3_a_major_case
In summary, he submitted that, looking at the material then available, the inference was inescapable that the Prime Minister's decision was motivated, or in any event substantially motivated, by his political interest in ensuring that there was no activity in Parliament during the period leading up to the EU Council summit on 17 / 18 October 2019.
0003_0005__submitted
submitted
0003_0002__summary
summary
0003_0005__submitted->0003_0002__summary
in[nim]
0003_0004__he
he
0003_0005__submitted->0003_0004__he
[arg0]
0003_1001____sta_
_*_
0003_0005__submitted->0003_1001____sta_
[arg1]
0003_0008__looking_0003_0009__at
looking_at
0003_1001____sta_->0003_0008__looking_0003_0009__at
[restriction]
0003_0017__was
was
0003_1001____sta_->0003_0017__was
[scope]
0003_0010__the_0003_0011__material
the_material
0003_0008__looking_0003_0009__at->0003_0010__the_0003_0011__material
[arg1]
z_0003_5005
_
0003_0008__looking_0003_0009__at->z_0003_5005
[arg0]
0003_0013__available
available
0003_0010__the_0003_0011__material->0003_0013__available
[attrib]
0003_0012__then
then
0003_0013__available->0003_0012__then
[qual]
0003_0015__the_0003_0016__inference
the_inference
0003_0025__was
was
0003_0015__the_0003_0016__inference->0003_0025__was
[emb]
0003_0028__or
or
0003_0025__was->0003_0028__or
[scope]
0003_0017__was->0003_0015__the_0003_0016__inference
[arg0]
0003_0018__inescapable
inescapable
0003_0017__was->0003_0018__inescapable
[prd]
0003_0024__decision
decision
0003_0020__the_0003_0021__Prime_0003_0022__Minister
the_prime_minister
0003_0024__decision->0003_0020__the_0003_0021__Prime_0003_0022__Minister
[gen]
0003_0026__motivated
motivated
0003_0028__or->0003_0026__motivated
[conj1]
0003_0033__motivated
motivated
0003_0028__or->0003_0033__motivated
[conj2]
0003_0026__motivated->0003_0024__decision
[arg1]
0003_0038__interest
interest
0003_0026__motivated->0003_0038__interest
by[arg0]
0003_0038__interest->0003_0020__the_0003_0021__Prime_0003_0022__Minister
[gen]
0003_0037__political
political
0003_0038__interest->0003_0037__political
[attrib]
0003_0040__ensuring
ensuring
0003_0038__interest->0003_0040__ensuring
in
0003_0033__motivated->0003_0024__decision
[arg1]
0003_0033__motivated->0003_0038__interest
by[arg0]
0003_0030__any_0003_0031__event
any_event
0003_0033__motivated->0003_0030__any_0003_0031__event
in[nim]
0003_0032__substantially
substantially
0003_0033__motivated->0003_0032__substantially
[nim]
0003_0044__no
no[quant]
0003_0040__ensuring->0003_0044__no
[arg1]
z_0003_5017
_
0003_0040__ensuring->z_0003_5017
[arg0]
0003_0043__was
was
0003_0044__no->0003_0043__was
[scope]
0003_0045__activity
activity
0003_0044__no->0003_0045__activity
[restriction]
0003_0043__was->0003_0045__activity
[arg0]
0003_0049__the_0003_0050__period
the_period
0003_0043__was->0003_0049__the_0003_0050__period
during[nim]
0003_0047__Parliament
parliament
0003_0045__activity->0003_0047__Parliament
in
0003_0051__leading_0003_0052__up_to
leading_up_to
0003_0051__leading_0003_0052__up_to->0003_0049__the_0003_0050__period
[inv][arg0]
0003_0053__the_0003_0054__EU_0003_0055__Council_0003_0056__summit
the_eu_council_summit
0003_0051__leading_0003_0052__up_to->0003_0053__the_0003_0054__EU_0003_0055__Council_0003_0056__summit
[arg1]
0003_0058__17_0003_0060__18_0003_0061__Octobe0003_0062__2019
17_18_october_2019
0003_0053__the_0003_0054__EU_0003_0055__Council_0003_0056__summit->0003_0058__17_0003_0060__18_0003_0061__Octobe0003_0062__2019
on
arc(r_0003_0005__submitted,r_0003_0002__summary,r_0003_0001__In__nim).
