Context                Previous, Next                Top


123_a_lob_a01
His basic defence of the health service cuts was that ‘even after the proposed changes the net cost of the service to the exchequer will have increased over three years by 20 per cent.

%3 r_0123_0003__defence defence r_0123_0001__His His r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0001__His [gen] r_0123_0002__basic basic r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0002__basic [attrib] r_0123_0005__the_r_0123_0006__health_r_0123_0007__service_r_0123_0008__cuts the health service cuts r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0005__the_r_0123_0006__health_r_0123_0007__service_r_0123_0008__cuts of r_0123_0009__was was r_0123_0009__was->r_0123_0003__defence [arg0] r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will that will r_0123_0009__was->r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will [prd] r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes the changes r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will->r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes even after [nim] r_0123_0027__have have r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will->r_0123_0027__have [scope] r_0123_0015__proposed proposed r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes->r_0123_0015__proposed [attrib] r_0123_0028__increased increased r_0123_0027__have->r_0123_0028__increased [scope] r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost the cost r_0123_0018__net net r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost->r_0123_0018__net [attrib] r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service the service r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost->r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service of r_0123_0024__the_r_0123_0025__exchequer the exchequer r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service->r_0123_0024__the_r_0123_0025__exchequer to r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost [arg0] r_0123_0030__three_r_0123_0031__years three years r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0030__three_r_0123_0031__years over [nim] r_0123_0033__20_r_0123_0034__per_cent 20 per cent r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0033__20_r_0123_0034__per_cent by [nim] 
arc(r_0123_0003__defence, r_0123_0001__His, gen).
arc(r_0123_0003__defence, r_0123_0002__basic, attrib6).
arc(r_0123_0003__defence, r_0123_0005__the_r_0123_0006__health_r_0123_0007__service_r_0123_0008__cuts, r_0123_0004__of).
arc(r_0123_0009__was, r_0123_0003__defence, arg0).
arc(r_0123_0009__was, r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will, prd).
arc(r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will, r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes, r_0123_0012__even_r_0123_0013__after_nim36).
arc(r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will, r_0123_0027__have, scope).
arc(r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes, r_0123_0015__proposed, attrib39).
arc(r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost, r_0123_0018__net, attrib47).
arc(r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost, r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service, r_0123_0020__of).
arc(r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service, r_0123_0024__the_r_0123_0025__exchequer, r_0123_0023__to).
arc(r_0123_0027__have, r_0123_0028__increased, scope).
arc(r_0123_0028__increased, r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost, arg0).
arc(r_0123_0028__increased, r_0123_0030__three_r_0123_0031__years, r_0123_0029__over_nim79).
arc(r_0123_0028__increased, r_0123_0033__20_r_0123_0034__per_cent, r_0123_0032__by_nim87).


