Context                Previous, Next                Top


25_a_history_of_qed
This QED was probably the most baroque and complicated of all its manifestations, particularly in pushing “regular expressions” well beyond what Kleene thought they should do.

%3 r_0025_0003__was was r_0025_0001__This_r_0025_0002__QED This QED r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0001__This_r_0025_0002__QED [arg0] r_0025_0004__probably probably r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0004__probably [nim] r_0025_0005__the the r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0005__the [prd] r_0025_0015__particularly particularly r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0015__particularly [nim] r_0025_0017__pushing pushing r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0017__pushing in [nim] r_0025_0008__and and r_0025_0005__the->r_0025_0008__and [attrib] r_0025_0013__manifestations manifestations r_0025_0005__the->r_0025_0013__manifestations of r_0025_0020__expressions expressions r_0025_0017__pushing->r_0025_0020__expressions [arg1] r_0025_0022__well well r_0025_0017__pushing->r_0025_0022__well [nim] z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_48 r_0025_0017__pushing->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_48 [arg0] z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 r_0025_0017__pushing->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 beyond [nim] r_0025_0006__most most r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0006__most [qual] r_0025_0007__baroque baroque r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0007__baroque [conj1] r_0025_0009__complicated complicated r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0009__complicated [conj2] r_0025_0012__its its r_0025_0013__manifestations->r_0025_0012__its [gen] r_0025_0011__all_quant all [quant] r_0025_0011__all_quant->r_0025_0005__the [scope] r_0025_0011__all_quant->r_0025_0013__manifestations [restriction] r_0025_0019__regular regular r_0025_0020__expressions->r_0025_0019__regular [attrib] r_0025_0026__thought thought r_0025_0025__Kleene Kleene r_0025_0026__thought->r_0025_0025__Kleene [arg0] r_0025_0028__should should r_0025_0026__thought->r_0025_0028__should [arg1] r_0025_0029__do do r_0025_0028__should->r_0025_0029__do [scope] r_0025_0029__do->r_0025_0020__expressions [arg0] r_0025_0029__do->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 [arg1] 
arc(r_0025_0003__was, r_0025_0001__This_r_0025_0002__QED, arg0).
arc(r_0025_0003__was, r_0025_0004__probably, nim9).
arc(r_0025_0003__was, r_0025_0005__the, prd).
arc(r_0025_0003__was, r_0025_0015__particularly, nim42).
arc(r_0025_0003__was, r_0025_0017__pushing, r_0025_0016__in_nim48).
arc(r_0025_0005__the, r_0025_0008__and, attrib15).
arc(r_0025_0005__the, r_0025_0013__manifestations, r_0025_0010__of).
arc(r_0025_0008__and, r_0025_0006__most, qual16).
arc(r_0025_0008__and, r_0025_0007__baroque, conj1).
arc(r_0025_0008__and, r_0025_0009__complicated, conj2).
arc(r_0025_0011__all_quant, r_0025_0005__the, scope).
arc(r_0025_0011__all_quant, r_0025_0013__manifestations, restriction).
arc(r_0025_0013__manifestations, r_0025_0012__its, gen).
arc(r_0025_0017__pushing, r_0025_0020__expressions, arg1).
arc(r_0025_0017__pushing, r_0025_0022__well, nim61).
arc(r_0025_0017__pushing, z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_48, arg0).
arc(r_0025_0017__pushing, z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67, r_0025_0023__beyond_nim67).
arc(r_0025_0020__expressions, r_0025_0019__regular, attrib54).
arc(r_0025_0026__thought, r_0025_0025__Kleene, arg0).
arc(r_0025_0026__thought, r_0025_0028__should, arg1).
arc(r_0025_0028__should, r_0025_0029__do, scope).
arc(r_0025_0029__do, r_0025_0020__expressions, arg0).
arc(r_0025_0029__do, z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67, arg1).


