Context                Previous, Next                Top


9_a_uksc_judgment
The first question, therefore, is whether the Prime Minister's action had the effect of frustrating or preventing the constitutional role of Parliament in holding the Government to account.

%3 r_0009_0007__is is r_0009_0001__The_r_0009_0002__first_r_0009_0003__question The first question r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0001__The_r_0009_0002__first_r_0009_0003__question [arg0] r_0009_0005__therefore therefore r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0005__therefore [nim] r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had whether had r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had [prd] r_0009_0013__action action r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had->r_0009_0013__action [arg0] r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect the effect r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had->r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect [arg1] r_0009_0009__the_r_0009_0010__Prime_r_0009_0011__Minister_r_0009_0012___apos_s the Prime Minister 's r_0009_0013__action->r_0009_0009__the_r_0009_0010__Prime_r_0009_0011__Minister_r_0009_0012___apos_s [gen] r_0009_0019__or or r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect->r_0009_0019__or of r_0009_0018__frustrating frustrating r_0009_0019__or->r_0009_0018__frustrating [conj1] r_0009_0020__preventing preventing r_0009_0019__or->r_0009_0020__preventing [conj2] r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role the role r_0009_0018__frustrating->r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role [arg1] z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 r_0009_0018__frustrating->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 [arg0] r_0009_0022__constitutional constitutional r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0022__constitutional [attrib] r_0009_0025__Parliament Parliament r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0025__Parliament of r_0009_0027__holding holding r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0027__holding in r_0009_0020__preventing->r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role [arg1] r_0009_0020__preventing->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 [arg0] r_0009_0028__the_r_0009_0029__Government the Government r_0009_0027__holding->r_0009_0028__the_r_0009_0029__Government [arg1] r_0009_0031__account account r_0009_0027__holding->r_0009_0031__account to [clr] z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_72 r_0009_0027__holding->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_72 [arg0] 
arc(r_0009_0007__is, r_0009_0001__The_r_0009_0002__first_r_0009_0003__question, arg0).
arc(r_0009_0007__is, r_0009_0005__therefore, nim11).
arc(r_0009_0007__is, r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had, prd).
arc(r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had, r_0009_0013__action, arg0).
arc(r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had, r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect, arg1).
arc(r_0009_0013__action, r_0009_0009__the_r_0009_0010__Prime_r_0009_0011__Minister_r_0009_0012___apos_s, gen).
arc(r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect, r_0009_0019__or, r_0009_0017__of).
arc(r_0009_0018__frustrating, r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role, arg1).
arc(r_0009_0018__frustrating, z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44, arg0).
arc(r_0009_0019__or, r_0009_0018__frustrating, conj1).
arc(r_0009_0019__or, r_0009_0020__preventing, conj2).
arc(r_0009_0020__preventing, r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role, arg1).
arc(r_0009_0020__preventing, z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44, arg0).
arc(r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role, r_0009_0022__constitutional, attrib58).
arc(r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role, r_0009_0025__Parliament, r_0009_0024__of).
arc(r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role, r_0009_0027__holding, r_0009_0026__in).
arc(r_0009_0027__holding, r_0009_0028__the_r_0009_0029__Government, arg1).
arc(r_0009_0027__holding, r_0009_0031__account, r_0009_0030__to_clr83).
arc(r_0009_0027__holding, z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_72, arg0).


