Context                Previous, Next                Top


41_a_major_case
On that issue: 18.1 it is by no means inherently improbable, particularly having regard to the matters set out in Sir John's previous submissions at <sect><sect> 20, that the Defendant had a purpose other than that which is recorded in the handful of documents disclosed; and, 18.2 even if it were, the evidence as to the true reasons (such as that set out in Sir John's previous submissions at <sect><sect> 16), and the absence of evidence to the contrary which it would be readily possible for the Defendant to provide if it were true, are more than sufficient to override any such improbability.

%3 r_0041_0007__is is r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue that issue r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue On [nim] r_0041_0010__means means r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0010__means by [nim] r_0041_0012__improbable improbable r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0012__improbable [prd] r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had that had r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had [arg0] r_0041_0011__inherently inherently r_0041_0012__improbable->r_0041_0011__inherently [qual] r_0041_0033__the_r_0041_0034__Defendant the Defendant r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had->r_0041_0033__the_r_0041_0034__Defendant [arg0] r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose a purpose r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had->r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose [arg1] r_0041_0009__no_quant no [quant] r_0041_0009__no_quant->r_0041_0007__is [scope] r_0041_0009__no_quant->r_0041_0010__means [restriction] r_0041_0015__having having r_0041_0014__particularly particularly r_0041_0015__having->r_0041_0014__particularly [nim] r_0041_0016__regard regard r_0041_0015__having->r_0041_0016__regard [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_39 r_0041_0015__having->z_000_41_a_major_case_39 [arg0] r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters the matters r_0041_0016__regard->r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters to r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out set out r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out->r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters [arg0] r_0041_0027__submissions submissions r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out->r_0041_0027__submissions in [nim] r_0041_0023__Sir_r_0041_0024__John_r_0041_0025___apos_s Sir John 's r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0023__Sir_r_0041_0024__John_r_0041_0025___apos_s [gen] r_0041_0026__previous previous r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0026__previous [attrib] r_0041_0029___sect__sect__r_0041_0030__20 sect sect  20 r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0029___sect__sect__r_0041_0030__20 at r_0041_0038__other other r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose->r_0041_0038__other [attrib] r_0041_0040__that that r_0041_0038__other->r_0041_0040__that than r_0041_0042__is is r_0041_0043__recorded recorded r_0041_0042__is->r_0041_0043__recorded [scope] r_0041_0043__recorded->r_0041_0040__that [arg1] r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful the handful r_0041_0043__recorded->r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful in [nim] z_000_41_a_major_case_119 r_0041_0043__recorded->z_000_41_a_major_case_119 [arg0] r_0041_0048__documents documents r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful->r_0041_0048__documents of r_0041_0049__disclosed disclosed r_0041_0049__disclosed->r_0041_0048__documents [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_138 r_0041_0049__disclosed->z_000_41_a_major_case_138 [arg0] r_0041_0051__and and r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if even if r_0041_0051__and->r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if [conj2] z_000_41_a_major_case_38 r_0041_0051__and->z_000_41_a_major_case_38 [conj1] r_0041_0057__were were r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if->r_0041_0057__were [restriction] r_0041_0105__are are r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if->r_0041_0105__are [scope] z_000_41_a_major_case_38->r_0041_0009__no_quant [scope] z_000_41_a_major_case_38->r_0041_0015__having [restriction] r_0041_0057__were->r_0041_0048__documents [arg0] r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue On [nim] r_0041_0081__and and r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0081__and [arg0] r_0041_0106__more more r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0106__more [prd] r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence the evidence r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons the reasons r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence->r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons as to r_0041_0063__true true r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons->r_0041_0063__true [attrib] r_0041_0081__and->r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence [conj1] r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence the absence r_0041_0081__and->r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence [conj2] r_0041_0085__evidence evidence r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence->r_0041_0085__evidence of r_0041_0087__the_r_0041_0088__contrary the contrary r_0041_0085__evidence->r_0041_0087__the_r_0041_0088__contrary to r_0041_0091__would would r_0041_0092__be be r_0041_0091__would->r_0041_0092__be [scope] r_0041_0094__possible possible r_0041_0092__be->r_0041_0094__possible [prd] r_0041_0100__if if r_0041_0092__be->r_0041_0100__if [arg0] r_0041_0093__readily readily r_0041_0094__possible->r_0041_0093__readily [qual] r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide for to provide r_0041_0100__if->r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide [scope] r_0041_0102__were were r_0041_0100__if->r_0041_0102__were [restriction] r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide->r_0041_0085__evidence [arg1] r_0041_0096__the_r_0041_0097__Defendant the Defendant r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide->r_0041_0096__the_r_0041_0097__Defendant [arg0] r_0041_0102__were->r_0041_0048__documents [arg0] r_0041_0103__true true r_0041_0102__were->r_0041_0103__true [prd] z_000_41_a_major_case_302 r_0041_0106__more->z_000_41_a_major_case_302 than r_0041_0108__sufficient sufficient z_000_41_a_major_case_302->r_0041_0108__sufficient [attrib] r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override to override r_0041_0108__sufficient->r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override [emb] r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability any improbability r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override->r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_306 r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override->z_000_41_a_major_case_306 [arg0] r_0041_0112__such such r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability->r_0041_0112__such [attrib] 
arc(r_0041_0007__is, r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue, r_0041_0001__On_nim5).
arc(r_0041_0007__is, r_0041_0010__means, r_0041_0008__by_nim25).
arc(r_0041_0007__is, r_0041_0012__improbable, prd).
arc(r_0041_0007__is, r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0009__no_quant, r_0041_0007__is, scope).
arc(r_0041_0009__no_quant, r_0041_0010__means, restriction).
arc(r_0041_0012__improbable, r_0041_0011__inherently, qual31).
arc(r_0041_0015__having, r_0041_0014__particularly, nim40).
arc(r_0041_0015__having, r_0041_0016__regard, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0015__having, z_000_41_a_major_case_39, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0016__regard, r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters, r_0041_0017__to).
arc(r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out, r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out, r_0041_0027__submissions, r_0041_0022__in_nim64).
arc(r_0041_0027__submissions, r_0041_0023__Sir_r_0041_0024__John_r_0041_0025___apos_s, gen).
arc(r_0041_0027__submissions, r_0041_0026__previous, attrib72).
arc(r_0041_0027__submissions, r_0041_0029___sect__sect__r_0041_0030__20, r_0041_0028__at).
arc(r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had, r_0041_0033__the_r_0041_0034__Defendant, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had, r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose, r_0041_0038__other, attrib103).
arc(r_0041_0038__other, r_0041_0040__that, r_0041_0039__than).
arc(r_0041_0042__is, r_0041_0043__recorded, scope).