%3 r_0025_0003__was was r_0025_0001__This_r_0025_0002__QED This QED r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0001__This_r_0025_0002__QED [arg0] r_0025_0004__probably probably r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0004__probably [nim] r_0025_0005__the the r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0005__the [prd] r_0025_0015__particularly particularly r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0015__particularly [nim] r_0025_0017__pushing pushing r_0025_0003__was->r_0025_0017__pushing in [nim] r_0025_0008__and and r_0025_0005__the->r_0025_0008__and [attrib] r_0025_0013__manifestations manifestations r_0025_0005__the->r_0025_0013__manifestations of r_0025_0020__expressions expressions r_0025_0017__pushing->r_0025_0020__expressions [arg1] r_0025_0022__well well r_0025_0017__pushing->r_0025_0022__well [nim] z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_48 r_0025_0017__pushing->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_48 [arg0] z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 r_0025_0017__pushing->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 beyond [nim] r_0025_0006__most most r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0006__most [qual] r_0025_0007__baroque baroque r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0007__baroque [conj1] r_0025_0009__complicated complicated r_0025_0008__and->r_0025_0009__complicated [conj2] r_0025_0012__its its r_0025_0013__manifestations->r_0025_0012__its [gen] r_0025_0011__all_quant all [quant] r_0025_0011__all_quant->r_0025_0003__was [scope] r_0025_0011__all_quant->r_0025_0013__manifestations [restriction] r_0025_0019__regular regular r_0025_0020__expressions->r_0025_0019__regular [attrib] r_0025_0026__thought thought r_0025_0025__Kleene Kleene r_0025_0026__thought->r_0025_0025__Kleene [arg0] r_0025_0028__should_r_0025_0029__do should do r_0025_0026__thought->r_0025_0028__should_r_0025_0029__do [arg1] r_0025_0028__should_r_0025_0029__do->r_0025_0020__expressions [arg0] r_0025_0028__should_r_0025_0029__do->z_000_25_a_history_of_qed_67 [arg1] 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_25_26_THOUGHT,R_25_25_KLEENE,R_25_28_SHOULD_DO,R_25_20_EXPRESSIONS,R_25_19_REGULAR,Z_25_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_67] :
      ( kleene(R_25_25_KLEENE)
      & regular(R_25_19_REGULAR)
      & ! [R_25_13_MANIFESTATIONS,R_25_12_ITS] :
          ( ( its(R_25_12_ITS)
            & manifestations(R_25_13_MANIFESTATIONS)
            & gen(R_25_13_MANIFESTATIONS,R_25_12_ITS) )
         => ? [R_25_3_WAS,R_25_1_THIS_QED,R_25_15_PARTICULARLY,R_25_4_PROBABLY,R_25_5_THE,R_25_8_AND,R_25_7_BAROQUE,R_25_9_COMPLICATED,R_25_6_MOST,R_25_17_PUSHING,Z_25_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_48,R_25_22_WELL] :
              ( this_QED(R_25_1_THIS_QED)
              & particularly(R_25_15_PARTICULARLY)
              & probably(R_25_4_PROBABLY)
              & baroque(R_25_7_BAROQUE)
              & complicated(R_25_9_COMPLICATED)
              & most(R_25_6_MOST)
              & well(R_25_22_WELL)
              & was(R_25_3_WAS,R_25_1_THIS_QED,R_25_5_THE)
              & the(R_25_5_THE)
              & attrib15(R_25_5_THE,R_25_8_AND)
              & and(R_25_8_AND)
              & conj1(R_25_8_AND,R_25_7_BAROQUE)
              & conj2(R_25_8_AND,R_25_9_COMPLICATED)
              & qual16(R_25_8_AND,R_25_6_MOST)
              & of(R_25_5_THE,R_25_13_MANIFESTATIONS)
              & nim42(R_25_3_WAS,R_25_15_PARTICULARLY)
              & nim9(R_25_3_WAS,R_25_4_PROBABLY)
              & in_nim48(R_25_3_WAS,R_25_17_PUSHING)
              & pushing(R_25_17_PUSHING,Z_25_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_48,R_25_20_EXPRESSIONS)
              & nim61(R_25_17_PUSHING,R_25_22_WELL)
              & beyond_nim67(R_25_17_PUSHING,Z_25_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_67) ) )
      & thought(R_25_26_THOUGHT,R_25_25_KLEENE,R_25_28_SHOULD_DO)
      & should_do(R_25_28_SHOULD_DO,R_25_20_EXPRESSIONS,Z_25_A_HISTORY_OF_QED_67)
      & expressions(R_25_20_EXPRESSIONS)
      & attrib54(R_25_20_EXPRESSIONS,R_25_19_REGULAR) ) ).