%3 r_0123_0003__defence defence r_0123_0001__His His r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0001__His [gen] r_0123_0002__basic basic r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0002__basic [attrib] r_0123_0005__the_r_0123_0006__health_r_0123_0007__service_r_0123_0008__cuts the health service cuts r_0123_0003__defence->r_0123_0005__the_r_0123_0006__health_r_0123_0007__service_r_0123_0008__cuts of r_0123_0009__was was r_0123_0009__was->r_0123_0003__defence [arg0] r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased that will have increased r_0123_0009__was->r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased [prd] r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes the changes r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes even after [nim] r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost the cost r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost [arg0] r_0123_0030__three_r_0123_0031__years three years r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0030__three_r_0123_0031__years over [nim] r_0123_0033__20_r_0123_0034__per_cent 20 per cent r_0123_0010__that_r_0123_0026__will_r_0123_0027__have_r_0123_0028__increased->r_0123_0033__20_r_0123_0034__per_cent by [nim] r_0123_0015__proposed proposed r_0123_0014__the_r_0123_0016__changes->r_0123_0015__proposed [attrib] r_0123_0018__net net r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost->r_0123_0018__net [attrib] r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service the service r_0123_0017__the_r_0123_0019__cost->r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service of r_0123_0024__the_r_0123_0025__exchequer the exchequer r_0123_0021__the_r_0123_0022__service->r_0123_0024__the_r_0123_0025__exchequer to 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_123_9_WAS,R_123_3_DEFENCE,R_123_2_BASIC,R_123_1_HIS,R_123_5_THE_HEALTH_SERVICE_CUTS,R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED,R_123_17_THE_COST,R_123_18_NET,R_123_21_THE_SERVICE,R_123_24_THE_EXCHEQUER,R_123_14_THE_CHANGES,R_123_15_PROPOSED,R_123_30_THREE_YEARS,R_123_33_20_PER_CENT] :
      ( basic(R_123_2_BASIC)
      & his(R_123_1_HIS)
      & the_health_service_cuts(R_123_5_THE_HEALTH_SERVICE_CUTS)
      & net(R_123_18_NET)
      & the_exchequer(R_123_24_THE_EXCHEQUER)
      & proposed(R_123_15_PROPOSED)
      & three_years(R_123_30_THREE_YEARS)
      & 20_per_cent(R_123_33_20_PER_CENT)
      & was(R_123_9_WAS,R_123_3_DEFENCE,R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED)
      & defence(R_123_3_DEFENCE)
      & attrib6(R_123_3_DEFENCE,R_123_2_BASIC)
      & gen(R_123_3_DEFENCE,R_123_1_HIS)
      & of(R_123_3_DEFENCE,R_123_5_THE_HEALTH_SERVICE_CUTS)
      & that_will_have_increased(R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED,R_123_17_THE_COST)
      & the_cost(R_123_17_THE_COST)
      & attrib47(R_123_17_THE_COST,R_123_18_NET)
      & of(R_123_17_THE_COST,R_123_21_THE_SERVICE)
      & the_service(R_123_21_THE_SERVICE)
      & to(R_123_21_THE_SERVICE,R_123_24_THE_EXCHEQUER)
      & even_after_nim36(R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED,R_123_14_THE_CHANGES)
      & the_changes(R_123_14_THE_CHANGES)
      & attrib39(R_123_14_THE_CHANGES,R_123_15_PROPOSED)
      & over_nim79(R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED,R_123_30_THREE_YEARS)
      & by_nim87(R_123_10_THAT_WILL_HAVE_INCREASED,R_123_33_20_PER_CENT) ) ).