%3 r_0009_0007__is is r_0009_0001__The_r_0009_0002__first_r_0009_0003__question The first question r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0001__The_r_0009_0002__first_r_0009_0003__question [arg0] r_0009_0005__therefore therefore r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0005__therefore [nim] r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had whether had r_0009_0007__is->r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had [prd] r_0009_0013__action action r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had->r_0009_0013__action [arg0] r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect the effect r_0009_0008__whether_r_0009_0014__had->r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect [arg1] r_0009_0009__the_r_0009_0010__Prime_r_0009_0011__Minister_r_0009_0012___apos_s the Prime Minister 's r_0009_0013__action->r_0009_0009__the_r_0009_0010__Prime_r_0009_0011__Minister_r_0009_0012___apos_s [gen] r_0009_0019__or or r_0009_0015__the_r_0009_0016__effect->r_0009_0019__or of r_0009_0018__frustrating frustrating r_0009_0019__or->r_0009_0018__frustrating [conj1] r_0009_0020__preventing preventing r_0009_0019__or->r_0009_0020__preventing [conj2] r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role the role r_0009_0018__frustrating->r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role [arg1] z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 r_0009_0018__frustrating->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 [arg0] r_0009_0022__constitutional constitutional r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0022__constitutional [attrib] r_0009_0025__Parliament Parliament r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0025__Parliament of r_0009_0027__holding holding r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role->r_0009_0027__holding in r_0009_0020__preventing->r_0009_0021__the_r_0009_0023__role [arg1] r_0009_0020__preventing->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_44 [arg0] r_0009_0028__the_r_0009_0029__Government the Government r_0009_0027__holding->r_0009_0028__the_r_0009_0029__Government [arg1] r_0009_0031__account account r_0009_0027__holding->r_0009_0031__account to [clr] z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_72 r_0009_0027__holding->z_000_9_a_uksc_judgment_72 [arg0] 
fof(formula,axiom,
    ? [R_9_7_IS,R_9_1_THE_FIRST_QUESTION,R_9_5_THEREFORE,R_9_8_WHETHER_HAD,R_9_13_ACTION,R_9_9_THE_PRIME_MINISTER_APOS_S,R_9_15_THE_EFFECT,R_9_19_OR,R_9_18_FRUSTRATING,R_9_20_PREVENTING,Z_9_A_UKSC_JUDGMENT_44,R_9_21_THE_ROLE,R_9_22_CONSTITUTIONAL,R_9_25_PARLIAMENT,R_9_27_HOLDING,Z_9_A_UKSC_JUDGMENT_72,R_9_28_THE_GOVERNMENT,R_9_31_ACCOUNT] :
      ( the_first_question(R_9_1_THE_FIRST_QUESTION)
      & therefore(R_9_5_THEREFORE)
      & the_Prime_Minister_apos_s(R_9_9_THE_PRIME_MINISTER_APOS_S)
      & constitutional(R_9_22_CONSTITUTIONAL)
      & parliament(R_9_25_PARLIAMENT)
      & the_Government(R_9_28_THE_GOVERNMENT)
      & account(R_9_31_ACCOUNT)
      & is(R_9_7_IS,R_9_1_THE_FIRST_QUESTION,R_9_8_WHETHER_HAD)
      & whether_had(R_9_8_WHETHER_HAD,R_9_13_ACTION,R_9_15_THE_EFFECT)
      & action(R_9_13_ACTION)
      & gen(R_9_13_ACTION,R_9_9_THE_PRIME_MINISTER_APOS_S)
      & the_effect(R_9_15_THE_EFFECT)
      & of(R_9_15_THE_EFFECT,R_9_19_OR)
      & or(R_9_19_OR)
      & conj1(R_9_19_OR,R_9_18_FRUSTRATING)
      & frustrating(R_9_18_FRUSTRATING,Z_9_A_UKSC_JUDGMENT_44,R_9_21_THE_ROLE)
      & the_role(R_9_21_THE_ROLE)
      & attrib58(R_9_21_THE_ROLE,R_9_22_CONSTITUTIONAL)
      & of(R_9_21_THE_ROLE,R_9_25_PARLIAMENT)
      & in(R_9_21_THE_ROLE,R_9_27_HOLDING)
      & holding(R_9_27_HOLDING,Z_9_A_UKSC_JUDGMENT_72,R_9_28_THE_GOVERNMENT)
      & to_clr83(R_9_27_HOLDING,R_9_31_ACCOUNT)
      & conj2(R_9_19_OR,R_9_20_PREVENTING)
      & preventing(R_9_20_PREVENTING,Z_9_A_UKSC_JUDGMENT_44,R_9_21_THE_ROLE)
      & nim11(R_9_7_IS,R_9_5_THEREFORE) ) ).