n25_a_history_of_qed n25_a_history_of_qed_4 This n25_a_history_of_qed_6 QED n25_a_history_of_qed_8 was n25_a_history_of_qed_11 probably n25_a_history_of_qed_14 the n25_a_history_of_qed_18 most n25_a_history_of_qed_22 baroque n25_a_history_of_qed_25 and n25_a_history_of_qed_28 complicated n25_a_history_of_qed_31 of n25_a_history_of_qed_34 all n25_a_history_of_qed_37 its n25_a_history_of_qed_39 manifestations n25_a_history_of_qed_41 , n25_a_history_of_qed_44 particularly n25_a_history_of_qed_47 in n25_a_history_of_qed_50 pushing n25_a_history_of_qed_53 <ldquo> n25_a_history_of_qed_56 regular n25_a_history_of_qed_58 expressions n25_a_history_of_qed_60 <rdquo> n25_a_history_of_qed_63 well n25_a_history_of_qed_66 beyond n25_a_history_of_qed_71 what n25_a_history_of_qed_74 Kleene n25_a_history_of_qed_76 thought n25_a_history_of_qed_81 they n25_a_history_of_qed_83 should n25_a_history_of_qed_86 *ICH*-174 n25_a_history_of_qed_88 do n25_a_history_of_qed_90 . n25_a_history_of_qed_1 IP-MAT n25_a_history_of_qed_2 NP-SBJ n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_2 n25_a_history_of_qed_7 BED;_Ln_ n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_7 n25_a_history_of_qed_9 ADVP-NIM n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_9 n25_a_history_of_qed_12 NP-PRD n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_12 n25_a_history_of_qed_40 PUNC n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_40 n25_a_history_of_qed_42 ADVP-NIM n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_42 n25_a_history_of_qed_45 PP-NIM n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_45 n25_a_history_of_qed_89 PUNC n25_a_history_of_qed_1->n25_a_history_of_qed_89 n25_a_history_of_qed_3 D n25_a_history_of_qed_2->n25_a_history_of_qed_3 n25_a_history_of_qed_5 NPR n25_a_history_of_qed_2->n25_a_history_of_qed_5 n25_a_history_of_qed_3->n25_a_history_of_qed_4 n25_a_history_of_qed_5->n25_a_history_of_qed_6 n25_a_history_of_qed_7->n25_a_history_of_qed_8 n25_a_history_of_qed_10 ADV n25_a_history_of_qed_9->n25_a_history_of_qed_10 n25_a_history_of_qed_10->n25_a_history_of_qed_11 n25_a_history_of_qed_13 D n25_a_history_of_qed_12->n25_a_history_of_qed_13 n25_a_history_of_qed_15 ADJP n25_a_history_of_qed_12->n25_a_history_of_qed_15 n25_a_history_of_qed_29 PP n25_a_history_of_qed_12->n25_a_history_of_qed_29 n25_a_history_of_qed_13->n25_a_history_of_qed_14 n25_a_history_of_qed_16 ADVP n25_a_history_of_qed_15->n25_a_history_of_qed_16 n25_a_history_of_qed_19 AJLYR n25_a_history_of_qed_15->n25_a_history_of_qed_19 n25_a_history_of_qed_17 ADVS n25_a_history_of_qed_16->n25_a_history_of_qed_17 n25_a_history_of_qed_17->n25_a_history_of_qed_18 n25_a_history_of_qed_20 AJLYR n25_a_history_of_qed_19->n25_a_history_of_qed_20 n25_a_history_of_qed_23 CONJP n25_a_history_of_qed_19->n25_a_history_of_qed_23 n25_a_history_of_qed_21 ADJ n25_a_history_of_qed_20->n25_a_history_of_qed_21 n25_a_history_of_qed_21->n25_a_history_of_qed_22 n25_a_history_of_qed_24 CONJ n25_a_history_of_qed_23->n25_a_history_of_qed_24 