Context                Previous, Next                Top


15_a_history_of_qed
CTSS was used at Bell Labs as part of our participation in the Multics project, and as Ken began to use Multics, he wrote yet another version of QED for that system.

%3 r_0015_0002__was was r_0015_0003__used used r_0015_0002__was->r_0015_0003__used [scope] r_0015_0001__CTSS CTSS r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0001__CTSS [arg1] r_0015_0005__Bell_r_0015_0006__Labs Bell Labs r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0005__Bell_r_0015_0006__Labs at [nim] r_0015_0008__part part r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0008__part [prd] z_000_15_a_history_of_qed_10 r_0015_0003__used->z_000_15_a_history_of_qed_10 [arg0] r_0015_0011__participation participation r_0015_0008__part->r_0015_0011__participation of r_0015_0010__our our r_0015_0011__participation->r_0015_0010__our [gen] r_0015_0013__the_r_0015_0014__Multics_r_0015_0015__project the Multics project r_0015_0011__participation->r_0015_0013__the_r_0015_0014__Multics_r_0015_0015__project in r_0015_0017__and and r_0015_0017__and->r_0015_0002__was [conj1] r_0015_0018__as as r_0015_0017__and->r_0015_0018__as [conj2] r_0015_0020__began began r_0015_0018__as->r_0015_0020__began [restriction] r_0015_0026__wrote wrote r_0015_0018__as->r_0015_0026__wrote [scope] r_0015_0019__Ken Ken r_0015_0020__began->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use to use r_0015_0020__began->r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use [arg1] r_0015_0026__wrote->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version another version r_0015_0026__wrote->r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version [arg1] r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0023__Multics Multics r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use->r_0015_0023__Multics [arg1] r_0015_0027__yet yet r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0027__yet [qual] r_0015_0031__QED QED r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0031__QED of r_0015_0033__that_r_0015_0034__system that system r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0033__that_r_0015_0034__system for 
arc(r_0015_0002__was, r_0015_0003__used, scope).
arc(r_0015_0003__used, r_0015_0001__CTSS, arg1).
arc(r_0015_0003__used, r_0015_0005__Bell_r_0015_0006__Labs, r_0015_0004__at_nim17).
arc(r_0015_0003__used, r_0015_0008__part, prd).
arc(r_0015_0003__used, z_000_15_a_history_of_qed_10, arg0).
arc(r_0015_0008__part, r_0015_0011__participation, r_0015_0009__of).
arc(r_0015_0011__participation, r_0015_0010__our, gen).
arc(r_0015_0011__participation, r_0015_0013__the_r_0015_0014__Multics_r_0015_0015__project, r_0015_0012__in).
arc(r_0015_0017__and, r_0015_0002__was, conj1).
arc(r_0015_0017__and, r_0015_0018__as, conj2).
arc(r_0015_0018__as, r_0015_0020__began, restriction).
arc(r_0015_0018__as, r_0015_0026__wrote, scope).
arc(r_0015_0020__began, r_0015_0019__Ken, arg0).
arc(r_0015_0020__began, r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use, arg1).
arc(r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use, r_0015_0019__Ken, arg0).
arc(r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use, r_0015_0023__Multics, arg1).
arc(r_0015_0026__wrote, r_0015_0019__Ken, arg0).
arc(r_0015_0026__wrote, r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version, arg1).
arc(r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version, r_0015_0027__yet, qual78).
arc(r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version, r_0015_0031__QED, r_0015_0030__of).
arc(r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version, r_0015_0033__that_r_0015_0034__system, r_0015_0032__for).