n9_a_uksc_judgment n9_a_uksc_judgment_4 The n9_a_uksc_judgment_6 first n9_a_uksc_judgment_8 question n9_a_uksc_judgment_10 , n9_a_uksc_judgment_13 therefore n9_a_uksc_judgment_15 , n9_a_uksc_judgment_17 is n9_a_uksc_judgment_21 whether n9_a_uksc_judgment_25 the n9_a_uksc_judgment_27 Prime n9_a_uksc_judgment_29 Minister n9_a_uksc_judgment_31 's n9_a_uksc_judgment_33 action n9_a_uksc_judgment_35 had n9_a_uksc_judgment_38 the n9_a_uksc_judgment_40 effect n9_a_uksc_judgment_43 of n9_a_uksc_judgment_48 frustrating n9_a_uksc_judgment_51 or n9_a_uksc_judgment_54 preventing n9_a_uksc_judgment_57 the n9_a_uksc_judgment_60 constitutional n9_a_uksc_judgment_62 role n9_a_uksc_judgment_65 of n9_a_uksc_judgment_68 Parliament n9_a_uksc_judgment_71 in n9_a_uksc_judgment_74 holding n9_a_uksc_judgment_77 the n9_a_uksc_judgment_79 Government n9_a_uksc_judgment_82 to n9_a_uksc_judgment_85 account n9_a_uksc_judgment_87 . n9_a_uksc_judgment_1 IP-MAT n9_a_uksc_judgment_2 NP-SBJ n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_2 n9_a_uksc_judgment_9 PUNC n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_9 n9_a_uksc_judgment_11 ADVP-NIM n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_11 n9_a_uksc_judgment_14 PUNC n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_14 n9_a_uksc_judgment_16 BEP;_equ_Vw_ n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_16 n9_a_uksc_judgment_18 CP-QUE-PRD n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_18 n9_a_uksc_judgment_86 PUNC n9_a_uksc_judgment_1->n9_a_uksc_judgment_86 n9_a_uksc_judgment_3 D n9_a_uksc_judgment_2->n9_a_uksc_judgment_3 n9_a_uksc_judgment_5 NUM n9_a_uksc_judgment_2->n9_a_uksc_judgment_5 n9_a_uksc_judgment_7 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_2->n9_a_uksc_judgment_7 n9_a_uksc_judgment_3->n9_a_uksc_judgment_4 n9_a_uksc_judgment_5->n9_a_uksc_judgment_6 n9_a_uksc_judgment_7->n9_a_uksc_judgment_8 n9_a_uksc_judgment_9->n9_a_uksc_judgment_10 n9_a_uksc_judgment_12 ADV n9_a_uksc_judgment_11->n9_a_uksc_judgment_12 n9_a_uksc_judgment_12->n9_a_uksc_judgment_13 n9_a_uksc_judgment_14->n9_a_uksc_judgment_15 n9_a_uksc_judgment_16->n9_a_uksc_judgment_17 n9_a_uksc_judgment_19 IP-SUB n9_a_uksc_judgment_18->n9_a_uksc_judgment_19 n9_a_uksc_judgment_20 WQ n9_a_uksc_judgment_19->n9_a_uksc_judgment_20 n9_a_uksc_judgment_22 NP-SBJ n9_a_uksc_judgment_19->n9_a_uksc_judgment_22 n9_a_uksc_judgment_34 HVD;_Tn_ n9_a_uksc_judgment_19->n9_a_uksc_judgment_34 n9_a_uksc_judgment_36 NP-OB1 n9_a_uksc_judgment_19->n9_a_uksc_judgment_36 n9_a_uksc_judgment_20->n9_a_uksc_judgment_21 n9_a_uksc_judgment_23 NP-GEN n9_a_uksc_judgment_22->n9_a_uksc_judgment_23 n9_a_uksc_judgment_32 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_22->n9_a_uksc_judgment_32 n9_a_uksc_judgment_24 D n9_a_uksc_judgment_23->n9_a_uksc_judgment_24 n9_a_uksc_judgment_26 NPR n9_a_uksc_judgment_23->n9_a_uksc_judgment_26 n9_a_uksc_judgment_28 NPR n9_a_uksc_judgment_23->n9_a_uksc_judgment_28 