ROLE
n31_a_major_case_158->n31_a_major_case_159
n31_a_major_case_161
NP
n31_a_major_case_158->n31_a_major_case_161
n31_a_major_case_159->n31_a_major_case_160
n31_a_major_case_162
NP-GEN
n31_a_major_case_161->n31_a_major_case_162
n31_a_major_case_171
NS
n31_a_major_case_161->n31_a_major_case_171
n31_a_major_case_163
D
n31_a_major_case_162->n31_a_major_case_163
n31_a_major_case_165
NPR
n31_a_major_case_162->n31_a_major_case_165
n31_a_major_case_167
NPR
n31_a_major_case_162->n31_a_major_case_167
n31_a_major_case_169
GENM
n31_a_major_case_162->n31_a_major_case_169
n31_a_major_case_163->n31_a_major_case_164
n31_a_major_case_165->n31_a_major_case_166
n31_a_major_case_167->n31_a_major_case_168
n31_a_major_case_169->n31_a_major_case_170
n31_a_major_case_171->n31_a_major_case_172
n31_a_major_case_173->n31_a_major_case_174
( (IP-MAT (PP-NIM (P-ROLE In;{in})
(NP (D any;{any})
(ADJP (ADJ normal;{normal}))
(N case;{case})))
(PUNC ,)
(NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
(MD;_cat_Vi_ would;{will})
(IP-INF-CAT (BE;_La_ be;{be})
(ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV all_but;{all_but}))
(ADJ inconceivable;{inconceivable}))
(CP-THT-NSBJ (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(NP-SBJ (D a;{a})
(N court;{court})
(PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
(NP (D these;{these})
(NS circumstances;{circumstance}))))
(MD;_cat_Vi_ would;{will})
(IP-INF-CAT (VB;__ reach;{reach})
(NP-OB1 (D any;{any})
(N conclusion;{conclusion})
(ADJP (ADJ other;{other})
(PP (P-ROLE than;{than})
(CP-THT (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(ILYR (ILYR (LST (PULB -LRB-)
(LS i)
(PURB -RRB-))
(NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
(PULQ <ldquo>)
(ADJP (ADJ legislative;{legislative}))
(N programme;{programme})
(PURQ <rdquo>)
(N explanation;{explanation}))
(MD;_cat_Vi_ must;{must})
(IP-INF-CAT (BE;_La_ be;{be})
(PUNC ,)
(ADVP-NIM (ADV at_best;{at_best}))
(PUNC ,)
(ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV materially;{materially}))
(ADJ incomplete;{incomplete}))))
(PUNC ,)
(CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
(ILYR (LST (PULB -LRB-)
(LS ii)
(PURB -RRB-))
(NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
(N decision;{decision}))
(BED;_cat_VePASS_ was;{be})
(ADVP-NIM (ADV in_fact;{in_fact}))
(IP-PPL-CAT (ADVP-NIM (ADV substantially;{substantially}))
(VVN;__ motivated;{motivate})
(PP-LGS (P-ROLE;_lgs_ by;{by})
(NP (D a;{a})
(N desire;{desire})
(IP-INF (TO to;{to})
(VB;__ obstruct;{obstruct})
(NP-OB1 (NPR Parliament;{Parliament}))
(PP-NIM (P-ROLE from;{from})
(IP-PPL (VAG;__ interfering;{interfere})
(PP-CLR (P-ROLE with;{with})
(NP (NP-GEN;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
(NPR Prime;{Prime})
(NPR Minister;{Minister})
(GENM <apos>s))
(NS plans;{plan})))))))))))))))))))))
(PUNC .))
(ID 31_a_major_case))