31_a_major_case
In any normal case, it would be all but inconceivable that a court in these circumstances would reach any conclusion other than that (i) the “legislative programme” explanation must be, at best, materially incomplete, and (ii) the decision was in fact substantially motivated by a desire to obstruct Parliament from interfering with the Prime Minister's plans.
0031_0002__any_0031_0004__case
any_case
0031_0003__normal
normal
0031_0002__any_0031_0004__case->0031_0003__normal
[attrib]
0031_0007__would
would
0031_0007__would->0031_0002__any_0031_0004__case
in[nim]
0031_0008__be
be
0031_0007__would->0031_0008__be
[scope]
0031_0010__inconceivable
inconceivable
0031_0008__be->0031_0010__inconceivable
[prd]
0031_0017__would
would
0031_0008__be->0031_0017__would
[arg0]
0031_0009__all_but
all_but
0031_0010__inconceivable->0031_0009__all_but
[qual]
0031_0018__reach
reach
0031_0017__would->0031_0018__reach
[scope]
0031_0012__a_0031_0013__court
a_court
0031_0015__these_0031_0016__circumstances
these_circumstances
0031_0012__a_0031_0013__court->0031_0015__these_0031_0016__circumstances
in
0031_0018__reach->0031_0012__a_0031_0013__court
[arg0]
0031_0019__any_0031_0020__conclusion
any_conclusion
0031_0018__reach->0031_0019__any_0031_0020__conclusion
[arg1]
0031_0021__other
other
0031_0019__any_0031_0020__conclusion->0031_0021__other
[attrib]
0031_0041__and
and
0031_0021__other->0031_0041__and
than
0031_0033__must
must
0031_0041__and->0031_0033__must
[conj1]
0031_0047__was
was
0031_0041__and->0031_0047__was
[conj2]
0031_0027__the_0031_0030__programme_0031_0032__explanation
the_programme_explanation
0031_0029__legislative
legislative
0031_0027__the_0031_0030__programme_0031_0032__explanation->0031_0029__legislative
[attrib]
0031_0034__be
be
0031_0033__must->0031_0034__be
[scope]
0031_0034__be->0031_0027__the_0031_0030__programme_0031_0032__explanation
[arg0]
0031_0036__at_best
at_best
0031_0034__be->0031_0036__at_best
[nim]
0031_0039__incomplete
incomplete
0031_0034__be->0031_0039__incomplete
[prd]
0031_0038__materially
materially
0031_0039__incomplete->0031_0038__materially
[qual]
0031_0048__in_fact
in_fact
0031_0047__was->0031_0048__in_fact
[nim]
0031_0050__motivated
motivated
0031_0047__was->0031_0050__motivated
[scope]
0031_0045__the_0031_0046__decision
the_decision
0031_0050__motivated->0031_0045__the_0031_0046__decision
[arg1]
0031_0049__substantially
substantially
0031_0050__motivated->0031_0049__substantially
[nim]
0031_0052__a_0031_0053__desire
a_desire
0031_0050__motivated->0031_0052__a_0031_0053__desire
by[arg0]
0031_0055__obstruct
obstruct
0031_0052__a_0031_0053__desire->0031_0055__obstruct
[emb]
0031_0056__Parliament
parliament
0031_0055__obstruct->0031_0056__Parliament
[arg1]
0031_0058__interfering
interfering
0031_0055__obstruct->0031_0058__interfering
from[nim]
z_0031_5026
_
0031_0055__obstruct->z_0031_5026
[arg0]
0031_0058__interfering->0031_0056__Parliament
[arg0]
0031_0064__plans
plans
0031_0058__interfering->0031_0064__plans
with[clr]
0031_0060__the_0031_0061__Prime_0031_0062__Minister
the_prime_minister
0031_0064__plans->0031_0060__the_0031_0061__Prime_0031_0062__Minister
[gen]
arc(r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case,r_0031_0003__normal,attrib).
arc(r_0031_0007__would,r_0031_0002__any_r_0031_0004__case,r_0031_0001__In__nim).
arc(r_0031_0007__would,r_0031_0008__be,keep_scope).
arc(r_0031_0008__be,r_0031_0010__inconceivable,prd).
arc(r_0031_0008__be,r_0031_0017__would,arg0).
arc(r_0031_0010__inconceivable,r_0031_0009__all_but,qual).
arc(r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court,r_0031_0015__these_r_0031_0016__circumstances,r_0031_0014__in).
arc(r_0031_0017__would,r_0031_0018__reach,keep_scope).
arc(r_0031_0018__reach,r_0031_0012__a_r_0031_0013__court,arg0).
arc(r_0031_0018__reach,r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion,arg1).
arc(r_0031_0019__any_r_0031_0020__conclusion,r_0031_0021__other,attrib).
arc(r_0031_0021__other,r_0031_0041__and,r_0031_0022__than).
arc(r_0031_0027__the_r_0031_0030__programme_r_0031_0032__explanation,r_0031_0029__legislative,attrib).
arc(r_0031_0033__must,r_0031_0034__be,keep_scope).
arc(r_0031_0034__be,r_0031_0027__the_r_0031_0030__programme_r_0031_0032__explanation,arg0).
arc(r_0031_0034__be,r_0031_0036__at_best,nim).
arc(r_0031_0034__be,r_0031_0039__incomplete,prd).
arc(r_0031_0039__incomplete,r_0031_0038__materially,qual).
arc(r_0031_0041__and,r_0031_0033__must,conj1).
arc(r_0031_0041__and,r_0031_0047__was,conj2).