arc(r_0041_0043__recorded, r_0041_0040__that, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0043__recorded, r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful, r_0041_0044__in_nim126).
arc(r_0041_0043__recorded, z_000_41_a_major_case_119, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful, r_0041_0048__documents, r_0041_0047__of).
arc(r_0041_0049__disclosed, r_0041_0048__documents, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0049__disclosed, z_000_41_a_major_case_138, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0051__and, r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if, conj2).
arc(r_0041_0051__and, z_000_41_a_major_case_38, conj1).
arc(r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if, r_0041_0057__were, restriction).
arc(r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if, r_0041_0105__are, scope).
arc(r_0041_0057__were, r_0041_0048__documents, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence, r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons, r_0041_0061__as_to).
arc(r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons, r_0041_0063__true, attrib179).
arc(r_0041_0081__and, r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence, conj1).
arc(r_0041_0081__and, r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence, conj2).
arc(r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence, r_0041_0085__evidence, r_0041_0084__of).
arc(r_0041_0085__evidence, r_0041_0087__the_r_0041_0088__contrary, r_0041_0086__to).
arc(r_0041_0091__would, r_0041_0092__be, scope).
arc(r_0041_0092__be, r_0041_0094__possible, prd).
arc(r_0041_0092__be, r_0041_0100__if, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0094__possible, r_0041_0093__readily, qual261).
arc(r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide, r_0041_0085__evidence, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide, r_0041_0096__the_r_0041_0097__Defendant, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0100__if, r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide, scope).
arc(r_0041_0100__if, r_0041_0102__were, restriction).
arc(r_0041_0102__were, r_0041_0048__documents, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0102__were, r_0041_0103__true, prd).
arc(r_0041_0105__are, r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue, r_0041_0001__On_nim5).
arc(r_0041_0105__are, r_0041_0081__and, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0105__are, r_0041_0106__more, prd).
arc(r_0041_0106__more, z_000_41_a_major_case_302, r_0041_0107__than).
arc(r_0041_0108__sufficient, r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override, emb306).
arc(r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override, r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability, arg1).
arc(r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override, z_000_41_a_major_case_306, arg0).
arc(r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability, r_0041_0112__such, attrib314).
arc(z_000_41_a_major_case_302, r_0041_0108__sufficient, attrib303).
arc(z_000_41_a_major_case_38, r_0041_0009__no_quant, scope).
arc(z_000_41_a_major_case_38, r_0041_0015__having, restriction).


%3 r_0041_0007__is is r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue that issue r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue On [nim] r_0041_0010__means means r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0010__means by [nim] r_0041_0012__improbable improbable r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0012__improbable [prd] r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had that had r_0041_0007__is->r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had [arg0] r_0041_0011__inherently inherently r_0041_0012__improbable->r_0041_0011__inherently [qual] r_0041_0033__the_r_0041_0034__Defendant the Defendant r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had->r_0041_0033__the_r_0041_0034__Defendant [arg0] r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose a purpose r_0041_0032__that_r_0041_0035__had->r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose [arg1] r_0041_0009__no_quant no [quant] r_0041_0009__no_quant->r_0041_0007__is [scope] r_0041_0009__no_quant->r_0041_0010__means [restriction] r_0041_0015__having having r_0041_0014__particularly particularly r_0041_0015__having->r_0041_0014__particularly [nim] r_0041_0016__regard regard r_0041_0015__having->r_0041_0016__regard [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_39 r_0041_0015__having->z_000_41_a_major_case_39 [arg0] r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters the matters r_0041_0016__regard->r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters to r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out set out r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out->r_0041_0018__the_r_0041_0019__matters [arg0] r_0041_0027__submissions submissions r_0041_0020__set_r_0041_0021__out->r_0041_0027__submissions in [nim] r_0041_0023__Sir_r_0041_0024__John_r_0041_0025___apos_s Sir John 's r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0023__Sir_r_0041_0024__John_r_0041_0025___apos_s [gen] r_0041_0026__previous previous r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0026__previous [attrib] r_0041_0029___sect__sect__r_0041_0030__20 sect sect  20 r_0041_0027__submissions->r_0041_0029___sect__sect__r_0041_0030__20 at r_0041_0038__other other r_0041_0036__a_r_0041_0037__purpose->r_0041_0038__other [attrib] r_0041_0040__that that r_0041_0038__other->r_0041_0040__that than r_0041_0042__is_r_0041_0043__recorded is recorded r_0041_0042__is_r_0041_0043__recorded->r_0041_0040__that [arg1] r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful the handful r_0041_0042__is_r_0041_0043__recorded->r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful in [nim] z_000_41_a_major_case_119 r_0041_0042__is_r_0041_0043__recorded->z_000_41_a_major_case_119 [arg0] r_0041_0048__documents documents r_0041_0045__the_r_0041_0046__handful->r_0041_0048__documents of r_0041_0049__disclosed disclosed r_0041_0049__disclosed->r_0041_0048__documents [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_138 r_0041_0049__disclosed->z_000_41_a_major_case_138 [arg0] r_0041_0051__and and r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if even if r_0041_0051__and->r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if [conj2] z_000_41_a_major_case_38 r_0041_0051__and->z_000_41_a_major_case_38 [conj1] r_0041_0057__were were r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if->r_0041_0057__were [restriction] r_0041_0105__are are r_0041_0054__even_r_0041_0055__if->r_0041_0105__are [scope] z_000_41_a_major_case_38->r_0041_0009__no_quant [conj2] z_000_41_a_major_case_38->r_0041_0015__having [conj1] r_0041_0057__were->r_0041_0048__documents [arg0] r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0002__that_r_0041_0003__issue On [nim] r_0041_0081__and and r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0081__and [arg0] r_0041_0106__more more r_0041_0105__are->r_0041_0106__more [prd] r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence the evidence r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons the reasons r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence->r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons as to r_0041_0063__true true r_0041_0062__the_r_0041_0064__reasons->r_0041_0063__true [attrib] r_0041_0081__and->r_0041_0059__the_r_0041_0060__evidence [conj1] r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence the absence r_0041_0081__and->r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence [conj2] r_0041_0085__evidence evidence r_0041_0082__the_r_0041_0083__absence->r_0041_0085__evidence of r_0041_0087__the_r_0041_0088__contrary the contrary r_0041_0085__evidence->r_0041_0087__the_r_0041_0088__contrary to r_0041_0091__would_r_0041_0092__be would be