51_a_uksc_judgment
61. It is impossible for us to conclude , on the evidence which has been put before us , that there was any reason - let alone a good reason - to advise Her Majesty to prorogue Parliament for five weeks , from 9th or 12th September until 14th October .

%3 0051_0003__is is 0051_0004__impossible impossible 0051_0003__is->0051_0004__impossible [prd2] 0051_0008__conclude conclude 0051_0003__is->0051_0008__conclude [argn0] 0051_0006__us us 0051_0008__conclude->0051_0006__us [arg0] 0051_0011__the_0051_0012__evidence the_evidence 0051_0008__conclude->0051_0011__the_0051_0012__evidence on[rst] 0051_0022__was_0051_0032__advise was_advise 0051_0008__conclude->0051_0022__was_0051_0032__advise [arg1] 0051_0023__any_0051_0024__reason any_reason 0051_0022__was_0051_0032__advise->0051_0023__any_0051_0024__reason [arg0] 0051_0033__He0051_0034__Majesty her_majesty 0051_0022__was_0051_0032__advise->0051_0033__He0051_0034__Majesty [arg2] 0051_0036__prorogue prorogue 0051_0022__was_0051_0032__advise->0051_0036__prorogue [arg1] 0051_0014__has_0051_0015__been_0051_0016__put has_been_put 0051_0014__has_0051_0015__been_0051_0016__put->0051_0006__us before[bnf] 0051_0014__has_0051_0015__been_0051_0016__put->0051_0011__the_0051_0012__evidence [arg1] 0051_0027__a_0051_0029__reason a_reason 0051_0023__any_0051_0024__reason->0051_0027__a_0051_0029__reason let_alone 0051_0036__prorogue->0051_0033__He0051_0034__Majesty [arg0] 0051_0037__Parliament parliament 0051_0036__prorogue->0051_0037__Parliament [arg1] 0051_0039__five_0051_0040__weeks five_weeks 0051_0036__prorogue->0051_0039__five_0051_0040__weeks for[tmp] 0051_0046__September september 0051_0036__prorogue->0051_0046__September from[dir] 0051_0049__October october 0051_0036__prorogue->0051_0049__October until[dir] 0051_0028__good good 0051_0027__a_0051_0029__reason->0051_0028__good [attrib] 0051_0044__or or 0051_0046__September->0051_0044__or [attrib] 0051_0048__14th 14th 0051_0049__October->0051_0048__14th [attrib] 0051_0043__9th 9th 0051_0044__or->0051_0043__9th [conj1] 0051_0045__12th 12th 0051_0044__or->0051_0045__12th [conj2]
arc(r_0051_0003__is,r_0051_0004__impossible,prd2).
arc(r_0051_0003__is,r_0051_0008__conclude,argn0).
arc(r_0051_0008__conclude,r_0051_0006__us,arg0).
arc(r_0051_0008__conclude,r_0051_0011__the_r_0051_0012__evidence,r_0051_0010__on__rst).
arc(r_0051_0008__conclude,r_0051_0022__was_r_0051_0032__advise,arg1).
arc(r_0051_0014__has_r_0051_0015__been_r_0051_0016__put,r_0051_0006__us,r_0051_0017__before__bnf).
arc(r_0051_0014__has_r_0051_0015__been_r_0051_0016__put,r_0051_0011__the_r_0051_0012__evidence,arg1).
arc(r_0051_0022__was_r_0051_0032__advise,r_0051_0023__any_r_0051_0024__reason,arg0).
arc(r_0051_0022__was_r_0051_0032__advise,r_0051_0033__Her_r_0051_0034__Majesty,arg2).
arc(r_0051_0022__was_r_0051_0032__advise,r_0051_0036__prorogue,arg1).
arc(r_0051_0023__any_r_0051_0024__reason,r_0051_0027__a_r_0051_0029__reason,r_0051_0026__let_alone).
arc(r_0051_0027__a_r_0051_0029__reason,r_0051_0028__good,attrib).
arc(r_0051_0036__prorogue,r_0051_0033__Her_r_0051_0034__Majesty,arg0).
arc(r_0051_0036__prorogue,r_0051_0037__Parliament,arg1).
arc(r_0051_0036__prorogue,r_0051_0039__five_r_0051_0040__weeks,r_0051_0038__for__tmp).
arc(r_0051_0036__prorogue,r_0051_0046__September,r_0051_0042__from__dir).
arc(r_0051_0036__prorogue,r_0051_0049__October,r_0051_0047__until__dir).
arc(r_0051_0044__or,r_0051_0043__9th,conj1).
arc(r_0051_0044__or,r_0051_0045__12th,conj2).
arc(r_0051_0046__September,r_0051_0044__or,attrib).
arc(r_0051_0049__October,r_0051_0048__14th,attrib).