%3 r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used was used r_0015_0001__CTSS CTSS r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0001__CTSS [arg1] r_0015_0005__Bell_r_0015_0006__Labs Bell Labs r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0005__Bell_r_0015_0006__Labs at [nim] r_0015_0008__part part r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used->r_0015_0008__part [prd] z_000_15_a_history_of_qed_10 r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used->z_000_15_a_history_of_qed_10 [arg0] r_0015_0011__participation participation r_0015_0008__part->r_0015_0011__participation of r_0015_0010__our our r_0015_0011__participation->r_0015_0010__our [gen] r_0015_0013__the_r_0015_0014__Multics_r_0015_0015__project the Multics project r_0015_0011__participation->r_0015_0013__the_r_0015_0014__Multics_r_0015_0015__project in r_0015_0017__and and r_0015_0017__and->r_0015_0002__was_r_0015_0003__used [conj1] r_0015_0018__as as r_0015_0017__and->r_0015_0018__as [conj2] r_0015_0020__began began r_0015_0018__as->r_0015_0020__began [conj1] r_0015_0026__wrote wrote r_0015_0018__as->r_0015_0026__wrote [conj2] r_0015_0019__Ken Ken r_0015_0020__began->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use to use r_0015_0020__began->r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use [arg1] r_0015_0026__wrote->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version another version r_0015_0026__wrote->r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version [arg1] r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use->r_0015_0019__Ken [arg0] r_0015_0023__Multics Multics r_0015_0021__to_r_0015_0022__use->r_0015_0023__Multics [arg1] r_0015_0027__yet yet r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0027__yet [qual] r_0015_0031__QED QED r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0031__QED of r_0015_0033__that_r_0015_0034__system that system r_0015_0028__another_r_0015_0029__version->r_0015_0033__that_r_0015_0034__system for 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_15_17_AND,R_15_2_WAS_USED,Z_15_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_10,R_15_1_CTSS,R_15_8_PART,R_15_11_PARTICIPATION,R_15_10_OUR,R_15_13_THE_MULTICS_PROJECT,R_15_5_BELL_LABS,R_15_18_AS,R_15_20_BEGAN,R_15_21_TO_USE,R_15_23_MULTICS,R_15_26_WROTE,R_15_19_KEN,R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION,R_15_27_YET,R_15_31_QED,R_15_33_THAT_SYSTEM] :
      ( cTSS(R_15_1_CTSS)
      & our(R_15_10_OUR)
      & the_Multics_project(R_15_13_THE_MULTICS_PROJECT)
      & bell_Labs(R_15_5_BELL_LABS)
      & multics(R_15_23_MULTICS)
      & ken(R_15_19_KEN)
      & yet(R_15_27_YET)
      & qED(R_15_31_QED)
      & that_system(R_15_33_THAT_SYSTEM)
      & and(R_15_17_AND)
      & conj1(R_15_17_AND,R_15_2_WAS_USED)
      & was_used(R_15_2_WAS_USED,Z_15_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_10,R_15_1_CTSS,R_15_8_PART)
      & part(R_15_8_PART)
      & of(R_15_8_PART,R_15_11_PARTICIPATION)
      & participation(R_15_11_PARTICIPATION)
      & gen(R_15_11_PARTICIPATION,R_15_10_OUR)
      & in(R_15_11_PARTICIPATION,R_15_13_THE_MULTICS_PROJECT)
      & at_nim17(R_15_2_WAS_USED,R_15_5_BELL_LABS)
      & conj2(R_15_17_AND,R_15_18_AS)
      & as(R_15_18_AS)
      & conj1(R_15_18_AS,R_15_20_BEGAN)
      & began(R_15_20_BEGAN,R_15_19_KEN,R_15_21_TO_USE)
      & to_use(R_15_21_TO_USE,R_15_19_KEN,R_15_23_MULTICS)
      & conj2(R_15_18_AS,R_15_26_WROTE)
      & wrote(R_15_26_WROTE,R_15_19_KEN,R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION)
      & another_version(R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION)
      & qual78(R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION,R_15_27_YET)
      & of(R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION,R_15_31_QED)
      & for(R_15_28_ANOTHER_VERSION,R_15_33_THAT_SYSTEM) ) ).


