Context                Previous, Next                Top


35_a_major_case
The Prime Minister is under a duty “to explain the full facts and reasoning underlying the decision challenged”: AHK v Secretary of State for the Home Department -LSB- 2012 -RSB- EWHC 1117 (Admin) at <sect> 22.

%3 0035_0004__is_5__under is_under 0035_0001__The_2__Prime_3__Minister The_Prime_Minister 0035_0004__is_5__under->0035_0001__The_2__Prime_3__Minister [arg0] 0035_0006__a_7__duty a_duty 0035_0004__is_5__under->0035_0006__a_7__duty [arg1] 0035_0010__explain explain 0035_0006__a_7__duty->0035_0010__explain [emb] 0035_0011__the_13__facts_14__and_15__reasoning the_facts_and_reasoning 0035_0010__explain->0035_0011__the_13__facts_14__and_15__reasoning [arg1] 0035_5004 0035_0010__explain->0035_5004 [arg0] 0035_0012__full full 0035_0011__the_13__facts_14__and_15__reasoning->0035_0012__full [attrib] 0035_0016__underlying underlying 0035_0016__underlying->0035_0011__the_13__facts_14__and_15__reasoning [inv][arg0] 0035_0017__the_18__decision the_decision 0035_0016__underlying->0035_0017__the_18__decision [arg1] 0035_0019__challenged challenged 0035_0019__challenged->0035_0017__the_18__decision [inv][arg0] 
arc(r_0035_0004__is_r_0035_0005__under,r_0035_0001__The_r_0035_0002__Prime_r_0035_0003__Minister,arg0).
arc(r_0035_0004__is_r_0035_0005__under,r_0035_0006__a_r_0035_0007__duty,arg1).
arc(r_0035_0006__a_r_0035_0007__duty,r_0035_0010__explain,emb).
arc(r_0035_0010__explain,r_0035_0011__the_r_0035_0013__facts_r_0035_0014__and_r_0035_0015__reasoning,arg1).
arc(r_0035_0010__explain,z_0035_5004,arg0).
arc(r_0035_0011__the_r_0035_0013__facts_r_0035_0014__and_r_0035_0015__reasoning,r_0035_0012__full,attrib).
arc(r_0035_0016__underlying,r_0035_0011__the_r_0035_0013__facts_r_0035_0014__and_r_0035_0015__reasoning,inv_arg0).
arc(r_0035_0016__underlying,r_0035_0017__the_r_0035_0018__decision,arg1).
arc(r_0035_0019__challenged,r_0035_0017__the_r_0035_0018__decision,inv_arg0).