arc(r_0003_0005__submitted,r_0003_0004__he,arg0).
arc(r_0003_0005__submitted,r_0003_1001____star__,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0008__looking_r_0003_0009__at,r_0003_0010__the_r_0003_0011__material,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0008__looking_r_0003_0009__at,z_0003_5005,arg0).
arc(r_0003_0010__the_r_0003_0011__material,r_0003_0013__available,attrib).
arc(r_0003_0013__available,r_0003_0012__then,qual).
arc(r_0003_0015__the_r_0003_0016__inference,r_0003_0025__was,emb).
arc(r_0003_0017__was,r_0003_0015__the_r_0003_0016__inference,arg0).
arc(r_0003_0017__was,r_0003_0018__inescapable,prd).
arc(r_0003_0024__decision,r_0003_0020__the_r_0003_0021__Prime_r_0003_0022__Minister,gen).
arc(r_0003_0025__was,r_0003_0028__or,scope).
arc(r_0003_0026__motivated,r_0003_0024__decision,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0026__motivated,r_0003_0038__interest,r_0003_0035__by_arg0).
arc(r_0003_0028__or,r_0003_0026__motivated,conj1).
arc(r_0003_0028__or,r_0003_0033__motivated,conj2).
arc(r_0003_0033__motivated,r_0003_0024__decision,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0033__motivated,r_0003_0030__any_r_0003_0031__event,r_0003_0029__in__nim).
arc(r_0003_0033__motivated,r_0003_0032__substantially,nim).
arc(r_0003_0033__motivated,r_0003_0038__interest,r_0003_0035__by_arg0).
arc(r_0003_0038__interest,r_0003_0020__the_r_0003_0021__Prime_r_0003_0022__Minister,gen).
arc(r_0003_0038__interest,r_0003_0037__political,attrib).
arc(r_0003_0038__interest,r_0003_0040__ensuring,r_0003_0039__in).
arc(r_0003_0040__ensuring,r_0003_0044__no__quant,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0040__ensuring,z_0003_5017,arg0).
arc(r_0003_0043__was,r_0003_0045__activity,arg0).
arc(r_0003_0043__was,r_0003_0049__the_r_0003_0050__period,r_0003_0048__during__nim).
arc(r_0003_0044__no__quant,r_0003_0043__was,scope).
arc(r_0003_0044__no__quant,r_0003_0045__activity,restriction).
arc(r_0003_0045__activity,r_0003_0047__Parliament,r_0003_0046__in).
arc(r_0003_0051__leading_r_0003_0052__up_to,r_0003_0049__the_r_0003_0050__period,inv_arg0).
arc(r_0003_0051__leading_r_0003_0052__up_to,r_0003_0053__the_r_0003_0054__EU_r_0003_0055__Council_r_0003_0056__summit,arg1).
arc(r_0003_0053__the_r_0003_0054__EU_r_0003_0055__Council_r_0003_0056__summit,r_0003_0058__17_r_0003_0060__18_r_0003_0061__October_r_0003_0062__2019,r_0003_0057__on).
arc(r_0003_1001____star__,r_0003_0008__looking_r_0003_0009__at,restriction).
arc(r_0003_1001____star__,r_0003_0017__was,scope).