n123_a_lob_a01 n123_a_lob_a01_5 His n123_a_lob_a01_8 basic n123_a_lob_a01_10 defence n123_a_lob_a01_13 of n123_a_lob_a01_16 the n123_a_lob_a01_18 health n123_a_lob_a01_20 service n123_a_lob_a01_22 cuts n123_a_lob_a01_24 was n123_a_lob_a01_28 that n123_a_lob_a01_30 <lquo> n123_a_lob_a01_33 even n123_a_lob_a01_35 after n123_a_lob_a01_38 the n123_a_lob_a01_41 proposed n123_a_lob_a01_43 changes n123_a_lob_a01_46 the n123_a_lob_a01_49 net n123_a_lob_a01_51 cost n123_a_lob_a01_54 of n123_a_lob_a01_57 the n123_a_lob_a01_59 service n123_a_lob_a01_62 to n123_a_lob_a01_65 the n123_a_lob_a01_67 exchequer n123_a_lob_a01_69 will n123_a_lob_a01_72 have n123_a_lob_a01_75 increased n123_a_lob_a01_78 over n123_a_lob_a01_81 three n123_a_lob_a01_83 years n123_a_lob_a01_86 by n123_a_lob_a01_89 20 n123_a_lob_a01_91 per_cent n123_a_lob_a01_93 . n123_a_lob_a01_1 IP-MAT n123_a_lob_a01_2 NP-SBJ n123_a_lob_a01_1->n123_a_lob_a01_2 n123_a_lob_a01_23 BED;_equ_Vf_ n123_a_lob_a01_1->n123_a_lob_a01_23 n123_a_lob_a01_25 CP-THT-PRD n123_a_lob_a01_1->n123_a_lob_a01_25 n123_a_lob_a01_92 PUNC n123_a_lob_a01_1->n123_a_lob_a01_92 n123_a_lob_a01_3 NP-GEN n123_a_lob_a01_2->n123_a_lob_a01_3 n123_a_lob_a01_6 ADJP n123_a_lob_a01_2->n123_a_lob_a01_6 n123_a_lob_a01_9 N n123_a_lob_a01_2->n123_a_lob_a01_9 n123_a_lob_a01_11 PP n123_a_lob_a01_2->n123_a_lob_a01_11 n123_a_lob_a01_4 PRO;_genm_ n123_a_lob_a01_3->n123_a_lob_a01_4 n123_a_lob_a01_4->n123_a_lob_a01_5 n123_a_lob_a01_7 ADJ n123_a_lob_a01_6->n123_a_lob_a01_7 n123_a_lob_a01_7->n123_a_lob_a01_8 n123_a_lob_a01_9->n123_a_lob_a01_10 n123_a_lob_a01_12 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_11->n123_a_lob_a01_12 n123_a_lob_a01_14 NP n123_a_lob_a01_11->n123_a_lob_a01_14 n123_a_lob_a01_12->n123_a_lob_a01_13 n123_a_lob_a01_15 D n123_a_lob_a01_14->n123_a_lob_a01_15 n123_a_lob_a01_17 N n123_a_lob_a01_14->n123_a_lob_a01_17 n123_a_lob_a01_19 N n123_a_lob_a01_14->n123_a_lob_a01_19 n123_a_lob_a01_21 NS n123_a_lob_a01_14->n123_a_lob_a01_21 n123_a_lob_a01_15->n123_a_lob_a01_16 n123_a_lob_a01_17->n123_a_lob_a01_18 n123_a_lob_a01_19->n123_a_lob_a01_20 n123_a_lob_a01_21->n123_a_lob_a01_22 n123_a_lob_a01_23->n123_a_lob_a01_24 n123_a_lob_a01_26 IP-SUB n123_a_lob_a01_25->n123_a_lob_a01_26 n123_a_lob_a01_27 C n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_27 n123_a_lob_a01_29 PULQ n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_29 n123_a_lob_a01_31 PP-NIM n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_31 n123_a_lob_a01_44 NP-SBJ n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_44 n123_a_lob_a01_68 MD;_cat_Vi_ n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_68 n123_a_lob_a01_70 IP-INF-CAT n123_a_lob_a01_26->n123_a_lob_a01_70 n123_a_lob_a01_27->n123_a_lob_a01_28 n123_a_lob_a01_29->n123_a_lob_a01_30 n123_a_lob_a01_32 ADV n123_a_lob_a01_31->n123_a_lob_a01_32 n123_a_lob_a01_34 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_31->n123_a_lob_a01_34 n123_a_lob_a01_36 NP n123_a_lob_a01_31->n123_a_lob_a01_36 n123_a_lob_a01_32->n123_a_lob_a01_33 n123_a_lob_a01_34->n123_a_lob_a01_35 n123_a_lob_a01_37 D n123_a_lob_a01_36->n123_a_lob_a01_37 n123_a_lob_a01_39 ADJP n123_a_lob_a01_36->n123_a_lob_a01_39 n123_a_lob_a01_42 NS n123_a_lob_a01_36->n123_a_lob_a01_42 n123_a_lob_a01_37->n123_a_lob_a01_38 n123_a_lob_a01_40 ADJ n123_a_lob_a01_39->n123_a_lob_a01_40 n123_a_lob_a01_40->n123_a_lob_a01_41 n123_a_lob_a01_42->n123_a_lob_a01_43 n123_a_lob_a01_45 D n123_a_lob_a01_44->n123_a_lob_a01_45 n123_a_lob_a01_47 ADJP n123_a_lob_a01_44->n123_a_lob_a01_47 n123_a_lob_a01_50 N n123_a_lob_a01_44->n123_a_lob_a01_50 n123_a_lob_a01_52 PP n123_a_lob_a01_44->n123_a_lob_a01_52 n123_a_lob_a01_45->n123_a_lob_a01_46 n123_a_lob_a01_48 ADJ n123_a_lob_a01_47->n123_a_lob_a01_48 n123_a_lob_a01_48->n123_a_lob_a01_49 n123_a_lob_a01_50->n123_a_lob_a01_51 n123_a_lob_a01_53 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_52->n123_a_lob_a01_53 n123_a_lob_a01_55 NP n123_a_lob_a01_52->n123_a_lob_a01_55 n123_a_lob_a01_53->n123_a_lob_a01_54 n123_a_lob_a01_56 D n123_a_lob_a01_55->n123_a_lob_a01_56 n123_a_lob_a01_58 N n123_a_lob_a01_55->n123_a_lob_a01_58 n123_a_lob_a01_60 PP n123_a_lob_a01_55->n123_a_lob_a01_60 n123_a_lob_a01_56->n123_a_lob_a01_57 n123_a_lob_a01_58->n123_a_lob_a01_59 