n9_a_uksc_judgment_30 GENM n9_a_uksc_judgment_23->n9_a_uksc_judgment_30 n9_a_uksc_judgment_24->n9_a_uksc_judgment_25 n9_a_uksc_judgment_26->n9_a_uksc_judgment_27 n9_a_uksc_judgment_28->n9_a_uksc_judgment_29 n9_a_uksc_judgment_30->n9_a_uksc_judgment_31 n9_a_uksc_judgment_32->n9_a_uksc_judgment_33 n9_a_uksc_judgment_34->n9_a_uksc_judgment_35 n9_a_uksc_judgment_37 D n9_a_uksc_judgment_36->n9_a_uksc_judgment_37 n9_a_uksc_judgment_39 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_36->n9_a_uksc_judgment_39 n9_a_uksc_judgment_41 PP n9_a_uksc_judgment_36->n9_a_uksc_judgment_41 n9_a_uksc_judgment_37->n9_a_uksc_judgment_38 n9_a_uksc_judgment_39->n9_a_uksc_judgment_40 n9_a_uksc_judgment_42 P-ROLE n9_a_uksc_judgment_41->n9_a_uksc_judgment_42 n9_a_uksc_judgment_44 IP-PPL n9_a_uksc_judgment_41->n9_a_uksc_judgment_44 n9_a_uksc_judgment_42->n9_a_uksc_judgment_43 n9_a_uksc_judgment_45 ILYR n9_a_uksc_judgment_44->n9_a_uksc_judgment_45 n9_a_uksc_judgment_55 NP-OB1 n9_a_uksc_judgment_44->n9_a_uksc_judgment_55 n9_a_uksc_judgment_46 ILYR n9_a_uksc_judgment_45->n9_a_uksc_judgment_46 n9_a_uksc_judgment_49 CONJP n9_a_uksc_judgment_45->n9_a_uksc_judgment_49 n9_a_uksc_judgment_47 VAG;_Tn_ n9_a_uksc_judgment_46->n9_a_uksc_judgment_47 n9_a_uksc_judgment_47->n9_a_uksc_judgment_48 n9_a_uksc_judgment_50 CONJ n9_a_uksc_judgment_49->n9_a_uksc_judgment_50 n9_a_uksc_judgment_52 ILYR n9_a_uksc_judgment_49->n9_a_uksc_judgment_52 n9_a_uksc_judgment_50->n9_a_uksc_judgment_51 n9_a_uksc_judgment_53 VAG;_Tn_ n9_a_uksc_judgment_52->n9_a_uksc_judgment_53 n9_a_uksc_judgment_53->n9_a_uksc_judgment_54 n9_a_uksc_judgment_56 D n9_a_uksc_judgment_55->n9_a_uksc_judgment_56 n9_a_uksc_judgment_58 ADJP n9_a_uksc_judgment_55->n9_a_uksc_judgment_58 n9_a_uksc_judgment_61 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_55->n9_a_uksc_judgment_61 n9_a_uksc_judgment_63 PP n9_a_uksc_judgment_55->n9_a_uksc_judgment_63 n9_a_uksc_judgment_69 PP n9_a_uksc_judgment_55->n9_a_uksc_judgment_69 n9_a_uksc_judgment_56->n9_a_uksc_judgment_57 n9_a_uksc_judgment_59 ADJ n9_a_uksc_judgment_58->n9_a_uksc_judgment_59 n9_a_uksc_judgment_59->n9_a_uksc_judgment_60 n9_a_uksc_judgment_61->n9_a_uksc_judgment_62 n9_a_uksc_judgment_64 P-ROLE n9_a_uksc_judgment_63->n9_a_uksc_judgment_64 n9_a_uksc_judgment_66 NP n9_a_uksc_judgment_63->n9_a_uksc_judgment_66 n9_a_uksc_judgment_64->n9_a_uksc_judgment_65 n9_a_uksc_judgment_67 NPR n9_a_uksc_judgment_66->n9_a_uksc_judgment_67 n9_a_uksc_judgment_67->n9_a_uksc_judgment_68 n9_a_uksc_judgment_70 P-ROLE n9_a_uksc_judgment_69->n9_a_uksc_judgment_70 n9_a_uksc_judgment_72 IP-PPL n9_a_uksc_judgment_69->n9_a_uksc_judgment_72 n9_a_uksc_judgment_70->n9_a_uksc_judgment_71 n9_a_uksc_judgment_73 VAG;_Tn.pr_ n9_a_uksc_judgment_72->n9_a_uksc_judgment_73 n9_a_uksc_judgment_75 NP-OB1 n9_a_uksc_judgment_72->n9_a_uksc_judgment_75 n9_a_uksc_judgment_80 PP-CLR n9_a_uksc_judgment_72->n9_a_uksc_judgment_80 