IP-MAT LST LS 61. NP-SBJ PRO;_provisional_ It BEP;~La is ADJP-PRD2 ADJ impossible IP-INF-NSBJ P-CONN for NP-SBJ PRO us TO to VB conclude PUNC , PP-RST P-ROLE on NP D the N evidence IP-REL NP-SBJ RPRO which HVP;~cat_Ve has IP-PPL-CAT BEN;~cat_Ve_passive_ been IP-PPL-CAT NP-LGS * VVN put PP-BNF P-ROLE before NP PRO us PUNC , CP-THT-OB1 IP-SUB C that EX there BED;~ex_cat_Vt was NP-ESBJ D any N reason PUNC - PP P-ROLE let_alone NP D a ADJP ADJ good N reason PUNC - IP-INF-CAT TO to VB;~Dn.t advise NP-OB2 NPR Her NPR Majesty IP-INF-OB1 TO to VB prorogue NP-OB1 NPR Parliament PP-TMP P-ROLE for NP NUM five NS weeks PUNC , PP-DIR P-ROLE from NP ADJP AJLYR ADJP ADJ 9th CONJP CONJ or ADJP ADJ 12th NPR September PP-DIR P-ROLE until NP ADJP ADJ 14th NPR October PUNC .
( (IP-MAT (LST (LS 61<dot>))
          (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ It;{it}))
          (BEP;~La is;{be})
          (ADJP-PRD2 (ADJ impossible;{impossible}))
          (IP-INF-NSBJ (P-CONN for;{for})
                       (NP-SBJ (PRO us;{we}))
                       (TO to;{to})
                       (VB conclude;{conclude})
                       (PUNC ,)
                       (PP-RST (P-ROLE on;{on})
                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                   (N evidence;{evidence})
                                   (IP-REL (NP-SBJ (RPRO which;{which}))
                                           (HVP;~cat_Ve has;{have})
                                           (IP-PPL-CAT (BEN;~cat_Ve_passive_ been;{be})
                                                       (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                                                   (VVN put;{put})
                                                                   (PP-BNF (P-ROLE before;{before})
                                                                           (NP (PRO us;{we}))))))))
                       (PUNC ,)
                       (CP-THT-OB1 (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                           (EX there;{there})
                                           (BED;~ex_cat_Vt was;{be})
                                           (NP-ESBJ (D any;{any})
                                                    (N reason;{reason})
                                                    (PUNC -)
                                                    (PP (P-ROLE let_alone;{let_alone})
                                                        (NP (D a;{a})
                                                            (ADJP (ADJ good;{good}))
                                                            (N reason;{reason}))))
                                           (PUNC -)
                                           (IP-INF-CAT (TO to;{to})
                                                       (VB;~Dn.t advise;{advise})
                                                       (NP-OB2 (NPR Her;{Her})
                                                               (NPR Majesty;{Majesty}))
                                                       (IP-INF-OB1 (TO to;{to})
                                                                   (VB prorogue;{prorogue})
                                                                   (NP-OB1;{PARLIAMENT} (NPR Parliament;{Parliament}))
                                                                   (PP-TMP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                                           (NP (NUM five;{five})
                                                                               (NS weeks;{week})))
                                                                   (PUNC ,)
                                                                   (PP-DIR (P-ROLE from;{from})
                                                                           (NP (ADJP (AJLYR (ADJP (ADJ 9th))
                                                                                            (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                                                                   (ADJP (ADJ 12th)))))
                                                                               (NPR September;{September})))
                                                                   (PP-DIR (P-ROLE until;{until})
                                                                           (NP (ADJP (ADJ 14th))
                                                                               (NPR October;{October}))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 51_a_uksc_judgment))