n123_a_lob_a01_61 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_60->n123_a_lob_a01_61 n123_a_lob_a01_63 NP n123_a_lob_a01_60->n123_a_lob_a01_63 n123_a_lob_a01_61->n123_a_lob_a01_62 n123_a_lob_a01_64 D n123_a_lob_a01_63->n123_a_lob_a01_64 n123_a_lob_a01_66 N n123_a_lob_a01_63->n123_a_lob_a01_66 n123_a_lob_a01_64->n123_a_lob_a01_65 n123_a_lob_a01_66->n123_a_lob_a01_67 n123_a_lob_a01_68->n123_a_lob_a01_69 n123_a_lob_a01_71 HV;_cat_Ve_ n123_a_lob_a01_70->n123_a_lob_a01_71 n123_a_lob_a01_73 IP-PPL-CAT n123_a_lob_a01_70->n123_a_lob_a01_73 n123_a_lob_a01_71->n123_a_lob_a01_72 n123_a_lob_a01_74 VVN;__ n123_a_lob_a01_73->n123_a_lob_a01_74 n123_a_lob_a01_76 PP-NIM n123_a_lob_a01_73->n123_a_lob_a01_76 n123_a_lob_a01_84 PP-NIM n123_a_lob_a01_73->n123_a_lob_a01_84 n123_a_lob_a01_74->n123_a_lob_a01_75 n123_a_lob_a01_77 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_76->n123_a_lob_a01_77 n123_a_lob_a01_79 NP n123_a_lob_a01_76->n123_a_lob_a01_79 n123_a_lob_a01_77->n123_a_lob_a01_78 n123_a_lob_a01_80 NUM n123_a_lob_a01_79->n123_a_lob_a01_80 n123_a_lob_a01_82 NS n123_a_lob_a01_79->n123_a_lob_a01_82 n123_a_lob_a01_80->n123_a_lob_a01_81 n123_a_lob_a01_82->n123_a_lob_a01_83 n123_a_lob_a01_85 P-ROLE n123_a_lob_a01_84->n123_a_lob_a01_85 n123_a_lob_a01_87 NP n123_a_lob_a01_84->n123_a_lob_a01_87 n123_a_lob_a01_85->n123_a_lob_a01_86 n123_a_lob_a01_88 NUM n123_a_lob_a01_87->n123_a_lob_a01_88 n123_a_lob_a01_90 N n123_a_lob_a01_87->n123_a_lob_a01_90 n123_a_lob_a01_88->n123_a_lob_a01_89 n123_a_lob_a01_90->n123_a_lob_a01_91 n123_a_lob_a01_92->n123_a_lob_a01_93 
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ (NP-GEN;{POWELL} (PRO;_genm_ His;{his}))
                  (ADJP (ADJ basic;{basic}))
                  (N defence;{defence})
                  (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                      (NP (D the;{the})
                          (N health;{health})
                          (N service;{service})
                          (NS cuts;{cut}))))
          (BED;_equ_Vf_ was;{be})
          (CP-THT-PRD (IP-SUB (C that;{that})
                              (PULQ <lquo>)
                              (PP-NIM (ADV even;{even})
                                      (P-ROLE after;{after})
                                      (NP (D the;{the})
                                          (ADJP (ADJ proposed;{proposed}))
                                          (NS changes;{change})))
                              (NP-SBJ (D the;{the})
                                      (ADJP (ADJ net;{net}))
                                      (N cost;{cost})
                                      (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                          (NP (D the;{the})
                                              (N service;{service})
                                              (PP (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                  (NP (D the;{the})
                                                      (N exchequer;{exchequer}))))))
                              (MD;_cat_Vi_ will;{will})
                              (IP-INF-CAT (HV;_cat_Ve_ have;{have})
                                          (IP-PPL-CAT (VVN;__ increased;{increase})
                                                      (PP-NIM (P-ROLE over;{over})
                                                              (NP (NUM three;{three})
                                                                  (NS years;{year})))
                                                      (PP-NIM (P-ROLE by;{by})
                                                              (NP (NUM 20)
                                                                  (N per_cent;{per_cent})))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 123_a_lob_a01))