TSPC 70_a_hedgehog

70_a_hedgehog
An analysis of the original badger culling experiments, published in April 2014, shows that while at some sites hedgehog numbers did increase, following a reduction in the number of badgers, it was thought that some of the sample sizes might have been too small.

arc(r_0070_0001__An_r_0070_0002__analysis, r_0070_0004__the_r_0070_0006__badger_r_0070_0007__culling_r_0070_0008__experiments, r_0070_0003__of).
arc(r_0070_0004__the_r_0070_0006__badger_r_0070_0007__culling_r_0070_0008__experiments, r_0070_0005__original, attrib13).
arc(r_0070_0010__published, r_0070_0004__the_r_0070_0006__badger_r_0070_0007__culling_r_0070_0008__experiments, arg1).
arc(r_0070_0010__published, r_0070_0012__April_r_0070_0013__2014, r_0070_0011__in_nim32).
arc(r_0070_0010__published, z_000_70_a_hedgehog_25, arg0).
arc(r_0070_0015__shows, r_0070_0001__An_r_0070_0002__analysis, arg0).
arc(r_0070_0015__shows, r_0070_0017__while, arg1).
arc(r_0070_0016__that_r_0070_0036__was, r_0070_0037__thought, scope).
arc(r_0070_0017__while, r_0070_0016__that_r_0070_0036__was, scope).
arc(r_0070_0017__while, r_0070_0023__did_r_0070_0024__increase, restriction).
arc(r_0070_0023__did_r_0070_0024__increase, r_0070_0019__some_r_0070_0020__sites, r_0070_0018__at_nim52).
arc(r_0070_0023__did_r_0070_0024__increase, r_0070_0021__hedgehog_r_0070_0022__numbers, arg0).
arc(r_0070_0023__did_r_0070_0024__increase, r_0070_0027__a_r_0070_0028__reduction, r_0070_0026__following_nim71).
arc(r_0070_0027__a_r_0070_0028__reduction, r_0070_0030__the_r_0070_0031__number, r_0070_0029__in).
arc(r_0070_0030__the_r_0070_0031__number, r_0070_0033__badgers, r_0070_0032__of).
arc(r_0070_0037__thought, r_0070_0038__that_r_0070_0044__might, arg1).
arc(r_0070_0037__thought, z_000_70_a_hedgehog_98, arg0).
arc(r_0070_0038__that_r_0070_0044__might, r_0070_0045__have, scope).
arc(r_0070_0039__some, r_0070_0041__the_r_0070_0042__sample_r_0070_0043__sizes, r_0070_0040__of).
arc(r_0070_0045__have, r_0070_0046__been, scope).
arc(r_0070_0046__been, r_0070_0039__some, arg0).
arc(r_0070_0046__been, r_0070_0048__small, prd).
arc(r_0070_0048__small, r_0070_0047__too, qual128).

fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_0070_0005__ORIGINAL,R_0070_0004__THE_R_0070_0006__BADGER_R_0070_0007__CULLING_R_0070_0008__EXPERIMENTS,R_0070_0012__APRIL_R_0070_0013__2014,Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_25,R_0070_0010__PUBLISHED,R_0070_0001__AN_R_0070_0002__ANALYSIS,R_0070_0041__THE_R_0070_0042__SAMPLE_R_0070_0043__SIZES,R_0070_0039__SOME,R_0070_0047__TOO,R_0070_0048__SMALL,R_0070_0038__THAT_R_0070_0044__MIGHT_R_0070_0045__HAVE_R_0070_0046__BEEN,Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_98,R_0070_0016__THAT_R_0070_0036__WAS_R_0070_0037__THOUGHT,R_0070_0019__SOME_R_0070_0020__SITES,R_0070_0021__HEDGEHOG_R_0070_0022__NUMBERS,R_0070_0033__BADGERS,R_0070_0030__THE_R_0070_0031__NUMBER,R_0070_0027__A_R_0070_0028__REDUCTION,R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE,R_0070_0017__WHILE,R_0070_0015__SHOWS] :
      ( r_0070_0005__original(R_0070_0005__ORIGINAL)
      & r_0070_0012__April_r_0070_0013__2014(R_0070_0012__APRIL_R_0070_0013__2014)
      & r_0070_0019__some_r_0070_0020__sites(R_0070_0019__SOME_R_0070_0020__SITES)
      & r_0070_0021__hedgehog_r_0070_0022__numbers(R_0070_0021__HEDGEHOG_R_0070_0022__NUMBERS)
      & r_0070_0033__badgers(R_0070_0033__BADGERS)
      & r_0070_0041__the_r_0070_0042__sample_r_0070_0043__sizes(R_0070_0041__THE_R_0070_0042__SAMPLE_R_0070_0043__SIZES)
      & r_0070_0047__too(R_0070_0047__TOO)
      & z_000_70_a_hedgehog_25(Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_25)
      & z_000_70_a_hedgehog_98(Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_98)
      & r_0070_0015__shows(R_0070_0015__SHOWS)
      & has_arg1(R_0070_0015__SHOWS,R_0070_0017__WHILE)
      & r_0070_0017__while(R_0070_0017__WHILE)
      & has_conj1(R_0070_0017__WHILE,R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE)
      & r_0070_0023__did_r_0070_0024__increase(R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE)
      & has_r_0070_0026__following_nim71(R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE,R_0070_0027__A_R_0070_0028__REDUCTION)
      & r_0070_0027__a_r_0070_0028__reduction(R_0070_0027__A_R_0070_0028__REDUCTION)
      & has_r_0070_0029__in(R_0070_0027__A_R_0070_0028__REDUCTION,R_0070_0030__THE_R_0070_0031__NUMBER)
      & r_0070_0030__the_r_0070_0031__number(R_0070_0030__THE_R_0070_0031__NUMBER)
      & has_r_0070_0032__of(R_0070_0030__THE_R_0070_0031__NUMBER,R_0070_0033__BADGERS)
      & has_arg0(R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE,R_0070_0021__HEDGEHOG_R_0070_0022__NUMBERS)
      & has_r_0070_0018__at_nim52(R_0070_0023__DID_R_0070_0024__INCREASE,R_0070_0019__SOME_R_0070_0020__SITES)
      & has_conj2(R_0070_0017__WHILE,R_0070_0016__THAT_R_0070_0036__WAS_R_0070_0037__THOUGHT)
      & r_0070_0016__that_r_0070_0036__was_r_0070_0037__thought(R_0070_0016__THAT_R_0070_0036__WAS_R_0070_0037__THOUGHT)
      & has_arg0(R_0070_0016__THAT_R_0070_0036__WAS_R_0070_0037__THOUGHT,Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_98)
      & has_arg1(R_0070_0016__THAT_R_0070_0036__WAS_R_0070_0037__THOUGHT,R_0070_0038__THAT_R_0070_0044__MIGHT_R_0070_0045__HAVE_R_0070_0046__BEEN)
      & r_0070_0038__that_r_0070_0044__might_r_0070_0045__have_r_0070_0046__been(R_0070_0038__THAT_R_0070_0044__MIGHT_R_0070_0045__HAVE_R_0070_0046__BEEN)
      & has_prd(R_0070_0038__THAT_R_0070_0044__MIGHT_R_0070_0045__HAVE_R_0070_0046__BEEN,R_0070_0048__SMALL)
      & r_0070_0048__small(R_0070_0048__SMALL)
      & has_qual128(R_0070_0048__SMALL,R_0070_0047__TOO)
      & has_arg0(R_0070_0038__THAT_R_0070_0044__MIGHT_R_0070_0045__HAVE_R_0070_0046__BEEN,R_0070_0039__SOME)
      & r_0070_0039__some(R_0070_0039__SOME)
      & has_r_0070_0040__of(R_0070_0039__SOME,R_0070_0041__THE_R_0070_0042__SAMPLE_R_0070_0043__SIZES)
      & has_arg0(R_0070_0015__SHOWS,R_0070_0001__AN_R_0070_0002__ANALYSIS)
      & r_0070_0001__An_r_0070_0002__analysis(R_0070_0001__AN_R_0070_0002__ANALYSIS)
      & has_r_0070_0003__of(R_0070_0001__AN_R_0070_0002__ANALYSIS,R_0070_0004__THE_R_0070_0006__BADGER_R_0070_0007__CULLING_R_0070_0008__EXPERIMENTS)
      & r_0070_0004__the_r_0070_0006__badger_r_0070_0007__culling_r_0070_0008__experiments(R_0070_0004__THE_R_0070_0006__BADGER_R_0070_0007__CULLING_R_0070_0008__EXPERIMENTS)
      & has_attrib13(R_0070_0004__THE_R_0070_0006__BADGER_R_0070_0007__CULLING_R_0070_0008__EXPERIMENTS,R_0070_0005__ORIGINAL)
      & r_0070_0010__published(R_0070_0010__PUBLISHED)
      & has_arg0(R_0070_0010__PUBLISHED,Z_000_70_A_HEDGEHOG_25)
      & has_r_0070_0011__in_nim32(R_0070_0010__PUBLISHED,R_0070_0012__APRIL_R_0070_0013__2014)
      & has_arg1(R_0070_0010__PUBLISHED,R_0070_0004__THE_R_0070_0006__BADGER_R_0070_0007__CULLING_R_0070_0008__EXPERIMENTS) ) ).

( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ (D An;{an})
                  (N analysis;{analysis})
                  (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                      (NP (D the;{the})
                          (ADJP (ADJ original;{original}))
                          (N badger;{badger})
                          (N culling;{culling})
                          (NS experiments;{experiment})
                          (PUNC ,)
                          (IP-PPL (NP-LGS *)
                                  (VVN;_Tn_ published;{publish})
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                          (NP (NPR April;{April})
                                              (NPR 2014)))))))
          (PUNC ,)
          (VBP;_Tf_ shows;{show})
          (CP-THT-OB1 (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                              (PP-SCON (P-CONN while;{while})
                                       (IP-ADV (PP-NIM (P-ROLE at;{at})
                                                       (NP (D some;{some})
                                                           (NS sites;{site})))
                                               (NP-SBJ (N hedgehog;{hedgehog})
                                                       (NS numbers;{number}))
                                               (DOD did;{do})
                                               (VB;_I_ increase;{increase})
                                               (PUNC ,)
                                               (PP-NIM (P-ROLE following;{following})
                                                       (NP (D a;{a})
                                                           (N reduction;{reduction})
                                                           (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                               (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                   (N number;{number})
                                                                   (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                       (NP (NS badgers;{badger})))))))))
                              (PUNC ,)
                              (NP-SBJ (PRO;_provisional_ it;{it}))
                              (BED;_cat_VePASS_ was;{be})
                              (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                          (VVN;_Tf_ thought;{think})
                                          (CP-THT-NSBJ (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                                                               (NP-SBJ (D;_nphd_ some;{some})
                                                                       (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                                           (NP (D the;{the})
                                                                               (N sample;{sample})
                                                                               (NS sizes;{size}))))
                                                               (MD;_cat_Vi_ might;{may})
                                                               (IP-INF-CAT (HV;_cat_Ve_ have;{have})
                                                                           (IP-PPL-CAT (BEN;_La_ been;{be})
                                                                                       (ADJP-PRD (ADVP (ADV too;{too}))
                                                                                                 (ADJ small;{small})))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 70_a_hedgehog;speaker=Colvile))