arc(r_0031_0047__was,r_0031_0048__in_fact,nim).
arc(r_0031_0047__was,r_0031_0050__motivated,keep_scope).
arc(r_0031_0050__motivated,r_0031_0045__the_r_0031_0046__decision,arg1).
arc(r_0031_0050__motivated,r_0031_0049__substantially,nim).
arc(r_0031_0050__motivated,r_0031_0052__a_r_0031_0053__desire,r_0031_0051__by_arg0).
arc(r_0031_0052__a_r_0031_0053__desire,r_0031_0055__obstruct,emb).
arc(r_0031_0055__obstruct,r_0031_0056__Parliament,arg1).
arc(r_0031_0055__obstruct,r_0031_0058__interfering,r_0031_0057__from__nim).
arc(r_0031_0055__obstruct,z_0031_5026,arg0).
arc(r_0031_0058__interfering,r_0031_0056__Parliament,arg0).
arc(r_0031_0058__interfering,r_0031_0064__plans,r_0031_0059__with__clr).
arc(r_0031_0064__plans,r_0031_0060__the_r_0031_0061__Prime_r_0031_0062__Minister,gen).
IP-MAT
PP-NIM
P-ROLE
In
NP
D
any
ADJP
ADJ
normal
N
case
PUNC
,
NP-SBJ
PRO;_provisional_
it
MD;~cat_Vi
would
IP-INF-CAT
BE;~La
be
ADJP-PRD
ADVP
ADV
all_but
ADJ
inconceivable
CP-THT-NSBJ
IP-SUB
C
that
NP-SBJ
D
a
N
court
PP
P-ROLE
in
NP
D
these
NS
circumstances
MD;~cat_Vi
would
IP-INF-CAT
VB
reach
NP-OB1
D
any
N
conclusion
ADJP
ADJ
other
PP
P-ROLE
than
CP-THT
IP-SUB
C
that
ILYR
ILYR
LST
PULB
-LRB-
LS
i
PURB
-RRB-
NP-SBJ
D
the
PULQ
“
ADJP
ADJ
legislative
N
programme
PURQ
”
N
explanation
MD;~cat_Vi
must
IP-INF-CAT
BE;~La
be
PUNC
,
ADVP-NIM
ADV
at_best
PUNC
,
ADJP-PRD
ADVP
ADV
materially
ADJ
incomplete
PUNC
,
CONJP
CONJ
and
ILYR
LST
PULB
-LRB-
LS
ii
PURB
-RRB-
NP-SBJ
D
the
N
decision
BED;~cat_Ve_passive_
was
ADVP-NIM
ADV
in_fact
IP-PPL-CAT
ADVP-NIM
ADV
substantially
VVN
motivated
PP-LGS
P-ROLE;_lgs_
by
NP
D
a
N
desire
IP-INF
TO
to
VB
obstruct
NP-OB1
NPR
Parliament
PP-NIM
P-ROLE
from
IP-PPL
VAG
interfering
PP-CLR
P-ROLE
with
NP
NP-GEN
D
the
NPR
Prime
NPR
Minister
GENM
's
NS
plans
PUNC
.
( (IP-MAT (PP-NIM (P-ROLE In;{in})
(NP (D any;{any})
(ADJP (ADJ normal;{normal}))
(N case;{case})))
(PUNC ,)
(NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
(MD;~cat_Vi would;{will})
(IP-INF-CAT (BE;~La be;{be})
(ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV all_but;{all_but}))
(ADJ inconceivable;{inconceivable}))
(CP-THT-NSBJ (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(NP-SBJ (D a;{a})
(N court;{court})
(PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
(NP (D these;{these})
(NS circumstances;{circumstance}))))
(MD;~cat_Vi would;{will})
(IP-INF-CAT (VB reach;{reach})
(NP-OB1 (D any;{any})
(N conclusion;{conclusion})
(ADJP (ADJ other;{other})
(PP (P-ROLE than;{than})
(CP-THT (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(ILYR (ILYR (LST (PULB -LRB-)
(LS i)
(PURB -RRB-))
(NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
(PULQ <ldquo>)
(ADJP (ADJ legislative;{legislative}))
(N programme;{programme})
(PURQ <rdquo>)
(N explanation;{explanation}))
(MD;~cat_Vi must;{must})
(IP-INF-CAT (BE;~La be;{be})
(PUNC ,)
(ADVP-NIM (ADV at_best;{at_best}))
(PUNC ,)
(ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV materially;{materially}))
(ADJ incomplete;{incomplete}))))
(PUNC ,)
(CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
(ILYR (LST (PULB -LRB-)
(LS ii)
(PURB -RRB-))
(NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
(N decision;{decision}))
(BED;~cat_Ve_passive_ was;{be})
(ADVP-NIM (ADV in_fact;{in_fact}))
(IP-PPL-CAT (ADVP-NIM (ADV substantially;{substantially}))
(VVN motivated;{motivate})
(PP-LGS (P-ROLE;_lgs_ by;{by})
(NP (D a;{a})
(N desire;{desire})
(IP-INF (TO to;{to})
(VB obstruct;{obstruct})
(NP-OB1 (NPR Parliament;{Parliament}))
(PP-NIM (P-ROLE from;{from})
(IP-PPL (VAG interfering;{interfere})
(PP-CLR (P-ROLE with;{with})
(NP (NP-GEN;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
(NPR Prime;{Prime})
(NPR Minister;{Minister})
(GENM <apos>s))
(NS plans;{plan})))))))))))))))))))))
(PUNC .))
(ID 31_a_major_case))