r_0041_0094__possible possible r_0041_0091__would_r_0041_0092__be->r_0041_0094__possible [prd] r_0041_0100__if if r_0041_0091__would_r_0041_0092__be->r_0041_0100__if [arg0] r_0041_0093__readily readily r_0041_0094__possible->r_0041_0093__readily [qual] r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide for to provide r_0041_0100__if->r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide [scope] r_0041_0102__were were r_0041_0100__if->r_0041_0102__were [restriction] r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide->r_0041_0085__evidence [arg1] r_0041_0096__the_r_0041_0097__Defendant the Defendant r_0041_0095__for_r_0041_0098__to_r_0041_0099__provide->r_0041_0096__the_r_0041_0097__Defendant [arg0] r_0041_0102__were->r_0041_0048__documents [arg0] r_0041_0103__true true r_0041_0102__were->r_0041_0103__true [prd] z_000_41_a_major_case_302 r_0041_0106__more->z_000_41_a_major_case_302 than r_0041_0108__sufficient sufficient z_000_41_a_major_case_302->r_0041_0108__sufficient [attrib] r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override to override r_0041_0108__sufficient->r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override [emb] r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability any improbability r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override->r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability [arg1] z_000_41_a_major_case_306 r_0041_0109__to_r_0041_0110__override->z_000_41_a_major_case_306 [arg0] r_0041_0112__such such r_0041_0111__any_r_0041_0113__improbability->r_0041_0112__such [attrib] 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_41_20_SET_OUT,R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS,R_41_26_PREVIOUS,R_41_23_SIR_JOHN_APOS_S,R_41_29__SECT_SECT_20,R_41_42_IS_RECORDED,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_119,R_41_40_THAT,R_41_45_THE_HANDFUL,R_41_49_DISCLOSED,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_138,R_41_48_DOCUMENTS,R_41_51_AND,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_38,R_41_15_HAVING,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_39,R_41_16_REGARD,R_41_18_THE_MATTERS,R_41_14_PARTICULARLY,R_41_91_WOULD_BE,R_41_94_POSSIBLE,R_41_93_READILY] :
      ( previous(R_41_26_PREVIOUS)
      & sir_John_apos_s(R_41_23_SIR_JOHN_APOS_S)
      & _sect_sect_20(R_41_29__SECT_SECT_20)
      & that(R_41_40_THAT)
      & documents(R_41_48_DOCUMENTS)
      & the_matters(R_41_18_THE_MATTERS)
      & particularly(R_41_14_PARTICULARLY)
      & readily(R_41_93_READILY)
      & set_out(R_41_20_SET_OUT,R_41_18_THE_MATTERS)
      & in_nim64(R_41_20_SET_OUT,R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS)
      & submissions(R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS)
      & attrib72(R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS,R_41_26_PREVIOUS)
      & gen(R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS,R_41_23_SIR_JOHN_APOS_S)
      & at(R_41_27_SUBMISSIONS,R_41_29__SECT_SECT_20)
      & is_recorded(R_41_42_IS_RECORDED,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_119,R_41_40_THAT)
      & in_nim126(R_41_42_IS_RECORDED,R_41_45_THE_HANDFUL)
      & the_handful(R_41_45_THE_HANDFUL)
      & of(R_41_45_THE_HANDFUL,R_41_48_DOCUMENTS)
      & disclosed(R_41_49_DISCLOSED,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_138,R_41_48_DOCUMENTS)
      & ! [R_41_57_WERE] :
          ( were(R_41_57_WERE,R_41_48_DOCUMENTS)
         => ? [R_41_105_ARE,R_41_81_AND,R_41_59_THE_EVIDENCE,R_41_62_THE_REASONS,R_41_63_TRUE,R_41_82_THE_ABSENCE,R_41_85_EVIDENCE,R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY,R_41_106_MORE,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_302,R_41_108_SUFFICIENT,R_41_109_TO_OVERRIDE,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_306,R_41_111_ANY_IMPROBABILITY,R_41_112_SUCH,R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE] :
              ( true(R_41_63_TRUE)
              & the_contrary(R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY)
              & such(R_41_112_SUCH)
              & that_issue(R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE)
              & are(R_41_105_ARE,R_41_81_AND,R_41_106_MORE)
              & and(R_41_81_AND)
              & conj1(R_41_81_AND,R_41_59_THE_EVIDENCE)
              & the_evidence(R_41_59_THE_EVIDENCE)
              & as_to(R_41_59_THE_EVIDENCE,R_41_62_THE_REASONS)
              & the_reasons(R_41_62_THE_REASONS)
              & attrib179(R_41_62_THE_REASONS,R_41_63_TRUE)
              & conj2(R_41_81_AND,R_41_82_THE_ABSENCE)
              & the_absence(R_41_82_THE_ABSENCE)
              & of(R_41_82_THE_ABSENCE,R_41_85_EVIDENCE)
              & evidence(R_41_85_EVIDENCE)
              & to(R_41_85_EVIDENCE,R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY)
              & more(R_41_106_MORE)
              & than(R_41_106_MORE,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_302)
              & z_41_a_major_case_302(Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_302)
              & attrib303(Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_302,R_41_108_SUFFICIENT)
              & sufficient(R_41_108_SUFFICIENT)
              & emb306(R_41_108_SUFFICIENT,R_41_109_TO_OVERRIDE)
              & to_override(R_41_109_TO_OVERRIDE,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_306,R_41_111_ANY_IMPROBABILITY)
              & any_improbability(R_41_111_ANY_IMPROBABILITY)
              & attrib314(R_41_111_ANY_IMPROBABILITY,R_41_112_SUCH)
              & on_nim5(R_41_105_ARE,R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE) ) )
      & conj2(CONJ2)
      & and(R_41_51_AND)
      & conj1(R_41_51_AND,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_38)
      & ! [R_41_10_MEANS] :
          ( means(R_41_10_MEANS)
         => ? [R_41_7_IS,R_41_32_THAT_HAD,R_41_33_THE_DEFENDANT,R_41_36_A_PURPOSE,R_41_38_OTHER,R_41_12_IMPROBABLE,R_41_11_INHERENTLY,R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE] :
              ( the_Defendant(R_41_33_THE_DEFENDANT)
              & inherently(R_41_11_INHERENTLY)
              & that_issue(R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE)
              & is(R_41_7_IS,R_41_32_THAT_HAD,R_41_12_IMPROBABLE)
              & that_had(R_41_32_THAT_HAD,R_41_33_THE_DEFENDANT,R_41_36_A_PURPOSE)
              & a_purpose(R_41_36_A_PURPOSE)
              & attrib103(R_41_36_A_PURPOSE,R_41_38_OTHER)
              & other(R_41_38_OTHER)
              & than(R_41_38_OTHER,R_41_40_THAT)
              & improbable(R_41_12_IMPROBABLE)
              & qual31(R_41_12_IMPROBABLE,R_41_11_INHERENTLY)
              & on_nim5(R_41_7_IS,R_41_2_THAT_ISSUE)
              & by_nim25(R_41_7_IS,R_41_10_MEANS) ) )
      & conj2(CONJ2)
      & z_41_a_major_case_38(Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_38)
      & conj1(Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_38,R_41_15_HAVING)
      & having(R_41_15_HAVING,Z_41_A_MAJOR_CASE_39,R_41_16_REGARD)
      & regard(R_41_16_REGARD)
      & to(R_41_16_REGARD,R_41_18_THE_MATTERS)
      & nim40(R_41_15_HAVING,R_41_14_PARTICULARLY)
      & ! [R_41_102_WERE,R_41_103_TRUE] :
          ( ( true(R_41_103_TRUE)
            & were(R_41_102_WERE,R_41_48_DOCUMENTS,R_41_103_TRUE) )
         => ? [R_41_95_FOR_TO_PROVIDE,R_41_96_THE_DEFENDANT,R_41_85_EVIDENCE,R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY] :
              ( the_Defendant(R_41_96_THE_DEFENDANT)
              & the_contrary(R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY)
              & for_to_provide(R_41_95_FOR_TO_PROVIDE,R_41_96_THE_DEFENDANT,R_41_85_EVIDENCE)
              & evidence(R_41_85_EVIDENCE)
              & to(R_41_85_EVIDENCE,R_41_87_THE_CONTRARY) ) )
      & arg0(ARG0)
      & would_be(R_41_91_WOULD_BE)
      & prd(R_41_91_WOULD_BE,R_41_94_POSSIBLE)
      & possible(R_41_94_POSSIBLE)
      & qual261(R_41_94_POSSIBLE,R_41_93_READILY) ) ).