n9_a_uksc_judgment_73->n9_a_uksc_judgment_74 n9_a_uksc_judgment_76 D n9_a_uksc_judgment_75->n9_a_uksc_judgment_76 n9_a_uksc_judgment_78 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_75->n9_a_uksc_judgment_78 n9_a_uksc_judgment_76->n9_a_uksc_judgment_77 n9_a_uksc_judgment_78->n9_a_uksc_judgment_79 n9_a_uksc_judgment_81 P-ROLE n9_a_uksc_judgment_80->n9_a_uksc_judgment_81 n9_a_uksc_judgment_83 NP n9_a_uksc_judgment_80->n9_a_uksc_judgment_83 n9_a_uksc_judgment_81->n9_a_uksc_judgment_82 n9_a_uksc_judgment_84 N n9_a_uksc_judgment_83->n9_a_uksc_judgment_84 n9_a_uksc_judgment_84->n9_a_uksc_judgment_85 n9_a_uksc_judgment_86->n9_a_uksc_judgment_87 
( (IP-MAT (NP-SBJ (D The;{the})
                  (NUM first;{first})
                  (N question;{question}))
          (PUNC ,)
          (ADVP-NIM (ADV therefore;{therefore}))
          (PUNC ,)
          (BEP;_equ_Vw_ is;{be})
          (CP-QUE-PRD (IP-SUB (WQ whether;{whether})
                              (NP-SBJ;{PROROGATION} (NP-GEN (D the;{the})
                                                            (NPR Prime;{Prime})
                                                            (NPR Minister;{Minister})
                                                            (GENM <apos>s))
                                                    (N action;{action}))
                              (HVD;_Tn_ had;{have})
                              (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                      (N effect;{effect})
                                      (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                          (IP-PPL (ILYR (ILYR (VAG;_Tn_ frustrating;{frustrate}))
                                                        (CONJP (CONJ or;{or})
                                                               (ILYR (VAG;_Tn_ preventing;{prevent}))))
                                                  (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                          (ADJP (ADJ constitutional;{constitutional}))
                                                          (N role;{role})
                                                          (PP (P-ROLE of;{of})
                                                              (NP;{PARLIAMENT} (NPR Parliament;{Parliament})))
                                                          (PP (P-ROLE in;{in})
                                                              (IP-PPL (VAG;_Tn.pr_ holding;{hold[to]})
                                                                      (NP-OB1 (D the;{the})
                                                                              (N Government;{government}))
                                                                      (PP-CLR (P-ROLE to;{to})
                                                                              (NP (N account;{account})))))))))))
          (PUNC .))
  (ID 9_a_uksc_judgment))