n15_a_history_of_qed n15_a_history_of_qed_6 CTSS n15_a_history_of_qed_8 was n15_a_history_of_qed_11 * n15_a_history_of_qed_13 used n15_a_history_of_qed_16 at n15_a_history_of_qed_19 Bell n15_a_history_of_qed_21 Labs n15_a_history_of_qed_24 as n15_a_history_of_qed_27 part n15_a_history_of_qed_30 of n15_a_history_of_qed_34 our n15_a_history_of_qed_36 participation n15_a_history_of_qed_39 in n15_a_history_of_qed_42 the n15_a_history_of_qed_44 Multics n15_a_history_of_qed_46 project n15_a_history_of_qed_48 , n15_a_history_of_qed_51 and n15_a_history_of_qed_55 as n15_a_history_of_qed_59 Ken n15_a_history_of_qed_61 began n15_a_history_of_qed_64 to n15_a_history_of_qed_66 use n15_a_history_of_qed_69 Multics n15_a_history_of_qed_71 , n15_a_history_of_qed_74 he n15_a_history_of_qed_76 wrote n15_a_history_of_qed_80 yet n15_a_history_of_qed_82 another n15_a_history_of_qed_84 version n15_a_history_of_qed_87 of n15_a_history_of_qed_90 QED n15_a_history_of_qed_93 for n15_a_history_of_qed_96 that n15_a_history_of_qed_98 system n15_a_history_of_qed_100 . n15_a_history_of_qed_1 IP-MAT n15_a_history_of_qed_2 ILYR n15_a_history_of_qed_1->n15_a_history_of_qed_2 n15_a_history_of_qed_99 PUNC n15_a_history_of_qed_1->n15_a_history_of_qed_99 n15_a_history_of_qed_3 ILYR n15_a_history_of_qed_2->n15_a_history_of_qed_3 n15_a_history_of_qed_47 PUNC n15_a_history_of_qed_2->n15_a_history_of_qed_47 n15_a_history_of_qed_49 CONJP n15_a_history_of_qed_2->n15_a_history_of_qed_49 n15_a_history_of_qed_4 NP-SBJ n15_a_history_of_qed_3->n15_a_history_of_qed_4 n15_a_history_of_qed_7 BED;_cat_VePASS_ n15_a_history_of_qed_3->n15_a_history_of_qed_7 n15_a_history_of_qed_9 IP-PPL-CAT n15_a_history_of_qed_3->n15_a_history_of_qed_9 n15_a_history_of_qed_5 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_4->n15_a_history_of_qed_5 n15_a_history_of_qed_5->n15_a_history_of_qed_6 n15_a_history_of_qed_7->n15_a_history_of_qed_8 n15_a_history_of_qed_10 NP-LGS n15_a_history_of_qed_9->n15_a_history_of_qed_10 n15_a_history_of_qed_12 VVN;_Cn.n/a_ n15_a_history_of_qed_9->n15_a_history_of_qed_12 n15_a_history_of_qed_14 PP-NIM n15_a_history_of_qed_9->n15_a_history_of_qed_14 n15_a_history_of_qed_22 PP-PRD n15_a_history_of_qed_9->n15_a_history_of_qed_22 n15_a_history_of_qed_10->n15_a_history_of_qed_11 n15_a_history_of_qed_12->n15_a_history_of_qed_13 n15_a_history_of_qed_15 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_14->n15_a_history_of_qed_15 n15_a_history_of_qed_17 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_14->n15_a_history_of_qed_17 n15_a_history_of_qed_15->n15_a_history_of_qed_16 n15_a_history_of_qed_18 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_17->n15_a_history_of_qed_18 n15_a_history_of_qed_20 NPRS n15_a_history_of_qed_17->n15_a_history_of_qed_20 n15_a_history_of_qed_18->n15_a_history_of_qed_19 n15_a_history_of_qed_20->n15_a_history_of_qed_21 n15_a_history_of_qed_23 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_22->n15_a_history_of_qed_23 n15_a_history_of_qed_25 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_22->n15_a_history_of_qed_25 n15_a_history_of_qed_23->n15_a_history_of_qed_24 n15_a_history_of_qed_26 N n15_a_history_of_qed_25->n15_a_history_of_qed_26 n15_a_history_of_qed_28 PP n15_a_history_of_qed_25->n15_a_history_of_qed_28 n15_a_history_of_qed_26->n15_a_history_of_qed_27 n15_a_history_of_qed_29 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_28->n15_a_history_of_qed_29 n15_a_history_of_qed_31 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_28->n15_a_history_of_qed_31 