n41_a_major_case n41_a_major_case_4 On n41_a_major_case_7 that n41_a_major_case_9 issue n41_a_major_case_11 : n41_a_major_case_16 18.1 n41_a_major_case_19 it n41_a_major_case_21 is n41_a_major_case_24 by n41_a_major_case_27 no n41_a_major_case_29 means n41_a_major_case_33 inherently n41_a_major_case_35 improbable n41_a_major_case_37 , n41_a_major_case_42 particularly n41_a_major_case_44 having n41_a_major_case_47 regard n41_a_major_case_50 to n41_a_major_case_53 the n41_a_major_case_55 matters n41_a_major_case_58 set n41_a_major_case_60 out n41_a_major_case_63 in n41_a_major_case_67 Sir n41_a_major_case_69 John n41_a_major_case_71 's n41_a_major_case_74 previous n41_a_major_case_76 submissions n41_a_major_case_79 at n41_a_major_case_82 <sect><sect> n41_a_major_case_84 20 n41_a_major_case_86 , n41_a_major_case_90 that n41_a_major_case_93 the n41_a_major_case_95 Defendant n41_a_major_case_97 had n41_a_major_case_100 a n41_a_major_case_102 purpose n41_a_major_case_105 other n41_a_major_case_108 than n41_a_major_case_111 that n41_a_major_case_115 which n41_a_major_case_117 is n41_a_major_case_120 * n41_a_major_case_122 recorded n41_a_major_case_125 in n41_a_major_case_128 the n41_a_major_case_130 handful n41_a_major_case_133 of n41_a_major_case_136 documents n41_a_major_case_139 * n41_a_major_case_141 disclosed n41_a_major_case_143 ; n41_a_major_case_146 and n41_a_major_case_148 , n41_a_major_case_152 18.2 n41_a_major_case_155 even n41_a_major_case_157 if n41_a_major_case_161 it n41_a_major_case_163 were n41_a_major_case_165 , n41_a_major_case_170 the n41_a_major_case_172 evidence n41_a_major_case_175 as_to n41_a_major_case_178 the n41_a_major_case_181 true n41_a_major_case_183 reasons n41_a_major_case_185 -LRB- n41_a_major_case_189 such_as n41_a_major_case_192 that n41_a_major_case_195 set n41_a_major_case_197 out n41_a_major_case_200 in n41_a_major_case_204 Sir n41_a_major_case_206 John n41_a_major_case_208 's n41_a_major_case_211 previous n41_a_major_case_213 submissions n41_a_major_case_216 at n41_a_major_case_219 <sect><sect> n41_a_major_case_221 16 n41_a_major_case_223 -RRB- n41_a_major_case_225 , n41_a_major_case_228 and n41_a_major_case_231 the n41_a_major_case_233 absence n41_a_major_case_236 of n41_a_major_case_239 evidence n41_a_major_case_242 to n41_a_major_case_245 the n41_a_major_case_247 contrary n41_a_major_case_251 which n41_a_major_case_254 it n41_a_major_case_256 would n41_a_major_case_259 be n41_a_major_case_263 readily n41_a_major_case_265 possible n41_a_major_case_268 *ICH*-172 n41_a_major_case_270 for n41_a_major_case_273 the n41_a_major_case_275 Defendant n41_a_major_case_277 to n41_a_major_case_279 provide n41_a_major_case_282 if n41_a_major_case_286 it n41_a_major_case_288 were n41_a_major_case_291 true n41_a_major_case_293 , n41_a_major_case_295 are n41_a_major_case_298 more n41_a_major_case_301 than n41_a_major_case_305 sufficient n41_a_major_case_308 to n41_a_major_case_310 override n41_a_major_case_313 any n41_a_major_case_316 such n41_a_major_case_318 improbability n41_a_major_case_320 . n41_a_major_case_1 IP-MAT n41_a_major_case_2 PP-NIM n41_a_major_case_1->n41_a_major_case_2 n41_a_major_case_10 PUNC n41_a_major_case_1->n41_a_major_case_10 n41_a_major_case_12 ILYR n41_a_major_case_1->n41_a_major_case_12 n41_a_major_case_319 PUNC n41_a_major_case_1->n41_a_major_case_319 n41_a_major_case_3 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_2->n41_a_major_case_3 n41_a_major_case_5 NP n41_a_major_case_2->n41_a_major_case_5 n41_a_major_case_3->n41_a_major_case_4 n41_a_major_case_6 D n41_a_major_case_5->n41_a_major_case_6 n41_a_major_case_8 N n41_a_major_case_5->n41_a_major_case_8 n41_a_major_case_6->n41_a_major_case_7 n41_a_major_case_8->n41_a_major_case_9 n41_a_major_case_10->n41_a_major_case_11 n41_a_major_case_13 ILYR n41_a_major_case_12->n41_a_major_case_13 n41_a_major_case_142 PUNC n41_a_major_case_12->n41_a_major_case_142 n41_a_major_case_144 CONJP n41_a_major_case_12->n41_a_major_case_144 n41_a_major_case_14 LST n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_14 n41_a_major_case_17 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_17 n41_a_major_case_20 BEP;_La_ n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_20 n41_a_major_case_22 PP-NIM n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_22 n41_a_major_case_30 ADJP-PRD n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_30 n41_a_major_case_36 PUNC n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_36 n41_a_major_case_38 PP-SCON n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_38 n41_a_major_case_85 PUNC n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_85 n41_a_major_case_87 CP-THT-NSBJ n41_a_major_case_13->n41_a_major_case_87 n41_a_major_case_15 LS n41_a_major_case_14->n41_a_major_case_15 n41_a_major_case_15->n41_a_major_case_16 n41_a_major_case_18 PRO;_provisional_ n41_a_major_case_17->n41_a_major_case_18 n41_a_major_case_18->n41_a_major_case_19 n41_a_major_case_20->n41_a_major_case_21 n41_a_major_case_23 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_22->n41_a_major_case_23 n41_a_major_case_25 NP n41_a_major_case_22->n41_a_major_case_25 n41_a_major_case_23->n41_a_major_case_24 n41_a_major_case_26 Q n41_a_major_case_25->n41_a_major_case_26 n41_a_major_case_28 NS n41_a_major_case_25->n41_a_major_case_28 n41_a_major_case_26->n41_a_major_case_27 n41_a_major_case_28->n41_a_major_case_29 n41_a_major_case_31 ADVP n41_a_major_case_30->n41_a_major_case_31 n41_a_major_case_34 ADJ n41_a_major_case_30->n41_a_major_case_34 n41_a_major_case_32 ADV n41_a_major_case_31->n41_a_major_case_32 n41_a_major_case_32->n41_a_major_case_33 n41_a_major_case_34->n41_a_major_case_35 n41_a_major_case_36->n41_a_major_case_37 n41_a_major_case_39 IP-PPL3 n41_a_major_case_38->n41_a_major_case_39 n41_a_major_case_40 ADVP-NIM n41_a_major_case_39->n41_a_major_case_40 n41_a_major_case_43 HAG;_Tn_ n41_a_major_case_39->n41_a_major_case_43 n41_a_major_case_45 NP-OB1 n41_a_major_case_39->n41_a_major_case_45 n41_a_major_case_41 ADV n41_a_major_case_40->n41_a_major_case_41 n41_a_major_case_41->n41_a_major_case_42 n41_a_major_case_43->n41_a_major_case_44 n41_a_major_case_46 N n41_a_major_case_45->n41_a_major_case_46 n41_a_major_case_48 PP n41_a_major_case_45->n41_a_major_case_48 n41_a_major_case_46->n41_a_major_case_47 n41_a_major_case_49 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_48->n41_a_major_case_49 n41_a_major_case_51 NP n41_a_major_case_48->n41_a_major_case_51 n41_a_major_case_49->n41_a_major_case_50 n41_a_major_case_52 D n41_a_major_case_51->n41_a_major_case_52 