n25_a_history_of_qed_26 AJLYR n25_a_history_of_qed_23->n25_a_history_of_qed_26 n25_a_history_of_qed_24->n25_a_history_of_qed_25 n25_a_history_of_qed_27 ADJ n25_a_history_of_qed_26->n25_a_history_of_qed_27 n25_a_history_of_qed_27->n25_a_history_of_qed_28 n25_a_history_of_qed_30 P-ROLE n25_a_history_of_qed_29->n25_a_history_of_qed_30 n25_a_history_of_qed_32 NP n25_a_history_of_qed_29->n25_a_history_of_qed_32 n25_a_history_of_qed_30->n25_a_history_of_qed_31 n25_a_history_of_qed_33 Q n25_a_history_of_qed_32->n25_a_history_of_qed_33 n25_a_history_of_qed_35 NP-GEN n25_a_history_of_qed_32->n25_a_history_of_qed_35 n25_a_history_of_qed_38 NS n25_a_history_of_qed_32->n25_a_history_of_qed_38 n25_a_history_of_qed_33->n25_a_history_of_qed_34 n25_a_history_of_qed_36 PRO;_genm_ n25_a_history_of_qed_35->n25_a_history_of_qed_36 n25_a_history_of_qed_36->n25_a_history_of_qed_37 n25_a_history_of_qed_38->n25_a_history_of_qed_39 n25_a_history_of_qed_40->n25_a_history_of_qed_41 n25_a_history_of_qed_43 ADV n25_a_history_of_qed_42->n25_a_history_of_qed_43 n25_a_history_of_qed_43->n25_a_history_of_qed_44 n25_a_history_of_qed_46 P-ROLE n25_a_history_of_qed_45->n25_a_history_of_qed_46 n25_a_history_of_qed_48 IP-PPL n25_a_history_of_qed_45->n25_a_history_of_qed_48 n25_a_history_of_qed_46->n25_a_history_of_qed_47 n25_a_history_of_qed_49 VAG;__ n25_a_history_of_qed_48->n25_a_history_of_qed_49 n25_a_history_of_qed_51 NP-OB1 n25_a_history_of_qed_48->n25_a_history_of_qed_51 n25_a_history_of_qed_61 ADVP-NIM n25_a_history_of_qed_48->n25_a_history_of_qed_61 n25_a_history_of_qed_64 PP-NIM n25_a_history_of_qed_48->n25_a_history_of_qed_64 n25_a_history_of_qed_49->n25_a_history_of_qed_50 n25_a_history_of_qed_52 PULQ n25_a_history_of_qed_51->n25_a_history_of_qed_52 n25_a_history_of_qed_54 ADJP n25_a_history_of_qed_51->n25_a_history_of_qed_54 n25_a_history_of_qed_57 NS n25_a_history_of_qed_51->n25_a_history_of_qed_57 n25_a_history_of_qed_59 PURQ n25_a_history_of_qed_51->n25_a_history_of_qed_59 n25_a_history_of_qed_52->n25_a_history_of_qed_53 n25_a_history_of_qed_55 ADJ n25_a_history_of_qed_54->n25_a_history_of_qed_55 n25_a_history_of_qed_55->n25_a_history_of_qed_56 n25_a_history_of_qed_57->n25_a_history_of_qed_58 n25_a_history_of_qed_59->n25_a_history_of_qed_60 n25_a_history_of_qed_62 ADV n25_a_history_of_qed_61->n25_a_history_of_qed_62 n25_a_history_of_qed_62->n25_a_history_of_qed_63 n25_a_history_of_qed_65 P-ROLE n25_a_history_of_qed_64->n25_a_history_of_qed_65 n25_a_history_of_qed_67 NP n25_a_history_of_qed_64->n25_a_history_of_qed_67 n25_a_history_of_qed_65->n25_a_history_of_qed_66 n25_a_history_of_qed_68 IP-REL n25_a_history_of_qed_67->n25_a_history_of_qed_68 n25_a_history_of_qed_69 NP-174 n25_a_history_of_qed_68->n25_a_history_of_qed_69 n25_a_history_of_qed_72 NP-SBJ n25_a_history_of_qed_68->n25_a_history_of_qed_72 n25_a_history_of_qed_75 VBD;__ n25_a_history_of_qed_68->n25_a_history_of_qed_75 n25_a_history_of_qed_77 CP-THT-OB1 n25_a_history_of_qed_68->n25_a_history_of_qed_77 n25_a_history_of_qed_70 RPRO