n15_a_history_of_qed_29->n15_a_history_of_qed_30 n15_a_history_of_qed_32 NP-GEN n15_a_history_of_qed_31->n15_a_history_of_qed_32 n15_a_history_of_qed_35 N n15_a_history_of_qed_31->n15_a_history_of_qed_35 n15_a_history_of_qed_37 PP n15_a_history_of_qed_31->n15_a_history_of_qed_37 n15_a_history_of_qed_33 PRO;_genm_ n15_a_history_of_qed_32->n15_a_history_of_qed_33 n15_a_history_of_qed_33->n15_a_history_of_qed_34 n15_a_history_of_qed_35->n15_a_history_of_qed_36 n15_a_history_of_qed_38 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_37->n15_a_history_of_qed_38 n15_a_history_of_qed_40 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_37->n15_a_history_of_qed_40 n15_a_history_of_qed_38->n15_a_history_of_qed_39 n15_a_history_of_qed_41 D n15_a_history_of_qed_40->n15_a_history_of_qed_41 n15_a_history_of_qed_43 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_40->n15_a_history_of_qed_43 n15_a_history_of_qed_45 N n15_a_history_of_qed_40->n15_a_history_of_qed_45 n15_a_history_of_qed_41->n15_a_history_of_qed_42 n15_a_history_of_qed_43->n15_a_history_of_qed_44 n15_a_history_of_qed_45->n15_a_history_of_qed_46 n15_a_history_of_qed_47->n15_a_history_of_qed_48 n15_a_history_of_qed_50 CONJ n15_a_history_of_qed_49->n15_a_history_of_qed_50 n15_a_history_of_qed_52 ILYR n15_a_history_of_qed_49->n15_a_history_of_qed_52 n15_a_history_of_qed_50->n15_a_history_of_qed_51 n15_a_history_of_qed_53 PP-SCON n15_a_history_of_qed_52->n15_a_history_of_qed_53 n15_a_history_of_qed_70 PUNC n15_a_history_of_qed_52->n15_a_history_of_qed_70 n15_a_history_of_qed_72 NP-SBJ n15_a_history_of_qed_52->n15_a_history_of_qed_72 n15_a_history_of_qed_75 VBD;__ n15_a_history_of_qed_52->n15_a_history_of_qed_75 n15_a_history_of_qed_77 NP-OB1 n15_a_history_of_qed_52->n15_a_history_of_qed_77 n15_a_history_of_qed_54 P-CONN n15_a_history_of_qed_53->n15_a_history_of_qed_54 n15_a_history_of_qed_56 IP-ADV n15_a_history_of_qed_53->n15_a_history_of_qed_56 n15_a_history_of_qed_54->n15_a_history_of_qed_55 n15_a_history_of_qed_57 NP-SBJ n15_a_history_of_qed_56->n15_a_history_of_qed_57 n15_a_history_of_qed_60 VBD;__ n15_a_history_of_qed_56->n15_a_history_of_qed_60 n15_a_history_of_qed_62 IP-INF-OB1 n15_a_history_of_qed_56->n15_a_history_of_qed_62 n15_a_history_of_qed_58 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_57->n15_a_history_of_qed_58 n15_a_history_of_qed_58->n15_a_history_of_qed_59 n15_a_history_of_qed_60->n15_a_history_of_qed_61 n15_a_history_of_qed_63 TO n15_a_history_of_qed_62->n15_a_history_of_qed_63 n15_a_history_of_qed_65 VB;__ n15_a_history_of_qed_62->n15_a_history_of_qed_65 n15_a_history_of_qed_67 NP-OB1 n15_a_history_of_qed_62->n15_a_history_of_qed_67 n15_a_history_of_qed_63->n15_a_history_of_qed_64 n15_a_history_of_qed_65->n15_a_history_of_qed_66 n15_a_history_of_qed_68 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_67->n15_a_history_of_qed_68 n15_a_history_of_qed_68->n15_a_history_of_qed_69 n15_a_history_of_qed_70->n15_a_history_of_qed_71 n15_a_history_of_qed_73 PRO n15_a_history_of_qed_72->n15_a_history_of_qed_73 n15_a_history_of_qed_73->n15_a_history_of_qed_74 n15_a_history_of_qed_75->n15_a_history_of_qed_76 n15_a_history_of_qed_78 ADVP n15_a_history_of_qed_77->n15_a_history_of_qed_78 n15_a_history_of_qed_81 D n15_a_history_of_qed_77->n15_a_history_of_qed_81 n15_a_history_of_qed_83 N n15_a_history_of_qed_77->n15_a_history_of_qed_83 n15_a_history_of_qed_85 PP n15_a_history_of_qed_77->n15_a_history_of_qed_85 n15_a_history_of_qed_91 PP n15_a_history_of_qed_77->n15_a_history_of_qed_91 n15_a_history_of_qed_79 ADV n15_a_history_of_qed_78->n15_a_history_of_qed_79 