n41_a_major_case_54 NS n41_a_major_case_51->n41_a_major_case_54 n41_a_major_case_56 IP-PPL n41_a_major_case_51->n41_a_major_case_56 n41_a_major_case_52->n41_a_major_case_53 n41_a_major_case_54->n41_a_major_case_55 n41_a_major_case_57 VVN;__ n41_a_major_case_56->n41_a_major_case_57 n41_a_major_case_59 RP n41_a_major_case_56->n41_a_major_case_59 n41_a_major_case_61 PP-NIM n41_a_major_case_56->n41_a_major_case_61 n41_a_major_case_57->n41_a_major_case_58 n41_a_major_case_59->n41_a_major_case_60 n41_a_major_case_62 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_61->n41_a_major_case_62 n41_a_major_case_64 NP n41_a_major_case_61->n41_a_major_case_64 n41_a_major_case_62->n41_a_major_case_63 n41_a_major_case_65 NP-GEN n41_a_major_case_64->n41_a_major_case_65 n41_a_major_case_72 ADJP n41_a_major_case_64->n41_a_major_case_72 n41_a_major_case_75 NS n41_a_major_case_64->n41_a_major_case_75 n41_a_major_case_77 PP n41_a_major_case_64->n41_a_major_case_77 n41_a_major_case_66 NPR n41_a_major_case_65->n41_a_major_case_66 n41_a_major_case_68 NPR n41_a_major_case_65->n41_a_major_case_68 n41_a_major_case_70 GENM n41_a_major_case_65->n41_a_major_case_70 n41_a_major_case_66->n41_a_major_case_67 n41_a_major_case_68->n41_a_major_case_69 n41_a_major_case_70->n41_a_major_case_71 n41_a_major_case_73 ADJ n41_a_major_case_72->n41_a_major_case_73 n41_a_major_case_73->n41_a_major_case_74 n41_a_major_case_75->n41_a_major_case_76 n41_a_major_case_78 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_77->n41_a_major_case_78 n41_a_major_case_80 NP n41_a_major_case_77->n41_a_major_case_80 n41_a_major_case_78->n41_a_major_case_79 n41_a_major_case_81 N n41_a_major_case_80->n41_a_major_case_81 n41_a_major_case_83 NUM n41_a_major_case_80->n41_a_major_case_83 n41_a_major_case_81->n41_a_major_case_82 n41_a_major_case_83->n41_a_major_case_84 n41_a_major_case_85->n41_a_major_case_86 n41_a_major_case_88 IP-SUB n41_a_major_case_87->n41_a_major_case_88 n41_a_major_case_89 C n41_a_major_case_88->n41_a_major_case_89 n41_a_major_case_91 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_88->n41_a_major_case_91 n41_a_major_case_96 HVD;_Tn_ n41_a_major_case_88->n41_a_major_case_96 n41_a_major_case_98 NP-OB1 n41_a_major_case_88->n41_a_major_case_98 n41_a_major_case_89->n41_a_major_case_90 n41_a_major_case_92 D n41_a_major_case_91->n41_a_major_case_92 n41_a_major_case_94 N n41_a_major_case_91->n41_a_major_case_94 n41_a_major_case_92->n41_a_major_case_93 n41_a_major_case_94->n41_a_major_case_95 n41_a_major_case_96->n41_a_major_case_97 n41_a_major_case_99 D n41_a_major_case_98->n41_a_major_case_99 n41_a_major_case_101 N n41_a_major_case_98->n41_a_major_case_101 n41_a_major_case_103 ADJP n41_a_major_case_98->n41_a_major_case_103 n41_a_major_case_99->n41_a_major_case_100 n41_a_major_case_101->n41_a_major_case_102 n41_a_major_case_104 ADJ n41_a_major_case_103->n41_a_major_case_104 n41_a_major_case_106 PP n41_a_major_case_103->n41_a_major_case_106 n41_a_major_case_104->n41_a_major_case_105 n41_a_major_case_107 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_106->n41_a_major_case_107 n41_a_major_case_109 NP n41_a_major_case_106->n41_a_major_case_109 n41_a_major_case_107->n41_a_major_case_108 n41_a_major_case_110 D;_nphd_ n41_a_major_case_109->n41_a_major_case_110 n41_a_major_case_112 IP-REL n41_a_major_case_109->n41_a_major_case_112 n41_a_major_case_110->n41_a_major_case_111 n41_a_major_case_113 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_112->n41_a_major_case_113 n41_a_major_case_116 BEP;_cat_VePASS_ n41_a_major_case_112->n41_a_major_case_116 n41_a_major_case_118 IP-PPL-CAT n41_a_major_case_112->n41_a_major_case_118 n41_a_major_case_114 RPRO n41_a_major_case_113->n41_a_major_case_114 n41_a_major_case_114->n41_a_major_case_115 n41_a_major_case_116->n41_a_major_case_117 n41_a_major_case_119 NP-LGS n41_a_major_case_118->n41_a_major_case_119 n41_a_major_case_121 VVN;__ n41_a_major_case_118->n41_a_major_case_121 n41_a_major_case_123 PP-NIM n41_a_major_case_118->n41_a_major_case_123 n41_a_major_case_119->n41_a_major_case_120 n41_a_major_case_121->n41_a_major_case_122 n41_a_major_case_124 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_123->n41_a_major_case_124 n41_a_major_case_126 NP n41_a_major_case_123->n41_a_major_case_126 n41_a_major_case_124->n41_a_major_case_125 n41_a_major_case_127 D n41_a_major_case_126->n41_a_major_case_127 n41_a_major_case_129 N n41_a_major_case_126->n41_a_major_case_129 n41_a_major_case_131 PP n41_a_major_case_126->n41_a_major_case_131 n41_a_major_case_127->n41_a_major_case_128 n41_a_major_case_129->n41_a_major_case_130 n41_a_major_case_132 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_131->n41_a_major_case_132 n41_a_major_case_134 NP n41_a_major_case_131->n41_a_major_case_134 n41_a_major_case_132->n41_a_major_case_133 n41_a_major_case_135 NS n41_a_major_case_134->n41_a_major_case_135 n41_a_major_case_137 IP-PPL n41_a_major_case_134->n41_a_major_case_137 n41_a_major_case_135->n41_a_major_case_136 n41_a_major_case_138 NP-LGS n41_a_major_case_137->n41_a_major_case_138 n41_a_major_case_140 VVN;__ n41_a_major_case_137->n41_a_major_case_140 n41_a_major_case_138->n41_a_major_case_139 n41_a_major_case_140->n41_a_major_case_141 n41_a_major_case_142->n41_a_major_case_143 n41_a_major_case_145 CONJ n41_a_major_case_144->n41_a_major_case_145 n41_a_major_case_147 PUNC n41_a_major_case_144->n41_a_major_case_147 n41_a_major_case_149 ILYR n41_a_major_case_144->n41_a_major_case_149 n41_a_major_case_145->n41_a_major_case_146 n41_a_major_case_147->n41_a_major_case_148 n41_a_major_case_150 LST n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_150 n41_a_major_case_153 PP-SCON n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_153 n41_a_major_case_164 PUNC n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_164 n41_a_major_case_166 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_166 n41_a_major_case_292 PUNC n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_292 n41_a_major_case_294 BEP;_La_ n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_294 n41_a_major_case_296 ADJP-PRD n41_a_major_case_149->n41_a_major_case_296 n41_a_major_case_151 LS n41_a_major_case_150->n41_a_major_case_151 n41_a_major_case_151->n41_a_major_case_152 n41_a_major_case_154 ADV n41_a_major_case_153->n41_a_major_case_154 n41_a_major_case_156 P-CONN n41_a_major_case_153->n41_a_major_case_156 n41_a_major_case_158 IP-ADV n41_a_major_case_153->n41_a_major_case_158 n41_a_major_case_154->n41_a_major_case_155 n41_a_major_case_156->n41_a_major_case_157 n41_a_major_case_159 