n25_a_history_of_qed_69->n25_a_history_of_qed_70 n25_a_history_of_qed_70->n25_a_history_of_qed_71 n25_a_history_of_qed_73 NPR n25_a_history_of_qed_72->n25_a_history_of_qed_73 n25_a_history_of_qed_73->n25_a_history_of_qed_74 n25_a_history_of_qed_75->n25_a_history_of_qed_76 n25_a_history_of_qed_78 IP-SUB n25_a_history_of_qed_77->n25_a_history_of_qed_78 n25_a_history_of_qed_79 NP-SBJ n25_a_history_of_qed_78->n25_a_history_of_qed_79 n25_a_history_of_qed_82 MD;_cat_Vi_ n25_a_history_of_qed_78->n25_a_history_of_qed_82 n25_a_history_of_qed_84 IP-INF-CAT n25_a_history_of_qed_78->n25_a_history_of_qed_84 n25_a_history_of_qed_80 PRO n25_a_history_of_qed_79->n25_a_history_of_qed_80 n25_a_history_of_qed_80->n25_a_history_of_qed_81 n25_a_history_of_qed_82->n25_a_history_of_qed_83 n25_a_history_of_qed_85 NP-OB1 n25_a_history_of_qed_84->n25_a_history_of_qed_85 n25_a_history_of_qed_87 DO;_Tn_ n25_a_history_of_qed_84->n25_a_history_of_qed_87 n25_a_history_of_qed_85->n25_a_history_of_qed_86 n25_a_history_of_qed_87->n25_a_history_of_qed_88 n25_a_history_of_qed_89->n25_a_history_of_qed_90 
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ;{GECOS_QED} (D This;{this})
                              (NPR QED;{QED}))
          (BED;_Ln_ was;{be})
          (ADVP-NIM (ADV probably;{probably}))
          (NP-PRD (D the;{the})
                  (ADJP (ADVP (ADVS most;{most}))
                        (AJLYR (AJLYR (ADJ baroque;{baroque}))
                               (CONJP (CONJ and;{and})
                                      (AJLYR (ADJ complicated;{complicated})))))
                  (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                      (NP (Q all;{all})
                          (NP-GEN;{QED} (PRO;_genm_ its;{its}))
                          (NS manifestations;{manifestation}))))
          (PUNC ,)
          (ADVP-NIM (ADV particularly;{particularly}))
          (PP-NIM (P-ROLE in;{in})
                  (IP-PPL (VAG;__ pushing;{push})
                          (NP-OB1;{REGEX} (PULQ <ldquo>)
                                          (ADJP (ADJ regular;{regular}))
                                          (NS expressions;{expression})
                                          (PURQ <rdquo>))
                          (ADVP-NIM (ADV well;{well}))
                          (PP-NIM (P-ROLE beyond;{beyond})
                                  (NP (IP-REL (NP-174 (RPRO what;{what}))
                                              (NP-SBJ (NPR Kleene;{Kleene}))
                                              (VBD;__ thought;{think})
                                              (CP-THT-OB1 (IP-SUB (NP-SBJ;{REGEX} (PRO they;{they}))
                                                                  (MD;_cat_Vi_ should;{shall})
                                                                  (IP-INF-CAT (NP-OB1 *ICH*-174)
                                                                              (DO;_Tn_ do;{do})))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 25_a_history_of_qed))