IP-MAT
PP-NIM
P-ROLE
In
NP
N
summary
PUNC
,
NP-SBJ
PRO
he
VBD;~Tf
submitted
CP-THT-OB1
IP-SUB
C
that
PUNC
,
PP-SCON
IP-PPL3
VAG;~Ipr
looking
PP-CLR
P-ROLE
at
NP
D
the
N
material
ADJP
ADVP
ADV
then
ADJ
available
PUNC
,
NP-SBJ
D
the
N
inference
CP-THT
*ICH*-184
BED;~La
was
ADJP-PRD
ADJ
inescapable
CP-THT-EPD-184
IP-SUB
C
that
NP-SBJ
NP-GEN
D
the
NPR
Prime
NPR
Minister
GENM
's
N
decision
BED;~cat_Ve_passive_
was
IP-PPL-CAT
ILYR
ILYR
VVN;~Tn
motivated
PUNC
,
CONJP
CONJ
or
ILYR
PP-NIM
P-ROLE
in
NP
D
any
N
event
ADVP-NIM
ADV
substantially
VVN;~Tn
motivated
PUNC
,
PP-LGS
P-ROLE;_lgs_
by
NP
NP-GEN
PRO;_genm_
his
ADJP
ADJ
political
N
interest
PP
P-ROLE
in
IP-PPL3
VAG;~Tf
ensuring
CP-THT-OB1
IP-SUB
C
that
EX
there
BED;~ex_V
was
NP-ESBJ
Q
no
N
activity
PP
P-ROLE
in
NP
NPR
Parliament
PP-NIM
P-ROLE
during
NP
D
the
N
period
IP-PPL
VAG;~Ipr
leading
PP-CLR
P-ROLE
up_to
NP
D
the
NPR
EU
NPR
Council
N
summit
PP
P-ROLE
on
NP
NPR
17
PUNC
<sol>
NPR
18
NPR
October
NPR
2019
PUNC
.
( (IP-MAT (PP-NIM (P-ROLE In;{in})
(NP (N summary;{summary})))
(PUNC ,)
(NP-SBJ;{MAJOR} (PRO he;{he}))
(VBD;~Tf submitted;{submit})
(CP-THT-OB1 (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(PUNC ,)
(PP-SCON (IP-PPL3 (VAG;~Ipr looking;{look[at]})
(PP-CLR (P-ROLE at;{at})
(NP (D the;{the})
(N material;{material})
(ADJP (ADVP (ADV then;{then}))
(ADJ available;{available}))))))
(PUNC ,)
(NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
(N inference;{inference})
(CP-THT *ICH*-184))
(BED;~La was;{be})
(ADJP-PRD (ADJ inescapable;{inescapable}))
(CP-THT-EPD-184 (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(NP-SBJ (NP-GEN;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
(NPR Prime;{Prime})
(NPR Minister;{Minister})
(GENM <apos>s))
(N decision;{decision}))
(BED;~cat_Ve_passive_ was;{be})
(IP-PPL-CAT (ILYR (ILYR (VVN;~Tn motivated;{motivate}))
(PUNC ,)
(CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
(ILYR (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
(NP (D any;{any})
(N event;{event})))
(ADVP-NIM (ADV substantially;{substantially}))
(VVN;~Tn motivated;{motivate}))))
(PUNC ,)
(PP-LGS (P-ROLE;_lgs_ by;{by})
(NP (NP-GEN;{JOHNSON} (PRO;_genm_ his;{his}))
(ADJP (ADJ political;{political}))
(N interest;{interest})
(PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
(IP-PPL3 (VAG;~Tf ensuring;{ensure})
(CP-THT-OB1 (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
(EX there;{there})
(BED;~ex_V was;{be})
(NP-ESBJ (Q no;{no})
(N activity;{activity})
(PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
(NP (NPR Parliament;{Parliament}))))
(PP-NIM (P-ROLE during;{during})
(NP (D the;{the})
(N period;{period})
(IP-PPL (VAG;~Ipr leading;{lead[up_to]})
(PP-CLR (P-ROLE up_to;{up_to})
(NP (D the;{the})
(NPR EU;{EU})
(NPR Council;{Council})
(N summit;{summit})
(PP (P-ROLE on;{on})
(NP (NPR 17)
(PUNC <sol>)
(NPR 18)
(NPR October;{October})
(NPR 2019)))))))))))))))))))
(PUNC .))
(ID 3_a_major_case))