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_158->n41_a_major_case_159 n41_a_major_case_162 BED;__ n41_a_major_case_158->n41_a_major_case_162 n41_a_major_case_160 PRO n41_a_major_case_159->n41_a_major_case_160 n41_a_major_case_160->n41_a_major_case_161 n41_a_major_case_162->n41_a_major_case_163 n41_a_major_case_164->n41_a_major_case_165 n41_a_major_case_167 NLYR n41_a_major_case_166->n41_a_major_case_167 n41_a_major_case_168 NLYR n41_a_major_case_167->n41_a_major_case_168 n41_a_major_case_224 PUNC n41_a_major_case_167->n41_a_major_case_224 n41_a_major_case_226 CONJP n41_a_major_case_167->n41_a_major_case_226 n41_a_major_case_169 D n41_a_major_case_168->n41_a_major_case_169 n41_a_major_case_171 N n41_a_major_case_168->n41_a_major_case_171 n41_a_major_case_173 PP n41_a_major_case_168->n41_a_major_case_173 n41_a_major_case_169->n41_a_major_case_170 n41_a_major_case_171->n41_a_major_case_172 n41_a_major_case_174 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_173->n41_a_major_case_174 n41_a_major_case_176 NP n41_a_major_case_173->n41_a_major_case_176 n41_a_major_case_174->n41_a_major_case_175 n41_a_major_case_177 D n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_177 n41_a_major_case_179 ADJP n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_179 n41_a_major_case_182 NS n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_182 n41_a_major_case_184 PULB n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_184 n41_a_major_case_186 PRN n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_186 n41_a_major_case_222 PURB n41_a_major_case_176->n41_a_major_case_222 n41_a_major_case_177->n41_a_major_case_178 n41_a_major_case_180 ADJ n41_a_major_case_179->n41_a_major_case_180 n41_a_major_case_180->n41_a_major_case_181 n41_a_major_case_182->n41_a_major_case_183 n41_a_major_case_184->n41_a_major_case_185 n41_a_major_case_187 PP n41_a_major_case_186->n41_a_major_case_187 n41_a_major_case_188 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_187->n41_a_major_case_188 n41_a_major_case_190 NP n41_a_major_case_187->n41_a_major_case_190 n41_a_major_case_188->n41_a_major_case_189 n41_a_major_case_191 D;_nphd_ n41_a_major_case_190->n41_a_major_case_191 n41_a_major_case_193 IP-PPL n41_a_major_case_190->n41_a_major_case_193 n41_a_major_case_191->n41_a_major_case_192 n41_a_major_case_194 VVN;__ n41_a_major_case_193->n41_a_major_case_194 n41_a_major_case_196 RP n41_a_major_case_193->n41_a_major_case_196 n41_a_major_case_198 PP-NIM n41_a_major_case_193->n41_a_major_case_198 n41_a_major_case_194->n41_a_major_case_195 n41_a_major_case_196->n41_a_major_case_197 n41_a_major_case_199 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_198->n41_a_major_case_199 n41_a_major_case_201 NP n41_a_major_case_198->n41_a_major_case_201 n41_a_major_case_199->n41_a_major_case_200 n41_a_major_case_202 NP-GEN n41_a_major_case_201->n41_a_major_case_202 n41_a_major_case_209 ADJP n41_a_major_case_201->n41_a_major_case_209 n41_a_major_case_212 NS n41_a_major_case_201->n41_a_major_case_212 n41_a_major_case_214 PP n41_a_major_case_201->n41_a_major_case_214 n41_a_major_case_203 NPR n41_a_major_case_202->n41_a_major_case_203 n41_a_major_case_205 NPR n41_a_major_case_202->n41_a_major_case_205 n41_a_major_case_207 GENM n41_a_major_case_202->n41_a_major_case_207 n41_a_major_case_203->n41_a_major_case_204 n41_a_major_case_205->n41_a_major_case_206 n41_a_major_case_207->n41_a_major_case_208 n41_a_major_case_210 ADJ n41_a_major_case_209->n41_a_major_case_210 n41_a_major_case_210->n41_a_major_case_211 n41_a_major_case_212->n41_a_major_case_213 n41_a_major_case_215 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_214->n41_a_major_case_215 n41_a_major_case_217 NP n41_a_major_case_214->n41_a_major_case_217 n41_a_major_case_215->n41_a_major_case_216 n41_a_major_case_218 N n41_a_major_case_217->n41_a_major_case_218 n41_a_major_case_220 NUM n41_a_major_case_217->n41_a_major_case_220 n41_a_major_case_218->n41_a_major_case_219 n41_a_major_case_220->n41_a_major_case_221 n41_a_major_case_222->n41_a_major_case_223 n41_a_major_case_224->n41_a_major_case_225 n41_a_major_case_227 CONJ n41_a_major_case_226->n41_a_major_case_227 n41_a_major_case_229 NLYR n41_a_major_case_226->n41_a_major_case_229 n41_a_major_case_227->n41_a_major_case_228 n41_a_major_case_230 D n41_a_major_case_229->n41_a_major_case_230 n41_a_major_case_232 N n41_a_major_case_229->n41_a_major_case_232 n41_a_major_case_234 PP n41_a_major_case_229->n41_a_major_case_234 n41_a_major_case_230->n41_a_major_case_231 n41_a_major_case_232->n41_a_major_case_233 n41_a_major_case_235 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_234->n41_a_major_case_235 n41_a_major_case_237 NP n41_a_major_case_234->n41_a_major_case_237 n41_a_major_case_235->n41_a_major_case_236 n41_a_major_case_238 N n41_a_major_case_237->n41_a_major_case_238 n41_a_major_case_240 PP n41_a_major_case_237->n41_a_major_case_240 n41_a_major_case_248 IP-REL n41_a_major_case_237->n41_a_major_case_248 n41_a_major_case_238->n41_a_major_case_239 n41_a_major_case_241 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_240->n41_a_major_case_241 n41_a_major_case_243 NP n41_a_major_case_240->n41_a_major_case_243 n41_a_major_case_241->n41_a_major_case_242 n41_a_major_case_244 D n41_a_major_case_243->n41_a_major_case_244 n41_a_major_case_246 N n41_a_major_case_243->n41_a_major_case_246 n41_a_major_case_244->n41_a_major_case_245 n41_a_major_case_246->n41_a_major_case_247 n41_a_major_case_249 NP-172 n41_a_major_case_248->n41_a_major_case_249 n41_a_major_case_252 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_248->n41_a_major_case_252 n41_a_major_case_255 MD;_cat_Vi_ n41_a_major_case_248->n41_a_major_case_255 n41_a_major_case_257 IP-INF-CAT n41_a_major_case_248->n41_a_major_case_257 n41_a_major_case_250 RPRO n41_a_major_case_249->n41_a_major_case_250 n41_a_major_case_250->n41_a_major_case_251 n41_a_major_case_253 PRO;_provisional_ n41_a_major_case_252->n41_a_major_case_253 n41_a_major_case_253->n41_a_major_case_254 n41_a_major_case_255->n41_a_major_case_256 n41_a_major_case_258 BE;_La_ n41_a_major_case_257->n41_a_major_case_258 n41_a_major_case_260 ADJP-PRD n41_a_major_case_257->n41_a_major_case_260 n41_a_major_case_266 IP-INF-NSBJ n41_a_major_case_257->n41_a_major_case_266 n41_a_major_case_258->n41_a_major_case_259 n41_a_major_case_261 ADVP n41_a_major_case_260->n41_a_major_case_261 n41_a_major_case_264 ADJ n41_a_major_case_260->n41_a_major_case_264 n41_a_major_case_262 ADV n41_a_major_case_261->n41_a_major_case_262 n41_a_major_case_262->n41_a_major_case_263 