n15_a_history_of_qed_79->n15_a_history_of_qed_80 n15_a_history_of_qed_81->n15_a_history_of_qed_82 n15_a_history_of_qed_83->n15_a_history_of_qed_84 n15_a_history_of_qed_86 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_85->n15_a_history_of_qed_86 n15_a_history_of_qed_88 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_85->n15_a_history_of_qed_88 n15_a_history_of_qed_86->n15_a_history_of_qed_87 n15_a_history_of_qed_89 NPR n15_a_history_of_qed_88->n15_a_history_of_qed_89 n15_a_history_of_qed_89->n15_a_history_of_qed_90 n15_a_history_of_qed_92 P-ROLE n15_a_history_of_qed_91->n15_a_history_of_qed_92 n15_a_history_of_qed_94 NP n15_a_history_of_qed_91->n15_a_history_of_qed_94 n15_a_history_of_qed_92->n15_a_history_of_qed_93 n15_a_history_of_qed_95 D n15_a_history_of_qed_94->n15_a_history_of_qed_95 n15_a_history_of_qed_97 N n15_a_history_of_qed_94->n15_a_history_of_qed_97 n15_a_history_of_qed_95->n15_a_history_of_qed_96 n15_a_history_of_qed_97->n15_a_history_of_qed_98 n15_a_history_of_qed_99->n15_a_history_of_qed_100 
( (IP-MAT (ILYR (ILYR (NP-SBJ (NPR CTSS;{CTSS}))
                      (BED;_cat_VePASS_ was;{be})
                      (IP-PPL-CAT (NP-LGS *)
                                  (VVN;_Cn.n/a_ used;{use[as]})
                                  (PP-NIM (P-ROLE at;{at})
                                          (NP;{BELL_LABS} (NPR Bell;{Bell})
                                                          (NPRS Labs;{Labs})))
                                  (PP-PRD (P-ROLE as;{as})
                                          (NP (N part;{part})
                                              (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                  (NP (NP-GEN;{BELL_LABS} (PRO;_genm_ our;{our}))
                                                      (N participation;{participation})
                                                      (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                          (NP (D the;{the})
                                                              (NPR Multics;{Multics})
                                                              (N project;{project})))))))))
                (PUNC ,)
                (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                       (ILYR (PP-SCON (P-CONN as;{as})
                                      (IP-ADV (NP-SBJ;{KEN} (NPR Ken;{Ken}))
                                              (VBD;__ began;{begin})
                                              (IP-INF-OB1 (TO to;{to})
                                                          (VB;__ use;{use})
                                                          (NP-OB1;{MULTICS} (NPR Multics;{Multics})))))
                             (PUNC ,)
                             (NP-SBJ;{KEN} (PRO he;{he}))
                             (VBD;__ wrote;{write})
                             (NP-OB1;{MULTICS_QED} (ADVP (ADV yet;{yet}))
                                                   (D another;{another})
                                                   (N version;{version})
                                                   (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                       (NP (NPR QED;{QED})))
                                                   (PP (P-ROLE for;{for})
                                                       (NP;{MULTICS} (D that;{that})
                                                                     (N system;{system})))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 15_a_history_of_qed))