n35_a_major_case n35_a_major_case__1_1_1_1 The n35_a_major_case__1_1_2_1 Prime n35_a_major_case__1_1_3_1 Minister n35_a_major_case__1_2_1 is n35_a_major_case__1_3_1_1 under n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_1_1 a n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_2_1 duty n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_3_1 <ldquo> n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_1_1 to n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_2_1 explain n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_1_1 the n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2_1_1 full n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1_1_1 facts n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_1_1 and n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2_1_1 reasoning n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_1_1 underlying n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_1_1 the n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_2_1 decision n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3_1_1 challenged n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_5_1 <rdquo> n35_a_major_case__1_4_1 : n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_1_1 AHK n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_1_1 v n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_1_1 Secretary n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_1_1 of n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2_1_1 State n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_1_1 for n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_1_1 the n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_2_1 Home n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_3_1 Department n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_3_1 -LSB- n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1_1_1 2012 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_5_1 -RSB- n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_6_1 EWHC n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_7_1 1117 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_8_1 -LRB- n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_9_1 Admin n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_10_1 -RRB- n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_1_1 at n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_1_1 <sect> n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_2_1 22 n35_a_major_case__1_6_1 . n35_a_major_case__1 IP-MAT n35_a_major_case__1_1 NP-SBJ n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_2 BEP;~Ipr n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3 PP-CLR n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_3 n35_a_major_case__1_4 PUNC n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_4 n35_a_major_case__1_5 META n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_5 n35_a_major_case__1_6 PUNC n35_a_major_case__1->n35_a_major_case__1_6 n35_a_major_case__1_1_1 D n35_a_major_case__1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_1_2 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_1_2 n35_a_major_case__1_1_3 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_1_3 n35_a_major_case__1_1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_1_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_1_2->n35_a_major_case__1_1_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_1_3->n35_a_major_case__1_1_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_2->n35_a_major_case__1_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_1 P-ROLE n35_a_major_case__1_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2 NP n35_a_major_case__1_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_1 D n35_a_major_case__1_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_2 N n35_a_major_case__1_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_3 PULQ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_3 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4 IP-INF n35_a_major_case__1_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_5 PURQ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_5 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_1 TO n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_2 VB;~ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3 NP-OB1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_1 D n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2 ADJP n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3 NLYR n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4 IP-PPL n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2_1 ADJ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1 NLYR n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2 CONJP n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1_1 NS n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_1_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_1 CONJ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2 NLYR n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2_1 N n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_3_2_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_1 VAG;~ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2 NP-OB1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_1 D n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_2 N n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3 IP-PPL n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3_1 VVN;~ n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3_1->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_4_3_4_2_3_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_5->n35_a_major_case__1_3_2_5_1 n35_a_major_case__1_4->n35_a_major_case__1_4_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_1 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2 PP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_3 PULB n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_3 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4 PRN n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_5 PURB n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_5 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_6 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_6 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_7 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_7 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_8 PULB n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_8 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_9 N n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_9 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_10 PURB n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_10 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11 PP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_1 P-ROLE n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_1 N n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2 PP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3 PP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_1 P-ROLE n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2_1 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_2_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_1 P-ROLE n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_1 D n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_2 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_3 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_3 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_3->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_2_2_3_2_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_3->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_3_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1_1 NPR n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_4_1_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_5->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_5_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_6->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_6_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_7->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_7_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_8->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_8_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_9->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_9_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_10->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_10_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_1 P-ROLE n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2 NP n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_1 N n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_2 NUM n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_2 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_1->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_1_1 n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_2->n35_a_major_case__1_5_1_11_2_2_1 n35_a_major_case__1_6->n35_a_major_case__1_6_1 
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ;{JOHNSON} (D The;{the})
                            (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                            (NPR Minister;{Minister}))
          (BEP;~Ipr is;{be[under]})
          (PP-CLR (P-ROLE under;{under})
                  (NP (D a;{a})
                      (N duty;{duty})
                      (PULQ <ldquo>)
                      (IP-INF (TO to;{to})
                              (VB;~ explain;{explain})
                              (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                      (ADJP (ADJ full;{full}))
                                      (NLYR (NLYR (NS facts;{fact}))
                                            (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                                   (NLYR (N reasoning;{reasoning}))))
                                      (IP-PPL (VAG;~ underlying;{underlie})
                                              (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                      (N decision;{decision})
                                                      (IP-PPL (VVN;~ challenged;{challenge}))))))
                      (PURQ <rdquo>)))
          (PUNC :)
          (META (NP (NPR AHK;{AHK})
                    (PP (P-ROLE v)
                        (NP (N Secretary;{secretary})
                            (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                (NP (NPR State;{State})))
                            (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                (NP (D the;{the})
                                    (NPR Home;{Home})
                                    (NPR Department;{Department})))))
                    (PULB -LSB-)
                    (PRN (NP (NPR 2012)))
                    (PURB -RSB-)
                    (NPR EWHC;{EWHC})
                    (NPR 1117)
                    (PULB -LRB-)
                    (N Admin;{admin})
                    (PURB -RRB-)
                    (PP (P-ROLE at;{at})
                        (NP (N <sect>)
                            (NUM 22)))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 35_a_major_case))