n41_a_major_case_264->n41_a_major_case_265 n41_a_major_case_267 NP-OB1 n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_267 n41_a_major_case_269 P-CONN n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_269 n41_a_major_case_271 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_271 n41_a_major_case_276 TO n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_276 n41_a_major_case_278 VB;__ n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_278 n41_a_major_case_280 PP-SCON n41_a_major_case_266->n41_a_major_case_280 n41_a_major_case_267->n41_a_major_case_268 n41_a_major_case_269->n41_a_major_case_270 n41_a_major_case_272 D n41_a_major_case_271->n41_a_major_case_272 n41_a_major_case_274 N n41_a_major_case_271->n41_a_major_case_274 n41_a_major_case_272->n41_a_major_case_273 n41_a_major_case_274->n41_a_major_case_275 n41_a_major_case_276->n41_a_major_case_277 n41_a_major_case_278->n41_a_major_case_279 n41_a_major_case_281 P-CONN n41_a_major_case_280->n41_a_major_case_281 n41_a_major_case_283 IP-ADV n41_a_major_case_280->n41_a_major_case_283 n41_a_major_case_281->n41_a_major_case_282 n41_a_major_case_284 NP-SBJ n41_a_major_case_283->n41_a_major_case_284 n41_a_major_case_287 BED;_La_ n41_a_major_case_283->n41_a_major_case_287 n41_a_major_case_289 ADJP-PRD n41_a_major_case_283->n41_a_major_case_289 n41_a_major_case_285 PRO n41_a_major_case_284->n41_a_major_case_285 n41_a_major_case_285->n41_a_major_case_286 n41_a_major_case_287->n41_a_major_case_288 n41_a_major_case_290 ADJ n41_a_major_case_289->n41_a_major_case_290 n41_a_major_case_290->n41_a_major_case_291 n41_a_major_case_292->n41_a_major_case_293 n41_a_major_case_294->n41_a_major_case_295 n41_a_major_case_297 ADJR n41_a_major_case_296->n41_a_major_case_297 n41_a_major_case_299 PP n41_a_major_case_296->n41_a_major_case_299 n41_a_major_case_297->n41_a_major_case_298 n41_a_major_case_300 P-ROLE n41_a_major_case_299->n41_a_major_case_300 n41_a_major_case_302 NP n41_a_major_case_299->n41_a_major_case_302 n41_a_major_case_300->n41_a_major_case_301 n41_a_major_case_303 ADJP n41_a_major_case_302->n41_a_major_case_303 n41_a_major_case_304 ADJ n41_a_major_case_303->n41_a_major_case_304 n41_a_major_case_306 IP-INF n41_a_major_case_303->n41_a_major_case_306 n41_a_major_case_304->n41_a_major_case_305 n41_a_major_case_307 TO n41_a_major_case_306->n41_a_major_case_307 n41_a_major_case_309 VB;__ n41_a_major_case_306->n41_a_major_case_309 n41_a_major_case_311 NP-OB1 n41_a_major_case_306->n41_a_major_case_311 n41_a_major_case_307->n41_a_major_case_308 n41_a_major_case_309->n41_a_major_case_310 n41_a_major_case_312 D n41_a_major_case_311->n41_a_major_case_312 n41_a_major_case_314 ADJP n41_a_major_case_311->n41_a_major_case_314 n41_a_major_case_317 N n41_a_major_case_311->n41_a_major_case_317 n41_a_major_case_312->n41_a_major_case_313 n41_a_major_case_315 ADJ;_such_ n41_a_major_case_314->n41_a_major_case_315 n41_a_major_case_315->n41_a_major_case_316 n41_a_major_case_317->n41_a_major_case_318 n41_a_major_case_319->n41_a_major_case_320 
( (IP-MAT (PP-NIM (P-ROLE On;{on})
                  (NP (D that;{that})
                      (N issue;{issue})))
          (PUNC :)
          (ILYR (ILYR (LST (LS 18<dot>1))
                      (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                      (BEP;_La_ is;{be})
                      (PP-NIM (P-ROLE by;{by})
                              (NP (Q no;{no})
                                  (NS means;{mean})))
                      (ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV inherently;{inherently}))
                                (ADJ improbable;{improbable}))
                      (PUNC ,)
                      (PP-SCON (IP-PPL3 (ADVP-NIM (ADV particularly;{particularly}))
                                        (HAG;_Tn_ having;{have})
                                        (NP-OB1 (N regard;{regard})
                                                (PP (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                    (NP (D the;{the})
                                                        (NS matters;{matter})
                                                        (IP-PPL (VVN;__ set;{set})
                                                                (RP out;{out})
                                                                (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                        (NP (NP-GEN;{MAJOR} (NPR Sir;{Sir})
                                                                                            (NPR John;{John})
                                                                                            (GENM <apos>s))
                                                                            (ADJP (ADJ previous;{previous}))
                                                                            (NS submissions;{submission})
                                                                            (PP (P-ROLE at;{at})
                                                                                (NP (N <sect><sect>)
                                                                                    (NUM 20)))))))))))
                      (PUNC ,)
                      (CP-THT-NSBJ (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                           (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                                   (N Defendant;{defendant}))
                                           (HVD;_Tn_ had;{have})
                                           (NP-OB1 (D a;{a})
                                                   (N purpose;{purpose})
                                                   (ADJP (ADJ other;{other})
                                                         (PP (P-ROLE than;{than})
                                                             (NP (D;_nphd_ that;{that})
                                                                 (IP-REL (NP-SBJ (RPRO which;{which}))
                                                                         (BEP;_cat_VePASS_ is;{be})
                                                                         (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                     (VVN;__ recorded;{record})
                                                                                     (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                             (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                                                 (N handful;{handful})
                                                                                                 (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                                                     (NP (NS documents;{document})
                                                                                                         (IP-PPL (NP-LGS *)
                                                                                                                 (VVN;__ disclosed;{disclose})))))))))))))))
                (PUNC ;)
                (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                       (PUNC ,)
                       (ILYR (LST (LS 18<dot>2))
                             (PP-SCON (ADV even;{even})
                                      (P-CONN if;{if})
                                      (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ (PRO it;{it}))
                                              (BED;__ were;{be})))
                             (PUNC ,)
                             (NP-SBJ (NLYR (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                                 (N evidence;{evidence})
                                                 (PP (P-ROLE as_to;{as_to})
                                                     (NP (D the;{the})
                                                         (ADJP (ADJ true;{true}))
                                                         (NS reasons;{reason})
                                                         (PULB -LRB-)
                                                         (PRN (PP (P-ROLE such_as;{such_as})
                                                                  (NP (D;_nphd_ that;{that})
                                                                      (IP-PPL (VVN;__ set;{set})
                                                                              (RP out;{out})
                                                                              (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                                                      (NP (NP-GEN;{MAJOR} (NPR Sir;{Sir})
                                                                                                          (NPR John;{John})
                                                                                                          (GENM <apos>s))
                                                                                          (ADJP (ADJ previous;{previous}))
                                                                                          (NS submissions;{submission})
                                                                                          (PP (P-ROLE at;{at})
                                                                                              (NP (N <sect><sect>)
                                                                                                  (NUM 16)))))))))
                                                         (PURB -RRB-))))
                                           (PUNC ,)
                                           (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                                  (NLYR (D the;{the})
                                                        (N absence;{absence})
                                                        (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                            (NP (N evidence;{evidence})
                                                                (PP (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                                    (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                        (N contrary;{contrary})))
                                                                (IP-REL (NP-172 (RPRO which;{which}))
                                                                        (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                                                                        (MD;_cat_Vi_ would;{will})
                                                                        (IP-INF-CAT (BE;_La_ be;{be})
                                                                                    (ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV readily;{readily}))
                                                                                              (ADJ possible;{possible}))
                                                                                    (IP-INF-NSBJ (NP-OB1 *ICH*-172)
                                                                                                 (P-CONN for;{for})
                                                                                                 (NP-SBJ;{JOHNSON} (D the;{the})
                                                                                                                   (N Defendant;{defendant}))
                                                                                                 (TO to;{to})
                                                                                                 (VB;__ provide;{provide})
                                                                                                 (PP-SCON (P-CONN if;{if})
                                                                                                          (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ (PRO it;{it}))
                                                                                                                  (BED;_La_ were;{be})
                                                                                                                  (ADJP-PRD (ADJ true;{true})))))))))))))
                             (PUNC ,)
                             (BEP;_La_ are;{be})
                             (ADJP-PRD (ADJR more;{more})
                                       (PP (P-ROLE than;{than})
                                           (NP (ADJP (ADJ sufficient;{sufficient})
                                                     (IP-INF (TO to;{to})
                                                             (VB;__ override;{override})
                                                             (NP-OB1 (D any;{any})
                                                                     (ADJP (ADJ;_such_ such;{such}))
                                                                     (N improbability;{improbability}))))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 41_a_major_case))